User: zemingduan, Location: Philadelphia,PA
Asked on: Thursday, September 4, 2025 at 2:24 pm EDT
Answered on: Saturday, September 6, 2025 at 12:13 pm EDT
Question: We have a single phase 200A service for the house panel which feed the 20HP 208V 3ph elevator with 65.4 FLA and 311 LRA. We feed the elevator through the 50HP phase converter (American Rotary AUL - 50) and 30KVA 240V - 208V 3ph transformer. See below single line diagram. The phase converter is sized 2.5 times the motor horsepower for the inrush starting current. The transformer is sized to 125% of the elevator full load amps.However during testing, the elevator company guy states the voltage drop at the elevator starter during the starting is too large and not acceptable. I think both the converter and transformer sizing are good. Any ideas and solutions?
Okay, let's break down this problem and troubleshoot the voltage drop issue at the elevator starter during starting. It's good you've already considered the sizing of the phase converter and transformer. Here's a systematic approach to identifying and addressing the voltage drop
1. Verify Your Calculations and Assumptions:
Phase Converter Sizing
You stated it's 2.5 times the motor HP. That's a common rule of thumb, but confirm with American Rotary's documentation for your specific model (AUL-50). Sometimes, they have application-specific recommendations. Make sure the AUL-50 is rated for the elevator application (frequent starts, potentially high load, etc.).
Transformer Sizing
You're using 125% of the elevator FLA (65.4A). Calculate the kVA: `65.4A 208V sqrt(3) / 1000 = 23.5 kVA`. A 30 kVA transformer seems correctly sized, but confirm this is after considering your phase converter needs.
Cable/Wire Sizing
This is the MOST LIKELY culprit! What size conductors are you using from the 200A service to the phase converter, from the phase converter to the transformer, and from the transformer to the elevator starter? Voltage drop is highly dependent on conductor length and ampacity.
Distance/Length
Carefully measure the distance of EACH run (service to converter, converter to transformer, transformer to elevator). Longer runs exacerbate voltage drop.
Elevation
Is the voltage drop during the startup within limits at the control panel of the elevator. If so, then the voltage drop is occurring between the controller and the motor.
2. Analyze the System Piece by Piece
A. Incoming Service to Phase Converter
Measurement: Measure the voltage at the input terminals of the phase converter
during elevator starting. Is the incoming voltage from the 200A service dropping significantly? If so, the issue is upstream of your equipment and points to potential utility issues or inadequate service entrance wiring. Solution: If the incoming voltage is sagging, contact the utility company. Upgrading the service to a larger capacity or requesting voltage stabilization equipment from the utility may be necessary. Also, inspect your service entrance conductors and connections for any issues. B. Phase Converter Output
Measurement: Measure the 3-phase voltage at the output terminals of the phase converter
during elevator starting. Is the voltage stable? Is the output voltage balanced between the phases? An unbalanced voltage can severely affect motor performance and exacerbate voltage drop. Solution: If the phase converter output is sagging significantly or unbalanced, it could indicate a problem with the phase converter itself. Contact American Rotary's technical support to troubleshoot the phase converter. Confirm the phase converter is set up correctly (dip switches, input voltage settings, etc.). C. Transformer Output
Measurement: Measure the 3-phase 208V voltage at the output terminals of the transformer
during elevator starting. How much voltage drop is occurring across the transformer? Solution: A properly sized and functioning transformer shouldn't contribute excessive voltage drop if the input voltage is stable. If the transformer is overheating or making unusual noises, it could indicate a problem with the transformer itself (rare, but possible). D. Transformer Output to Elevator Starter
Measurement: Measure the voltage at the elevator starter terminals
during starting. This is where you're already seeing the problem, but now you need to correlate it with the other measurements. Solution: If the voltage is dropping significantly between the transformer and the elevator starter, the problem is almost certainly the conductor size or length.3. Conductor Sizing - The Most Likely Culprit
Voltage Drop Calculation
Use a voltage drop calculator (online, or in the NEC Annex C) to calculate the expected voltage drop for your conductor size, length, and the elevator's inrush current (311 LRA). Important Considerations:
Conductor Material
Copper has lower voltage drop than aluminum.
Temperature Correction
If the conductors are in a hot environment, you may need to derate their ampacity and recalculate voltage drop.
Acceptable Voltage Drop
The NEC recommends limiting voltage drop to 3% for feeders and 5% total (feeder + branch circuit). However, elevator manufacturers often have stricter requirements. Find out the elevator manufacturer's acceptable voltage drop limit at the starter during starting. This is CRITICAL.
Upgrading Conductors
If the voltage drop calculation shows excessive drop, you'll need to increase the conductor size. Consider parallel conductors if necessary.
Check Connections
Ensure all connections are clean, tight, and properly made. Loose connections can create resistance and contribute to voltage drop.
4. Specific Solutions Based on Findings
If the problem is inadequate service
Upgrade the service entrance.
If the problem is the phase converter
Contact American Rotary for troubleshooting or replacement.
If the problem is the transformer
Inspect for damage, overheating, or internal faults. Consider a transformer with lower impedance if necessary (though this is less common).
If the problem is the conductors
Increase the conductor size and/or shorten the run.
5. Other Considerations
Power Factor Correction
While probably not the primary issue, consider adding power factor correction capacitors at the elevator motor. This can improve the system's overall efficiency and reduce the current draw, potentially mitigating voltage drop. This is unlikely the primary cause as the LRA already incorporates the power factor component.
Soft Starter
A soft starter can dramatically reduce the inrush current (LRA) of the elevator motor. This will significantly lessen the voltage drop during starting. This is the most ideal solution.
Autotransformer Starter
Like soft starters, autotransformer starters reduce the voltage applied to the motor at starting by reducing the inrush current.
Example Voltage Drop Calculation (Illustrative - You MUST Use Your Specific Values)
Let's say you have a 100-foot run of #2 AWG copper wire from the transformer to the elevator starter. The elevator's LRA is 311 amps. Using a voltage drop calculator: Voltage Drop (Approximate): 14.5 Volts (line-to-line) Percentage Voltage Drop: (14.5V / 208V) 100% = 7%This 7% voltage drop is likely unacceptable, especially if the elevator manufacturer has a stricter limit. You would need to increase the conductor size to reduce the voltage drop to an acceptable level.
Action Plan
Gather Data
Get precise conductor sizes, lengths, and voltage readings at each point (service, converter input/output, transformer input/output, elevator starter) during elevator starting.2.
Voltage Drop Calculations
Perform accurate voltage drop calculations based on your specific data and the elevator's LRA.3.
Check Connections
Inspect all connections for tightness and cleanliness.4.
Compare to Elevator Manufacturer's Requirements
Find out the acceptable voltage drop limit specified by the elevator manufacturer.5.
Implement Solutions: Based on your findings, implement the appropriate solutions (upgrade conductors, fix connections, replace equipment, etc.).By systematically investigating each part of the system and performing accurate calculations, you should be able to pinpoint the cause of the voltage drop and implement an effective solution. Good luck! Flag for review