User: hbiss, Location: Little Falls, New York NEC: 2017
Asked on: Sunday, September 14, 2025 at 10:35 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, September 14, 2025 at 10:36 pm EDT
Question: Is it me or why is it nobody makes a ground clamp for 1" copper which is 1-1/8" OD? The 1/2 to 3/4" clamp is too small. Next up is the 1-1/4 to 2" which is too big. But if I take that 1-1/4 to 2" clamp apart and flip the back it works but I'm wondering if that is code compliant.-Hal
You're not alone in noticing this gap in readily available grounding clamps! It's a frustrating situation for many electricians and plumbers. Let's break down the issue and address your concerns about flipping the clamp.
Why the Gap?
The discrepancy in sizing likely comes down to a few factors: Demand
1" copper water pipe isn't as commonly used as smaller sizes for grounding purposes. Manufacturers may focus on producing what sells most frequently.
Standardization
While copper tubing sizes are somewhat standardized (nominal vs. OD), grounding clamp manufacturers might be using different internal standards or targeting a broader range of pipe sizes within each clamp.
Historical Use
Grounding practices may have evolved over time, and clamp sizes haven't always kept pace with changes in piping materials and installation methods.
Is Flipping the Clamp Code Compliant?
This is where it gets tricky and potentially dangerous. Here's why: Listing and Labeling
Electrical components, including grounding clamps, are typically listed and labeled by organizations like UL (Underwriters Laboratories) or ETL (Intertek). This listing indicates that the device has been tested and approved for use according to the manufacturer's instructions. Modifying the clamp by flipping parts violates those instructions.
Intended Use
Flipping the back may create better contact with the copper, but it fundamentally alters the clamp's design and compromises its ability to maintain reliable contact over time. The intended pressure points, surface area, and even the metal compatibility might be affected.
Corrosion and Conductivity
The flipped clamp might introduce dissimilar metal contact in a way the manufacturer didn't intend, leading to accelerated corrosion and reduced conductivity at the grounding point.
Mechanical Stability
The structural integrity of the clamp might be compromised, leading to loosening or failure over time. Vibration, temperature changes, and physical stress could all contribute to this.
NEC (National Electrical Code) Considerations
The NEC requires: 110.3(B) Installation and Use
"Listed or labeled equipment shall be installed and used in accordance with any instructions included in the listing or labeling." This is the big one. Using the clamp in a way it wasn't designed violates this section.
250.8 Connection of Grounding and Bonding Equipment
This section requires that connections be made in a manner that ensures a permanent and effective ground path. A modified clamp could be argued to violate this.
250.64(A) Grounding Electrode Conductor Installation
This section covers the proper installation of the grounding electrode conductor, and the connection method is a key part of that.
In short, flipping the clamp is very likely NOT code-compliant and could create a dangerous situation.What are Your Options?1. Search More Diligently
Keep looking! It's possible that a manufacturer produces a clamp that's a better fit. Contact electrical supply houses and ask them to check their catalogs and with their suppliers. Focus on specific brands known for quality grounding products (e.g., Ideal, Bridgeport, Burndy).2.
Use a Bonding Jumper with a Smaller Clamp
Solder or Braze a lug onto the 1" pipe. Attach a copper bonding jumper from the lug to the water meter or another location with an appropriate clamp.
NOTE
Soldering or brazing can be challenging on in-service pipes and requires skill to avoid leaks.3.
Use the "Too Big" Clamp and Fill the Gap (With Caution)
If you absolutely must use the larger clamp, you might be able to use a conductive, corrosion-resistant shim material (like copper sheet) to fill the gap and ensure good contact.
IMPORTANT
This is also pushing the boundaries of code compliance and requires extreme care. Consult with a licensed electrical inspector before proceeding. The shim must be properly sized, securely attached, and compatible with the metals involved to prevent corrosion and ensure a reliable connection.
WARNING
This is the riskiest option and should only be considered as a last resort, with expert consultation and approval.4.
Consult with a Licensed Electrical Inspector
The best advice is to speak with your local electrical inspector. They can provide definitive guidance on what is acceptable in your jurisdiction. They might know of a specific product or installation method that meets code requirements.5.
Contact Manufacturers Directly
Reach out to grounding clamp manufacturers directly and explain the problem. They might be working on a solution or could offer a custom-made clamp (although this is unlikely to be cost-effective).
Safety First!
Electrical grounding is a critical safety system. Do not compromise it by using improperly sized or modified components. Take the time to find the right solution, even if it's more difficult or expensive.
In summary, while your observation about the gap in clamp sizes is valid, modifying the clamp is not a safe or code-compliant solution. Explore the other options listed above and consult with a qualified professional to ensure a safe and reliable grounding system. Flag for review