User: SSDriver, Location: California
Asked on: Wednesday, September 10, 2025 at 9:36 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 10, 2025 at 9:37 pm EDT
Question: I'm only talking about the controls in this post.I know I get a lot of voltage spikes when I have larger Contactors open going back to the control circuit. Enough that 120v LED pilot lights flash when the contactors de-energize. I have tried surge suppressors, RC, and varistors mounted on the contactors that do help but not eliminate the issue. They help enough that the LED's don't burnout but you will get a smaller flicker.I have a project that I will have a PLC, HMI, 3 pilot lights, and three 40A contactors. Space is very limited and I was wondering if I could use the same power supply for the contactors, pilot lights, PLC, and HMI. Everything that could run at the same time would be under 40va and I was looking at a 48va Power supply that would work for inrush and space wise as well. Will I run into issues? I was planning on putting some " IronHorse Surge Suppresser, varistor, RC "modules on each contactor. Only 2 would ever open at the same time. I don't use DC contactors that much and wasn't sure if the spike would be worse or better than on an AC circuit.Thanks.
Okay, let's break down the issues and potential solutions regarding sharing a power supply with your contactors, PLC, HMI, and pilot lights, especially given your experience with voltage spikes.
The Core Problem: Back EMF and Voltage Spikes
When a contactor coil de-energizes, the collapsing magnetic field induces a voltage spike back into the circuit. This spike can be significantly higher than your normal operating voltage and is known as back EMF (electromotive force). This is what causes your pilot lights to flicker and can potentially damage sensitive electronic components like your PLC and HMI.
Why Sharing a Power Supply is Risky (Especially Without Careful Mitigation)
Sharing the same power supply for your control circuit (PLC, HMI, pilot lights) and your contactor coils can work, but it makes the voltage spike problem significantly worse. Here's why: Direct Coupling
All the equipment is now directly tied to the voltage spikes. Instead of the spike being isolated (even partially) to the contactor circuit, it now has a direct path to your PLC, HMI, and pilot lights.
Common Mode Noise
Voltage spikes can propagate through the ground conductor, causing noise and potentially disrupting the operation of your PLC and HMI. This can lead to erratic behavior, data corruption, or even component failure.
Power Supply Vulnerability
The power supply itself might not be robust enough to handle these repeated spikes. It could become stressed and eventually fail, or it may exhibit its own voltage fluctuations that affect your connected equipment.
Addressing the Concerns: Mitigation Strategies
Here's a more detailed approach to managing the voltage spikes:1. Suppressor Selection and Placement
RC Snubbers
These are generally effective for reducing the magnitude and rate of voltage spikes. They consist of a resistor and capacitor in series, placed directly across the contactor coil. The values of the resistor and capacitor are important for the voltage you are using.
Varistors (MOVs)
These are voltage-dependent resistors that clamp the voltage to a certain level. They're good for limiting the maximum voltage, but they can degrade over time with repeated surges. Again select the right voltage for your use case.
Surge Suppressors (TVS Diodes)
These can provide fast clamping action, but they typically have lower energy handling capabilities compared to MOVs.Important Placement: The closer you mount the suppression device to the contactor coil, the more effective it will be. This minimizes the loop area for the inductive spike.2.
Power Supply Considerations
Over-Sizing
Consider using a significantly larger power supply than your calculated 48VA. For example, a 100VA or larger supply might provide better stability and headroom to handle the surges. The better the power supply is designed the better it will filter out voltage spikes.
Power Supply Type
Look for a power supply specifically designed for industrial applications. These are typically more robust and have better built-in surge protection and filtering. Meanwell is often a good option, but there are many others.
Power Supply Surge Ratings
Check the surge rating of the power supply itself to see if it is capable of handling the spikes.3.
Isolation
Separate Power Supplies
Ideally, use a separate power supply for the control circuit (PLC, HMI, pilot lights) and the contactor coils. This provides the best isolation and minimizes the risk of voltage spikes affecting your sensitive electronics. This is the most effective but sometimes the most expensive.
Isolation Relays/Optocouplers
If you must share a power supply, consider using isolation relays or optocouplers to isolate the control signals from the contactor coil circuits.4.
Wiring and Grounding
Dedicated Ground
Make sure you have a dedicated, low-impedance ground connection for your equipment. This helps to shunt surge currents to ground and minimize noise.
Shielded Cables
Use shielded cables for sensitive signal lines (e.g., PLC inputs/outputs).
Star Grounding
Implement a star grounding topology, where all ground wires are connected to a single point. This helps to prevent ground loops and circulating currents.
Separate Control Wiring
Keep the control wiring separate from the power wiring for the contactors. Don't run them in the same conduit or cable tray.5.
PLC/HMI Protection
PLC Input/Output Protection
Many PLCs have built-in surge protection on their inputs and outputs. Make sure these are enabled.
External Surge Protection
Consider adding external surge protectors to the PLC and HMI power inputs for added protection.6.
DC vs. AC Contactors
DC Contactors with Flyback Diodes
DC contactors typically have flyback diodes built-in across the coil. These diodes provide a path for the inductive current to flow when the coil is de-energized, which significantly reduces the voltage spike. If you can use DC contactors, the back EMF issue is generally less severe than with AC contactors if they have flyback diodes.
AC Contactors
AC contactors rely on other methods like MOVs or RC snubbers for spike suppression.
Recommendations for Your Project
Strongly consider separate power supplies
Given your space constraints, this might be difficult, but it offers the best protection for your PLC and HMI.2.
Over-size the power supply
If you share a power supply, use a significantly larger one than your calculated requirement (e.g., 100VA or more).3.
Use high-quality industrial-grade power supplies
These are better designed to handle voltage fluctuations and surges.4.
RC Snubbers + Varistors
Use both RC snubbers and varistors directly across each* contactor coil. Pay close attention to the voltage ratings of the varistors.5.
Check Contactors
If you have access to the contactors information sheets you may find that the coils are DC. If they are make sure the flyback diodes are working or add some.6.
Proper Grounding
Implement a robust grounding system with dedicated grounds, shielded cables, and star grounding.7.
Thorough Testing
After installation, thoroughly test the system to ensure that the voltage spikes are adequately suppressed and that the PLC and HMI are functioning correctly. Use an oscilloscope if possible to measure the actual voltage spikes.
In summary: Sharing a power supply is possible but requires careful planning and implementation of appropriate mitigation strategies. The best approach is to use separate power supplies for the control circuit and the contactor coils. If that's not feasible, focus on robust surge suppression, a high-quality over-sized power supply, proper grounding, and thorough testing. Flag for review