Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Question transformer undersized but dont see anything in NEC 2017

User: hhsting, Location: Glen bunie, md, us

Asked on: Thursday, September 11, 2025 at 7:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, September 11, 2025 at 7:30 pm EDT

Question: I have 30kva transformer delta to wye. Primary voltage 380v three phase and secondary voltage 208/120v. Primary breaker is sized 40A and secondary breaker is sized 100A. Wverything is upto NEC 2017 this far.The secondary side total demand amps comes to 99A. It wont trip the secondary 100A breaker but the total demand kvA comes to 99*.208.1.732= 35kva.So question 99A demand wont trip the secondary breaker 100A but wont 30kva transformer be undersized due to 35kva demand load?

Yes, you are correct. Your transformer is theoretically overloaded in terms of kVA demand, even though the secondary breaker isn't tripping. Let's break down why and what to consider

The Problem:
Transformer kVA Rating

Your transformer is rated for 30 kVA. This is its continuous duty rating.


Calculated kVA Demand

Your calculated secondary demand is 35 kVA.

Overload

35 kVA / 30 kVA = 1.167, or 116.7%. This represents a 16.7% overload on the transformer.

Why the Breaker Isn't Tripping (Yet)



Breaker Tolerances

Breakers aren't designed to trip immediately at their rated current. They have trip curves that allow for short-term overloads. A 100A breaker might not trip immediately at 105A or even 110A, especially depending on the breaker's type (thermal-magnetic, etc.) and the nature of the load.

Load Diversity

Your 99A demand might be a calculated peak demand, assuming all loads are on simultaneously. In reality, the actual instantaneous demand might be lower due to load diversity (not all loads operating at their maximum at the same time).


Transformer Overload Capacity

Transformers can withstand short-term overloads, but continuously exceeding their rating will shorten their lifespan and potentially lead to failure.

Consequences of Overloading



Reduced Lifespan

The transformer's insulation will degrade faster due to increased heat.


Voltage Drop

The secondary voltage will drop under heavy load, potentially affecting the performance of connected equipment.

Premature Failure

The transformer is more likely to fail prematurely.


Safety Hazard

Overheating can create a fire hazard.

What to Do


Verify the Load Calculation



Review all load calculations.
Make sure you're not double-counting loads or using overly conservative demand factors. Ensure you've correctly accounted for motor loads (inrush current, running current), lighting, receptacle loads, etc. Consider Demand Factors

Review NEC Article 220 for appropriate demand factors that can be applied to certain types of loads.

Monitor Actual Load

Use a power quality meter to monitor the actual current and kVA demand on the secondary side of the transformer over a typical operating period. This will give you a more realistic picture of the actual load profile.2.

Options if Overload is Confirmed



Upgrade the Transformer

This is the most reliable solution. Replace the 30 kVA transformer with a larger one (e.g., 45 kVA or even 75 kVA, depending on future load growth). This is the most reliable and recommended option.

Reduce the Load

Can you reduce the connected load? This might involve more efficient equipment, load shedding (turning off non-essential loads during peak periods), or redistributing loads to other circuits or transformers.


Do NOT Increase Breaker Size



Do NOT
simply increase the size of the secondary breaker to avoid nuisance tripping. This will only mask the problem and increase the risk of damaging the transformer. The breaker is there to protect the conductors and the transformer, and increasing its size defeats that purpose.3. NEC Considerations



NEC 450.3

This article covers transformer overcurrent protection. While your primary breaker might be sized appropriately based on the transformer's primary current rating, the
secondary protection is crucial for preventing overloads.

NEC 220

This article details how to calculate branch circuit, feeder, and service loads. Ensure you're using the correct methods for calculating the total demand load.

Example Calculation (Transformer Sizing)

To properly size the transformer, you would calculate the total kVA demand, then select a transformer with a kVA rating equal to or greater than that demand.kVA = (Volts Amps sqrt(3)) / 1000Amps = kVA 1000 / (Volts sqrt(3))In your case, with a calculated demand of 35kVA you need at least that size of the transformer.

In summary, while your secondary breaker hasn't tripped, the fact that your calculated kVA demand exceeds the transformer's rating indicates a potential problem. Investigate the load calculation, monitor actual load, and strongly consider upgrading the transformer to avoid long-term issues.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question