Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 50A CB for small load at 3 Phse 208V

User: Isaiah, Location: Baton Rouge

Asked on: Monday, September 15, 2025 at 10:09 am EDT
Answered on: Monday, September 15, 2025 at 10:10 am EDT

Question: I’m still wondering why/how a major engineering firm sized a three phase CB at 50A for 3phase 208V Control panel that is rated just 4800VA. I’m seeing at CB of around 15A is all that’s neededEnviado desde mi iPhone utilizando Tapatalk

You're right, a 50A breaker for a 4800VA, 208V, 3-phase control panel seems significantly oversized. Let's break down the possible reasons why an engineering firm might have specified that, despite it seeming incorrect on the surface. We'll start with the calculation and then move into the possible justification for the oversize.1. Calculation: What Should the Breaker Size Be? VA to Amps

We need to convert the VA (Volt-Amps) to Amps. The formula for 3-phase VA is:VA = √3
V I (where V is voltage, and I is current)Therefore, to find the current (I):I = VA / (√3 V)I = 4800 VA / (√3 208V)I = 4800 VA / (1.732 208V)I = 4800 VA / 360.256 VI ≈ 13.32 Amps

Breaker Sizing

According to the NEC (National Electrical Code, assuming this is in the US), you generally need to size the breaker at
least 125% of the continuous load. If this load is considered continuous (operates for 3 hours or more at a time), then:Continuous Load Breaker = 13.32 Amps 1.25Continuous Load Breaker ≈ 16.65 Amps

Standard Breaker Size

Since 16.65A isn't a standard breaker size, you'd typically round
up to the next standard size, which would likely be a 20A breaker.

So, based on the apparent load, a 20A breaker would seem to be the appropriate size.
2. Possible Justifications for the 50A Breaker (These are hypotheses - you need to investigate to confirm)



Future Expansion/Load

This is the most likely reason. The engineering firm might be anticipating a significant increase in the load on the control panel in the future. They may have designed the panel for a potential upgrade or addition of equipment. For example: Maybe the panel currently controls some pumps, but the design allows for adding more pumps later. Perhaps the panel currently has some small motors, but the design is intended to support larger motors later. They might be planning to add a future HVAC unit, etc.To verify, you need to check the original design documents, load calculations, and any notes about future expansion. Ask the engineers if this was the case.

Motor Starting Current (Inrush)

If the control panel includes motors (even small ones), they draw a significantly higher current during startup than their running current. This is called inrush current, or locked rotor current. While the breaker doesn't need to be sized for the peak inrush, it needs to be large enough to avoid nuisance tripping during motor starts. The type of motor starting method can affect the inrush. For instance, a soft starter will significantly reduce the inrush current.To verify, you need to know the type and size of any motors controlled by the panel, and how they are started. A motor FLA (Full Load Amps) rating will be on the motor nameplate. The LRA (Locked Rotor Amps) rating is what you need to look at as well.

Branch Circuits within the Panel

The 4800VA rating might be the
total capacity of the panel, but there could be multiple branch circuits inside the panel, each requiring its own breaker. The 50A breaker could be feeding a sub-panel within the main control panel, and those branch circuits may never actually draw the full 50 amps, the engineer could have allowed for future branch circuits to be installed.If this is the case, examine the internal wiring and breaker arrangement within the control panel.



Transformer Sizing

The control panel may be fed by a step-down transformer. The transformer itself might be rated for a larger VA than the 4800VA of the control panel. The primary side of the transformer needs to have overcurrent protection, and the secondary side will have a main breaker as well. This is to protect the transformer itself from overload or fault conditions. It is possible that the 50A CB is the primary side CB to protect the transformer, and the control panel has its own main CB that is much smaller.

Derating Factors

The engineer might have applied significant derating factors to the conductors and equipment due to ambient temperature, conduit fill, or other environmental conditions. This would require larger conductors (and a correspondingly larger breaker) than would be apparent from just the 4800VA rating.


Standard Engineering Practice (Possibly Overly Conservative)

Some engineers might simply have a very conservative approach to breaker sizing, using a large safety factor. While this is generally safe, it can lead to unnecessary expense.

Error/Oversight

It's also possible (though less likely if it's a reputable firm) that there was a simple error in the design or specification. Mistakes happen.

What to Do


Review the Original Design Documents

This is the most important step. Obtain the panel's electrical drawings, load calculations, and specifications. This should explain the reasoning behind the breaker size.2.

Examine the Internal Wiring

Look inside the control panel to see how the circuits are arranged and what loads are connected.3.

Document the Actual Load

Measure the actual current draw of the control panel under normal operating conditions using a clamp meter. Compare this to the nameplate rating and the breaker size.4.

Consult with the Engineering Firm

If you still have questions after reviewing the documentation, contact the engineering firm directly and ask for clarification. Explain your concerns and ask them to justify the breaker size.5.

Consult with a Qualified Electrician

A licensed electrician can assess the situation and provide a professional opinion on whether the breaker size is appropriate and safe.6.

Consider Replacing the Breaker (If Justified)

If you determine that the breaker is significantly oversized and there's no reasonable justification, consider replacing it with a properly sized breaker
after consulting with a qualified electrician or engineer.

Do not do this without proper authorization and verification.

Important Note

Changing a breaker to a smaller size can be dangerous if the original design considered factors you're not aware of.

Never reduce the breaker size without thoroughly understanding the reasons behind the original specification and ensuring that the new breaker will provide adequate protection for the circuit.
* Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question