User: Isaiah, Location: Baton Rouge
Asked on: Friday, September 12, 2025 at 11:03 am EDT
Answered on: Friday, September 12, 2025 at 11:04 am EDT
Question: Client has a delta-delta ungrounded transformer (13.8kV to 480V, 2.0MVA), that feeds a 480V SWGR, 3P,3W, via bus duct for. The XMFR secondaryFrom the SWGR, they feed 5 480V MCCs,3P,3W with parallel 500kCMIL conductors, BUT they do not show an EGC with any of the feeders…as far as I know you must have an EGC in each conduit for parallel feeders even if the upstream transformer is ungrounded. Am I missing something?Enviado desde mi iPhone utilizando Tapatalk
You are absolutely correct. Even with an ungrounded delta-delta transformer, an Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC) is required in each conduit run of parallel feeders to the MCCs.Here's a breakdown of why, and the relevant code sections: Purpose of the EGC
The primary function of the EGC is to provide a low-impedance fault current path back to the source in the event of a ground fault. This low impedance path facilitates the operation of overcurrent protective devices (OCPDs) like circuit breakers or fuses, quickly clearing the fault and minimizing damage and the risk of electrical shock.
Ungrounded System Doesn't Eliminate the Need for an EGC
While an ungrounded system will continue to operate with a single ground fault (though it should be located and corrected promptly), a second ground fault on a different phase will create a short circuit with potentially devastating consequences. The EGC is still required to clear these second ground faults and provide safety. Also, the ungrounded system can still develop a ground reference due to stray capacitance.
Parallel Feeders and EGCs
NEC 310.10(H)(3) states: "Where conductors are installed in parallel in more than one raceway or cable, the equipment grounding conductor, where used, shall be installed in parallel in each raceway or cable." This means that each raceway or cable containing a parallel feeder must have its own EGC.
Why is an EGC Needed, Given the Ungrounded System? Safety
As mentioned above, the EGC provides a return path for fault current in the event of a second ground fault. Without it, fault currents could be limited and not trip the protective devices quickly.
Voltage Surges
Ungrounded systems can be susceptible to voltage surges during switching or fault events. The EGC helps to limit these surges.
Stray Capacitance and Ground Reference
Ungrounded systems are rarely truly ungrounded in practice. Stray capacitance to ground can create a voltage potential, and the EGC helps to stabilize this and provide a ground reference.
Fault Protection
Although a first fault to ground in an ungrounded system will not trip the protective devices, it is not recommended to allow this condition to persist. The addition of ground fault detection devices will sound an alarm on the first fault to ground but will require an EGC to perform properly.
Future Changes
A system may be changed in the future to a grounded configuration. The addition of an EGC facilitates such a change.
Code References
NEC 250.4(A)(5)
Electrical equipment and wiring shall be installed in a manner that creates a low-impedance circuit facilitating the operation of overcurrent devices.
NEC 250.4(B)(4)
The earth shall not be used as the sole equipment grounding conductor or equipment bonding jumper.
NEC 250.118
Specifies the types of conductors that are suitable for use as EGCs (e.g., copper, aluminum, rigid metal conduit, etc.).
NEC 310.10(H)(3)
Mandates parallel EGCs in each raceway when parallel conductors are used.
NEC 250.30(A)(1)
Requires a grounding electrode conductor (GEC) to be installed at the ungrounded separately derived system
Practical Considerations
The size of the EGC must be adequate to handle the available fault current. Table 250.122 in the NEC provides guidance on sizing the EGC based on the size of the ungrounded conductors. Properly connect the EGC to the equipment enclosures and the transformer's grounding electrode conductor (GEC). Inspect the installation to ensure that all connections are tight and secure.
In summary, you are correct. An EGC is absolutely required in each conduit containing parallel feeder conductors, even when supplied by an ungrounded delta-delta transformer. The absence of EGCs in this situation is a serious safety concern and a code violation.Recommendations for your client
Immediate Action
Inform your client immediately* of the dangerous condition. Stress the potential for equipment damage, fire, and electrical shock.2.
Detailed Inspection
Conduct a thorough inspection of the entire feeder system to verify the absence of EGCs in each conduit run.3.
Corrective Action
Work with a qualified electrical contractor to install appropriately sized EGCs in each conduit run, in accordance with the NEC. This may involve pulling additional conductors or replacing the existing conductors with ones that include an EGC.4.
Ground Fault Detection
Recommend the installation of ground fault detection equipment on the ungrounded system to alert personnel of the first ground fault so that it can be found and repaired.5.
Review: Review the original design and installation to understand why the EGCs were omitted. This may point to other potential errors in the electrical system.Document everything and provide a written report to your client emphasizing the importance of the corrective action. Their insurance carrier and local electrical inspector should also be notified (or have them notify them). This is a critical safety issue that needs to be addressed promptly. Flag for review