User: ptonsparky, Location: NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)
Asked on: Saturday, September 6, 2025 at 9:12 am EDT
Answered on: Saturday, September 6, 2025 at 12:16 pm EDT
Question: Shop learning project.I have braking resistors I've salvaged from scrap drives. One set of parallel 62 ohm have a small contactor that can short them. Go from 31 ohm to 0.Why is that done? Instant stop?
You've stumbled upon a common and clever technique used in variable frequency drive (VFD) braking systems. Here's why a contactor is used to short out a portion of the braking resistor
Understanding Braking Resistors in VFDs
First, a quick recap: Regenerative Braking
When an AC motor controlled by a VFD decelerates rapidly, it acts as a generator, feeding energy back into the VFD.
DC Bus Overvoltage
This regenerative energy increases the voltage on the VFD's DC bus. If the voltage exceeds a certain threshold, the VFD will trip and shut down to protect itself.
Braking Resistor Solution
A braking resistor (also called a dynamic braking resistor) is connected to the DC bus via a braking transistor (IGBT). When the DC bus voltage rises too high, the VFD turns on the braking transistor, which dissipates the excess energy as heat in the resistor.
Why Short Out Part of the Resistor? Two-Stage Braking
The contactor arrangement you described (shorting out part of the resistor) is likely implementing a two-stage braking system. The purpose is to provide more efficient and controllable braking, and it often serves these purposes:1. High Initial Braking Power (Fast Deceleration)
When braking is initiated, the contactor is open, and the full resistance (31 ohms in your example) is in the circuit. This lower resistance results in a higher braking current and therefore higher braking torque (energy dissipation). This is ideal for quickly reducing the motor speed from a high value.2.
Reduced Braking Power (Controlled Deceleration and Avoiding Overheating)
As the motor slows down, the regenerative energy decreases. If the full braking resistance (31 ohms) were maintained, the braking torque might become too strong at lower speeds, potentially causing jerky stops or even mechanical stress. More importantly, with a high resistance at lower speeds, the energy dissipated in the resistor may be low enough that the bus voltage remains high. By shorting out part of the resistance, the drive can continue to dump the remaining energy to the resistor. After a delay, or when the motor reaches a certain speed or DC bus voltage threshold, the VFD closes the contactor, effectively shorting out part of the resistor. Now, the resistance drops to nearly 0 ohms for the bypassed section (and you are left with 0 ohms overall). This reduces the braking power, allowing for a smoother stop and preventing the resistor from overheating.
Analogy
Think of it like applying the brakes in a car:
Initial Hard Braking
You slam on the brakes for maximum stopping power when you need to stop quickly from high speed. (Full resistance)
Gradual Deceleration
As you slow down, you ease off the brakes to avoid locking the wheels and provide a smoother stop. (Reduced resistance)
Advantages of Two-Stage Braking
Faster Deceleration
Gets you to a stop quicker.
Smoother Stops
Avoids jerking or abrupt stops.
Reduced Resistor Overheating
By reducing the braking power as the motor slows, you prevent the resistor from getting excessively hot. This is especially important in applications with frequent or prolonged braking.
More Efficient Use of Resistor
Better match the braking power to the regenerative energy.
Is it an "Instant Stop"?
While two-stage braking provides faster deceleration, it's rarely a true "instant stop." Inertia and the motor's inherent characteristics will still dictate the minimum stopping time. The two-stage system primarily aims to control the deceleration rate, not necessarily to achieve the absolute fastest possible stop. It can allow for a very rapid stop, but only within the motor and mechanical system's capabilities.
Important Considerations
VFD Programming
The VFD must be programmed correctly to manage the braking resistor and the contactor. Parameters like the braking resistance value, the DC bus voltage threshold, and the delay before engaging the contactor are crucial.
Resistor Power Rating
The braking resistor(s) must be adequately sized to handle the peak braking power and the duty cycle of the braking application. Incorrect sizing can lead to overheating and failure.
Contactor Reliability
The contactor must be rated for the voltage and current it will be switching, and it must be a reliable device capable of frequent operation.
Safety: Braking resistors generate significant heat. Ensure they are properly mounted and cooled to prevent fire hazards or burns.In summary, the contactor shorting a portion of your braking resistor is a clever technique to optimize braking performance, balancing speed, smoothness, and thermal management. Understanding the principles of regenerative braking and two-stage braking will help you troubleshoot and maintain VFD systems effectively. Flag for review