Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Derated wiring solutions?

User: savage-sparky, Location: Maine

Asked on: Monday, September 15, 2025 at 5:03 am EDT
Answered on: Monday, September 15, 2025 at 5:15 am EDT

Question: I have a customer who had a union electrician friend of his help him with his wiring in his new house up here in maine. For starters not positive if his friend is licensed or not or just has his helpers, however he ran all circuits to a 12x12 junction box in the ceiling and feom the junction box he ran a 2 1/2" emt to the main panel. My question is once you account for derating calculations of approximately 20 circuits give or take this is reqyiring me to run a #10 for 15a circuits and #8 for 20a circuits is there a simplied and way less expensive solution to runing these circuits? I've considered just running feed wires through the conduit to a sub panel but even in thay case the entire place is already drywalled and finished off? Never ran into this situation so just trying to brainstorm thanks.

Okay, this is definitely a tricky situation, and it sounds like the electrician friend might have created a significant code violation and practical problem. Let's break down the issues and some potential solutions, keeping in mind code compliance and cost-effectiveness. I'm also assuming you're in the US, so I'll be referencing NEC.

Problem Breakdown



Junction Box as a Hub

The idea of consolidating all circuits into a single, large junction box is
highly unusual and almost certainly not code-compliant for residential wiring. While not illegal per se, the number of conductors bundled together, the access required for connections, and the derating issues it creates make it impractical and unsafe. NEC 314.16(B) would likely be violated.

Derating Nightmare

With 20+ circuits bundled together, derating for ampacity is going to be severe, requiring excessively large conductors. You've already identified the issue of #10 for 15A and #8 for 20A circuits. This is not only expensive but also makes terminations difficult. NEC 310.15(C)(1) and associated tables are the applicable sections.

Conduit Fill

A 2 1/2" EMT conduit, while seemingly large, might still be overfilled, even with derated wires. You need to calculate conduit fill based on the number and size of the conductors. NEC Chapter 9, Table 4 and associated notes apply.


Accessibility

The location of the junction box in the ceiling after drywalling is problematic for future maintenance, troubleshooting, and potential additions.

Possible Unlicensed Work

The fact that the homeowner isn't sure if the friend is licensed raises concerns about the overall quality and safety of the work performed.


Finished Walls

The fact that the walls are finished complicates any major rewiring.

Potential Solutions (Ranked from Best to Worst, in my opinion)


The Ideal (But Potentially Most Disruptive) Solution: Rewire and Distribute Circuits Properly
Concept

The
best solution is to remove the junction box entirely and run individual circuits directly from the panel to their respective outlets/devices. This is the most code-compliant and safest approach.

Process



Carefully map out all existing circuits.
Identify what each circuit serves. Remove the drywall around the junction box to expose the wiring and EMT connection. Disconnect all circuits from the junction box. Rewire each circuit individually from the panel. This may involve fishing wires through existing wall cavities. Consider using existing wire runs where possible, but ensure they meet current code standards (wire gauge, grounding, etc.). Add circuits as needed directly from the panel. Patch and repair the drywall. Pros

Meets code requirements. Eliminates derating issues. Improves circuit reliability and troubleshooting. Avoids potential future problems.

Cons

Most disruptive to the homeowner (drywall work, etc.). Most labor-intensive and therefore most expensive.2.

Subpanel(s) (with Careful Planning): A More Practical, but Still Involved, Solution
Concept

Place one or more subpanels closer to the load center in the house.


Process



Determine Optimal Subpanel Location(s)

Choose locations that minimize wire runs to the branch circuits and are accessible. Attic spaces, closets, or utility rooms are possible locations.


Install the Subpanel(s)

Mount the subpanel(s) securely.

Run a Feeder to the Subpanel

This is crucial. You'll need to calculate the load on the subpanel and size the feeder conductors and overcurrent protection accordingly.


Split the Circuits

Divide the existing circuits between the subpanel(s) and the main panel. Carefully consider the load distribution to avoid overloading either panel.

Rewire Circuits

Reconnect existing circuits to the appropriate panel (main or sub). This might involve some fishing of wires.


Pros

Reduces derating issues (fewer conductors in the original conduit run). Improves voltage drop. Potentially less drywall repair than a full rewire. Adds capacity for future expansion.

Cons

Requires careful load calculations. Still involves some fishing of wires. Adds the cost of the subpanel(s) and associated components. Requires a main breaker on the subpanel. Finished walls.3.

Reduce the Number of Circuits (Consolidate Where Possible): Least Desirable, Likely Code Violation
Concept

Combine some of the 15A or 20A circuits to reduce the total number of conductors in the conduit and junction box, thereby lowering the derating factor. This is the least preferred and is often a bad idea and code violation.


Process



Carefully Analyze Existing Circuits

Identify circuits that serve areas with low or intermittent loads.
Never combine circuits that serve kitchens, bathrooms, or other areas with high appliance loads.

Consolidate Lighting Circuits

Consider combining lighting circuits that serve multiple rooms if the total load is low.

Ensure Neutral Sharing is Correct

If you're combining circuits, you
must ensure the neutral conductors are properly shared to avoid overloading the neutral. This can be very tricky and should only be done by a qualified electrician.

Pros

Potentially the least expensive option.

Cons

Reduces circuit capacity. Increases the risk of overloading circuits. Requires careful analysis and expert knowledge.

LIKELY CODE VIOLATION

Combining circuits in a way that overloads them or creates a safety hazard is a serious violation. Not easily reversed if problems arise. Potentially could need arc-fault breakers if circuits are changed and go into new areas.

Recommendations


Insist on Proper Permitting and Inspection

This is crucial. Even if the homeowner is resistant due to cost, explain that unpermitted work can cause problems with insurance, resale, and, most importantly, safety.2.

Load Calculation

Perform a thorough load calculation to determine the actual demand on the electrical system. This will help you size conductors, overcurrent protection, and the subpanel (if used).3.

Detailed Proposal

Provide the homeowner with a detailed written proposal outlining the problems, the proposed solutions, the costs, and the potential risks of each option.4.

Professional Assessment

Consider having a qualified electrical inspector review the existing installation and provide an independent assessment.5.

Document Everything

Take photos of the existing wiring and document all changes made during the repair process.

Important Considerations



Arc-Fault Circuit Interrupters (AFCIs)

Ensure compliance with current AFCI requirements. Many areas now require AFCI protection on almost all 15A and 20A circuits.


Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters (GFCIs)

Ensure proper GFCI protection in required locations (bathrooms, kitchens, outdoors, etc.).

Local Codes

Check for any local electrical code amendments that may apply.

In Conclusion:


The situation described is problematic. The electrician friend created a complex and potentially unsafe wiring system. The best long-term solution is a complete rewire, but the subpanel approach may be a more practical compromise. Always prioritize safety and code compliance. Consulting with a qualified electrical inspector and obtaining the necessary permits is essential. Never perform electrical work that you are not qualified to do. You will want to cover your butt on this one.
Disclaimer: I am an AI Chatbot and not an Electrical Engineer. This information is for informational purposes only. Consult with a qualified electrician before making any decisions about electrical work.* Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question