User: sw_ross, Location: NoDak
Asked on: Monday, September 15, 2025 at 8:27 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, September 15, 2025 at 8:27 pm EDT
Question: Had a younger co-worker that was playing around with ChatGPT, playing around with it to put together an estimate for wiring up a shop.I have no experience with it but it was an interesting experience. It seemed pretty thorough. As you would gradually give it more information it would modify the estimate price and actually give you feedback about whether your hourly rate was too high or low, etc.I would never submit a bid/estimate based on it but I would definitely use it to check my estimate before submitting.Where does it get its information?
That's a fascinating anecdote! It highlights both the potential and the limitations of using AI tools like ChatGPT for professional tasks like electrical estimating. Here's a breakdown of where ChatGPT gets its information and how that impacts its performance
Where ChatGPT Gets Its Information:
Massive Text and Code Dataset
ChatGPT is trained on a colossal dataset of text and code scraped from the internet. This includes: Websites: Articles, blogs, forums, documentation, news sites, e-commerce sites, etc. Books: A vast library of digitized books covering a wide range of topics. Code Repositories: Public code from platforms like GitHub, providing examples of programming techniques and best practices. Other Text Data: Academic papers, legal documents, and a variety of other textual information.
Training Process
The model is trained using a combination of techniques, including:
Supervised Learning
Training with labeled data to learn specific tasks (e.g., translation, question answering).
Unsupervised Learning
Identifying patterns and relationships in unlabeled data.
Reinforcement Learning
Fine-tuning the model's responses based on human feedback.
How This Impacts ChatGPT's Abilities
General Knowledge
The massive dataset gives ChatGPT a broad understanding of many topics. It can access and process information from a variety of sources.
Pattern Recognition
It excels at recognizing patterns in language and code. This enables it to generate coherent and grammatically correct text, as well as understand and respond to complex queries.
Simulating Expertise
It can mimic the style and tone of an expert by learning from the language used in its training data. This can make it seem knowledgeable, even if it lacks true understanding.
Limitations
No Real-World Experience
ChatGPT has no physical experience or real-world knowledge. It cannot "see" a building, feel the texture of wire, or understand the nuances of a construction site.
Data Bias
The training data may contain biases that are reflected in ChatGPT's responses. This could lead to inaccurate or unfair estimates if the data it was trained on underrepresents certain regions, or has inaccurate pricing.
Lack of Up-to-Date Information
The training data has a cut-off date (currently early 2023). So, it may not have the latest pricing information for materials, labor rates, or code updates.
Inability to Verify Information
ChatGPT cannot independently verify the accuracy of the information it provides. It may generate plausible-sounding but incorrect information.
Generalization and Contextual Understanding
ChatGPT can struggle with complex scenarios or subtle contextual clues.
Estimating Complexity
Calculating the square footage of a location, the labor hours required, or permit pricing would all be beyond the abilities of ChatGPT.
Specific to Estimating and Feedback
Pricing Data
ChatGPT likely got some pricing information from online retailers, manufacturers' websites, or construction cost databases (if they were part of its training data).
Labor Rates
Information on typical electrician hourly rates may have come from job boards, salary surveys, or articles about industry compensation.
Feedback on Hourly Rates
The suggestion that your hourly rate was "too high or low" likely stems from the model comparing it to the average rates it found in its training data.
Why You're Right to Be Cautious
Local Codes and Regulations
Electrical codes and regulations vary widely by location. ChatGPT may not be aware of the specific requirements in your area.
Specific Project Details
A generic estimate cannot account for unique project challenges such as accessibility, existing infrastructure, or specialized materials.*
Market Conditions
Local market conditions (e.g., supply chain issues, material shortages, contractor availability) can significantly impact pricing. ChatGPT is unlikely to be aware of these real-time factors.
How to Use ChatGPT as a Tool (With Caution)
Brainstorming
Use it to generate a list of potential tasks or materials needed for a project.2.
Checking for Completeness
Compare its output to your own estimate to see if you've missed anything.3.
Researching Material Options
Ask it to provide information on different types of wiring or electrical components.4.
Identifying Potential Issues
Ask it about common challenges in similar electrical projects.
Key Takeaway
ChatGPT can be a useful tool for brainstorming, generating ideas, and identifying potential issues. However, it should never be used as a substitute for your own professional judgment and expertise.
Always verify the information it provides and tailor your estimates to the specific requirements of the project and your local market. It's a starting point, not a replacement for experience and thorough research. Flag for review