User: Nguyen Ho, Location: Bellevue
Asked on: Wednesday, September 10, 2025 at 12:41 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 10, 2025 at 12:46 pm EDT
Question: I am currently working on an arc flash study and need the infomation for one of the Square D breaker that has been disconntinued. Really appreciate if anyone could share the breaker datasheet or anything that will help me creating an Etap model for this breaker.Breaker: Square D ML-1, ML-3 (or 997316, etc)Regards,
You're right, finding reliable data for discontinued breakers can be tricky. The Square D ML-1 and ML-3 series are definitely older models. Here's a breakdown of what you need and how to find it, along with what to look for in lieu of a perfect datasheet
What You Need for Etap Modeling (Specifically for Arc Flash):
The most crucial parameters for accurate arc flash calculations in ETAP for a breaker are:1. Interrupting Rating (kA)
This is the maximum fault current the breaker can safely interrupt. This is critical for arc flash hazard calculations.2.
Clearing Time (cycles or milliseconds)
How long does it take for the breaker to open under a fault condition? This has a HUGE impact on arc flash energy. You're looking for the total clearing time, including both sensing and tripping.3.
Time-Current Curves (TCC)
These curves show the operating characteristics of the breaker. They plot current on the x-axis against time on the y-axis. You need these to determine the clearing time for various fault current levels.4.
Voltage Rating (V)
The nominal system voltage the breaker is designed for (e.g., 480V, 600V).5.
Continuous Current Rating (Amps)
The normal current the breaker is designed to carry continuously without overheating. While not directly used in arc flash calculations, it's essential to ensure the breaker is properly sized for the load.6.
Number of Poles
(e.g., 3-pole).
Where to Find the Information
Square D/Schneider Electric (Most Likely Source)
Historical Document Archive
Schneider Electric might have some older documents in their archive. Contact their technical support directly. Be prepared to provide the specific catalog number (like 997316) if you have it. Explain you're doing an arc flash study and need the interrupting rating and time-current curves. This may require some patience.
Local Square D/Schneider Electric Distributor
Experienced distributors may have access to older product information or know-how. They might have application guides or internal resources.
Used Equipment Dealers / Breaker Recyclers
Companies that specialize in selling used and refurbished circuit breakers sometimes have original documentation or can perform testing to determine the breaker's characteristics. Search online for "used circuit breakers" or "circuit breaker recycling." Examples include: National Switchgear Industrial Circuit Breaker Services (ICBS) Gator Breaker Be very careful using data from these sources. Verify the information as much as possible.
Engineering Firms/Consultants
Other engineering firms that have worked on similar projects in the past might have this information in their archives. It's a long shot, but worth considering if you're stuck.
Online Forums/Communities
Power engineering forums (like Eng-Tips, IEEE forums) can be helpful. Post a clear, concise request for information, including the breaker details and what you need for your arc flash study. Someone might have encountered this breaker before.
Existing Electrical Drawings/One-Line Diagrams
Check the existing drawings for the facility where the breaker is installed. Sometimes the interrupting rating is listed directly on the drawing.
Nameplate Information (If Accessible)
The nameplate on the breaker itself might have the interrupting rating and voltage rating. However, it usually won't have the time-current curves.
Important Safety Note
Only qualified personnel should access electrical equipment.
If You Can't Find the Exact Datasheet
This is the most likely scenario. Here's how to proceed:1.
"Similar" Breaker Data
Look for time-current curves for similar Square D breakers from the same era (e.g., other ML-series breakers, or breakers with similar voltage and current ratings). This is NOT ideal, but it's better than nothing. Document very clearly that you're using estimated data.2.
Worst-Case Scenario (Conservative Approach)
If you cannot find any data, you will have to make very conservative assumptions to ensure safety. This means:
Interrupting Rating
Use the lowest available interrupting rating from other Square D breakers of that voltage and current rating that you can find data for.
Clearing Time
Assume a long clearing time. A general-purpose molded case circuit breaker might have a clearing time of 3-5 cycles (50-83 ms on a 60 Hz system) for high fault currents. For a conservative approach, use 5 cycles (83 ms) or even higher (e.g., 100 ms) if you have no other information. Document your reasoning very clearly.
Coordination Study
This is crucial! Make sure the upstream protective devices are coordinated to clear faults before the assumed clearing time of the breaker in question. This is usually done during the detailed arc flash study.
Important Considerations
Documentation
Thoroughly document everything you do, including where you obtained data, what assumptions you made, and why. This is essential for the validity of your arc flash study and for future reference.
Peer Review
Have another qualified electrical engineer review your work, especially the assumptions you've made.
Limitations
Acknowledge the limitations of the study due to the lack of accurate breaker data. Emphasize the conservative assumptions made to ensure safety.
Field Verification
Consider field testing the breaker (if possible and safe) to verify its operation and clearing time. This can be costly, but it provides the most accurate data. (This is often not practical for discontinued breakers).
Replacement
The best long-term solution is often to replace the obsolete breaker with a modern breaker for which accurate data is readily available.
Example ETAP Input (Based on Hypothetical Data)
Let's say, after much searching, you think the ML-1 has these properties (this is just an example; verify your data!):
Voltage Rating
480V
Continuous Current Rating
100A
Interrupting Rating
14 kA
Clearing Time
Based on a similar breaker's TCC, you estimate 2 cycles (33 ms) at 10 kA fault current.In ETAP:1.
Breaker Library
Create a new breaker model in the ETAP device library.2.
Ratings Tab
Voltage
480V
Current (Ampere Rating)
100A
Interrupting Duty
14 kA3.
TCC Tab
You'll need to enter the time-current curve data. This is the most challenging part. You'll likely have to manually enter data points from a scanned or photographed TCC (if you find one). You can also approximate the curve with a standard breaker curve type (e.g., inverse time, very inverse time) if that's all you have.4.
Trip Unit Settings
If it's an adjustable breaker, enter the tap, time delay, and instantaneous settings based on the existing settings in the field (if available).
Disclaimer:Arc flash studies are complex and should be performed by qualified electrical engineers with experience in power system analysis and arc flash hazard calculations. I am an AI and cannot provide professional engineering advice. This information is for general guidance only. You are solely responsible for the accuracy and safety of your arc flash study.Good luck with your arc flash study! It's a critical aspect of electrical safety. Flag for review