Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: SCCR FOR CONTROL PANEL WITH SERVO DRIVES

User: tom@tsl, Location: washington state

Asked on: Monday, September 8, 2025 at 3:00 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, September 8, 2025 at 3:06 pm EDT

Question: I have a customer that is wanting an sccr rating of 45ka. The issue is the Yaskawa drives lowering the rating to 35ka. Speaking with Yaskawa, I can use a different fuse that would bring this to 42ka.Question, other than an isolation transformer, how can I raise the overll SCCR rating? Can I put a branch disconnect in front of the drive fuses??? Would this circuit now be rated at the kva of the disconnect???Feeder Circuit​

Let's break down how to increase the SCCR of your system with Yaskawa drives, focusing on solutions beyond an isolation transformer, and address the effectiveness of a branch disconnect.

Understanding SCCR and its Limitations SCCR (Short-Circuit Current Rating)

This is the maximum fault current (kA) a component or assembly can withstand without causing a fire or electrical hazard. The
lowest SCCR in a series-connected circuit determines the overall system SCCR. This is crucial. A "weak link" limits everything.

Yaskawa Drive Limitation

The drives themselves are the weak link, rated for 35kA (or potentially 42kA with the new fuse option).

Options to Increase SCCR (Beyond Isolation Transformers)
1. Series Reactors/Inductors (AC Line Reactors): How They Work

Reactors add impedance to the circuit, limiting the fault current that can reach the drive. Think of them as electrical chokes.


Placement

Install upstream (before) of the Yaskawa drive(s). They can be placed right before the drive's fuses if that's the design.

Sizing

This is critical. You need to select a reactor with an impedance that will reduce the fault current at the drive to a level below its SCCR. Consult with the reactor manufacturer and an engineer experienced in SCCR calculations. Consider factors like:
Available fault current at the point of installation (the "infinite bus" kA). The drive's input voltage and current requirements. The desired SCCR (45kA in your case).

Considerations

Reactors introduce voltage drop during normal operation. You'll need to account for this and potentially adjust transformer taps or other settings to compensate. Reactors generate heat. Ensure proper ventilation. They add cost and space to your installation.

Important

Reactors do
not change the component ratings downstream. They simply reduce the available fault current.2.

Current Limiting Fuses (Upstream)
: How They Work

Specialized fuses are designed to interrupt fault currents very quickly and significantly limit the let-through current (the amount of current that passes through the fuse before it clears). They are often referred to as "current limiting" fuses.

Placement

Install
upstream of the Yaskawa drive's branch circuit protection (the fuses Yaskawa specifies). They protect the entire branch circuit downstream, including the drive.

Selection

Choose fuses with a low let-through current (I2t) rating. This is the key parameter. The goal is to select fuses such that the let-through current to the Yaskawa drive is below the drive's SCCR.

Considerations

Current-limiting fuses are more expensive than standard fuses. They may require larger enclosures due to their physical size. You must coordinate the fuses with the upstream and downstream protection. Selective coordination is crucial to prevent nuisance tripping. This requires careful engineering analysis.

Important

This only protects the components downstream.3.

Combine Reactors and Current-Limiting Fuses

In some cases, a combination of reactors and current-limiting fuses may be the most cost-effective and technically feasible solution. The reactor reduces the fault current, and the current-limiting fuses provide the final level of protection.4.

Drive-Specific SCCR Solutions



Consult Yaskawa Engineering

Beyond the fuse change, ask Yaskawa if they offer any other tested and documented solutions for increasing the SCCR of their drives. They may have specific configurations or external components they recommend.


SCCR Kits

Some manufacturers provide pre-engineered SCCR kits that include the drive, fuses, and other components necessary to achieve a specific SCCR rating.

Can a Branch Disconnect Increase the SCCR?
No, a branch disconnect alone cannot increase the SCCR of the circuit downstream. Reasoning

A disconnect switch is primarily an isolation device. It simply opens and closes the circuit. It does not limit current. A disconnect switch has its own SCCR, but it doesn't provide any overcurrent protection. It will do nothing to stop the current from reaching your drive that only has a 35/42 KA sccr rating.

Does Adding a Branch Disconnect In Front Change the Circuit Rating to the Disconnect's kA?
* Absolutely not. The overall system SCCR is still limited by the weakest link. If your Yaskawa drive is rated for 35kA (or 42kA with the new fuses), the circuit's SCCR cannot exceed that value, regardless of the disconnect's rating.

In summary


Assess the Available Fault Current

Calculate (or have an engineer calculate) the available fault current at the point of connection to your feeder circuit. This is the starting point.2.

Calculate the Required Impedance

Determine the impedance needed from a reactor to reduce the fault current to below the drive's SCCR.3.

Fuse Selection

If using current-limiting fuses, select fuses with a let-through current low enough to protect the drive. Perform fuse coordination studies.4.

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of all components used, SCCR ratings, calculations, and testing performed. This is essential for compliance and future maintenance.5.

Consult Professionals:
Given the complexity of SCCR coordination, it's highly recommended to work with a qualified electrical engineer and your Yaskawa representative to ensure a safe and compliant installation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question