User: RickGram, Location: Arkansas
Asked on: Thursday, September 11, 2025 at 6:22 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, September 11, 2025 at 6:22 pm EDT
Question: So circling back on this from the thread I previousl;y started that Roger shut down - not sure why he did that. Roger ?Here is what I figured out.It is not a "lost" neutral, as in, the result of a broken wire, etc.The circuit includes a 4-way switch in the middle of two 3-ways BUT, 12/2 was used for the travelers, not the standard 12/3, so no neutral passing through the middle box that contains the 4-way, hence the need for the "mystrey neutral" to complete the circuit.
Okay, I understand the situation better now. Thanks for clarifying.Let's break this down: The Core Issue
You have a 4-way switch wired in between two 3-way switches in a lighting circuit. The problem is that 12/2 cable was used as travelers between the 3-way switches and the 4-way switch, instead of 12/3. This means there's no neutral wire running to the 4-way switch box.
Why this is a Problem
A proper 4-way switch circuit using 12/3 between switches naturally provides a continuous neutral path back to the panel. By using 12/2, you've interrupted this neutral path at the 4-way switch box. Without a neutral, connected loads have no path to flow. That likely explains the symptom you are having that necessitated your looking into this in the first place.
"Mystery Neutral"
When you say "mystery neutral," I assume you mean someone has tapped into a neutral from another circuit within the 4-way switch box to complete the neutral path for the lighting fixture controlled by this switch arrangement.Here are some considerations and points you'll want to consider:
1. Why This is Bad (and Potentially Dangerous)
Illegal and Code Violation
This is almost certainly a violation of electrical code (NEC). Connecting neutrals from different circuits is generally prohibited.
Overloading the Neutral
Neutrals are sized to carry the unbalanced current of the hot wires they serve. By combining neutrals from different circuits, you risk overloading one of the neutral conductors, which can lead to overheating and fire.
Ghost Voltage/False Readings
Shared neutrals can introduce voltage fluctuations and make troubleshooting other circuits difficult.
Electrocution Hazard
In specific fault conditions, a shared neutral can create a dangerous voltage potential on what would normally be a safe ground.
2. The Right Way to Fix This
Replace the Cable
The correct and safest way to resolve this is to replace the 12/2 cables running to the 4-way switch box with 12/3 cables. This establishes the proper neutral path for the circuit.
Alternative Solution
Depending on the specifics, and in some scenarios this may not be easily possible or practical, you might be able to eliminate the 4-way switch altogether and convert the circuit to use only two 3-way switches. This would require rewiring at the existing 3-way switch locations, and is likely not a desirable solution based on the current functionality.
3. Important Safety Steps
Turn Off the Power
Before doing any electrical work, completely shut off the power to the circuit at the breaker. Verify the power is off with a non-contact voltage tester.
Professional Help
Unless you are very* comfortable and knowledgeable about electrical work, I strongly recommend hiring a qualified electrician. This is a significant safety issue.
In Summary:
You've likely uncovered a dangerous and improperly wired circuit. The "mystery neutral" is a serious red flag. The best course of action is to correct the wiring by replacing the 12/2 with 12/3 between the switches. Safety should be your absolute priority. Do not continue to use the circuit in its current state.Please let me know if you have any other questions. I will do my best to help. Flag for review