User: powerpete69, Location: Northeast, Ohio
Asked on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 7:50 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 3, 2025 at 1:42 pm EDT
Question: At what resistance level should 5 KV shielded cables be replaced when meggering?I've read some things that say if you get below 1500 mega-ohms on any phase, replace cable.I've read other things they say you can push it to 100 mega-ohms?I've also read you need 1 mega ohm per thousand volts. So in this case, 5 Mega Ohms should be okay.Personally, I've seen cable short circuit at 800 Mega ohms.My actual cable in question has the following megger measurements from phase to ground:Phase A: 1.8 Giga ohmsPhase B: 40 Mega-ohmsPhase C: 90 Mega-ohmsTo me, this is a replace cable ASAP situation.Also, they do VLF/Tan delta tests as well which requires 7,000 volts compared to 1,000 volts for megger test.My electrician skipped the VLF/Tan delta test because he said we would likely blow up a cable with less than 100 mega-ohms on it if you put 7,000 volts across it.Anyways, does anyone have any solid info on this from their experience?
You've hit upon the frustrating reality: there isn't a single, universally agreed-upon "replace now" megohmmeter reading for shielded 5 kV cable. It's a judgment call based on several factors, with no absolute, definitive answer.Here's a breakdown of the factors at play and how to interpret your readings
Factors Influencing Interpretation:
Cable Type & Age
The type of insulation (e.g., XLPE, EPR) and the age of the cable significantly impact insulation resistance. Older cables, even with good insulation, will naturally have lower readings than new cables.
Environmental Conditions
Temperature and humidity strongly affect megohmmeter readings. Higher temperatures and humidity will lower the readings. Always record temperature and humidity when taking measurements.
Cable Length
Longer cables have more insulation surface area, which leads to lower resistance readings. A short run of cable might show a high reading, while a longer run of the same cable type might show a lower reading.
Application
How critical is the circuit? A cable feeding a critical life-safety system has a lower tolerance for degradation than a cable feeding a non-essential load.
Manufacturer's Recommendations
Ideally, consult the cable manufacturer's specifications for recommended megohmmeter values. This is the most reliable guideline. Often, this data is difficult to obtain for older cables.
Trend Analysis
This is the most important factor. A single megohmmeter reading is less valuable than tracking readings over time. A sudden drop in insulation resistance is a red flag, even if the absolute value is still above a nominal threshold.
Industry Standards
While not universally enforced, some industry standards like IEEE 400 (Recommended Practice for Field Testing and Evaluation of the Insulation of Shielded Power Cable Systems) provide guidance, though they rarely give specific "replace" numbers.
Diagnostic Testing
As you mentioned, VLF and Tan Delta testing can provide a more in-depth assessment of the insulation's condition, identifying localized weaknesses that a simple megohmmeter test might miss. Partial Discharge testing is also another very good method.
Experience
Experienced technicians develop a sense of what's "normal" for specific cable types in specific environments based on years of data collection.
Debunking Common Rules of Thumb
1 Megaohm per 1000 Volts
This is a very general rule of thumb and should not be used as a definitive pass/fail criterion for shielded power cables. It's better suited for unshielded wiring. For shielded cables, this is extremely conservative.
100 Megaohms Minimum
While 100 megaohms might indicate some level of insulation integrity, it's still too low for 5kV shielded cable, especially when other phases have much higher readings.
1500 Megaohms Minimum
This is also a potentially conservative number, but definitely more in line with a solid, healthy shielded cable reading.
Analyzing Your Readings
Phase A: 1.8 Gigaohms
This is a very good reading, suggesting that the insulation on this phase is in excellent condition.
Phase B: 40 Megaohms
This is significantly lower than Phase A and Phase C. This reading is concerning and warrants further investigation.
Phase C: 90 Megaohms
This is also lower than Phase A but somewhat higher than Phase B. Still, it's low enough to cause concern, especially in relation to Phase A.
Your Assessment is Correct: This is a Replace Cable ASAP Situation
Based solely on these megohmmeter readings, especially the large discrepancies between phases, you are absolutely correct to consider this a replace-ASAP situation. The difference between Phase A and Phases B & C is alarming. This is not a situation to "wait and see." Something is deteriorating.
Why Your Electrician Was Correct About VLF
Your electrician made a wise decision to skip the VLF/Tan Delta test at this point. Applying 7 kV to a cable with insulation already showing signs of weakness (40 and 90 megaohms) could very likely lead to a breakdown and potentially damage the cable further, as he stated. The VLF test is better suited for preventative maintenance on cables that are still within acceptable megohmmeter ranges.
Recommended Actions
Immediate Action
De-energize the cable and isolate it. Do not rely on this cable to carry load.2.
Visual Inspection
Carefully inspect the cable for any signs of physical damage, such as cuts, abrasions, or swelling of the insulation. Pay close attention to terminations and splices.3.
Investigate Terminations
Carefully examine the cable terminations. A failing termination can cause the cable insulation to deteriorate. Partial Discharge at a termination can wreak havoc on the cable.4.
Review Historical Data
Check if there are any previous megohmmeter readings for this cable. This is crucial for trend analysis. If the readings on Phases B and C have been steadily declining, that confirms your assessment.5.
Consider Cable Sectioning
If you're dealing with a long cable run and suspect a localized problem, you might be able to isolate the fault by sectioning the cable and testing each section individually. This can save the cost of replacing the entire run.6.
Partial Discharge Testing
Although the electrician said he did not want to put 7,000 volts on the cable, there are Partial Discharge testing units that can measure PD at lower voltages without damaging the insulation.7.
Replace the Cable
Given the low readings and the significant differences between phases, the safest and most prudent course of action is to replace the cable.
Important Considerations
Root Cause Analysis
Don't just replace the cable and walk away. Identify why the cable failed. Was it due to age, environmental factors, improper installation, voltage surges, or a manufacturing defect? Addressing the root cause will prevent future failures.*
Documentation: Meticulously document all test results, observations, and actions taken. This will be valuable for future troubleshooting and maintenance.In summary, while there's no single "magic number," your assessment of a "replace ASAP" situation is correct based on the substantial discrepancies in your megohmmeter readings. Don't delay – take action to ensure safety and prevent a potential outage. Prioritize replacing the cable, and then investigate the root cause to prevent future issues. Flag for review