User: Alexis, Location: Los Angeles
Asked on: Tuesday, September 16, 2025 at 2:52 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, September 16, 2025 at 2:52 pm EDT
Question: Hello,We just had an inspection in one of the cities around Los Angeles. They have all their own local codes and rules. Some of them could be reasonable and some are just funny. I'd apreciate any feedback!The property is a 10 unit plus HSE (11 meters total). We upgraded the main panel to 400A (with main disconnect) the sub panel breakers are all 30A with 10awg feeders to each unit. Inspector demanded to have minimum 6awg and 60A per unit.What is your opinion? If I'm reading the 230.79 and 230.80 right the 400A main disconnect is falling under this requirement and gives us permission to keep 30A down the stream for each unit. That's how at least we've been doing this for many other inspections.The other correction was that if we are replacing the panels we have to replace the feeder to each unit and we can't keep using existing flex as a ground, like it was done in each sub panel before.He told us also to remove gas pipe bonding that we installed between each gas meter..Some ridiculous corrections that he added for local utility rules:1. No main ground wire allowed in the main service disconnect to bond to the neutral. Has to be installed in one of the meter stacks.2. No parallel service feeders (we have two sets of 3/0)3. No LB on the service mast (we have added rings for utility to seal). When I asked how do you even do that 90 on the wall without a LB, he said "be creative".I'd apreciate any feedback from you guys! Thanks!!
Okay, let's break down these issues and provide some feedback. It sounds like you're dealing with an inspector with a strong, potentially idiosyncratic, interpretation of the code.
Regarding the 30A/10 AWG Feeders vs. 60A/6 AWG Requirement
This is the most critical and arguably the most questionable issue. You're right to question this. Here's the analysis: NEC Perspective
While it's true that 230.79 and 230.80 deal with service-entrance conductors and service disconnects, they don't directly dictate the size of subpanel feeders. The size of the feeder conductors and overcurrent protection for a dwelling unit subpanel are typically governed by Article 215 (Feeders) and Article 225 (Outside Branch Circuits and Feeders) in conjunction with Article 220 (Load Calculations).
Load Calculation is Key
The critical factor is the calculated load for each dwelling unit. You need to perform a load calculation (NEC Article 220, Part III - Dwelling Units) for a typical unit. This calculation determines the minimum ampacity required for the feeder.
Is 30A Sufficient? Many smaller apartments (especially studios or one-bedroom units) can, in practice, often be adequately served by a 30A feeder, if the load calculation supports it. However, in California (and especially near LA), inspectors tend to err on the side of caution. Inspector's Rationale
The inspector is likely applying a more conservative, blanket rule. The rationale might be to future-proof the installation, to ensure adequate capacity for modern appliances, or simply because they have seen problems with undersized feeders in the past. He's also potentially worried about voltage drop.
Your Argument
You need to prove that the 30A/10 AWG is adequate by providing a detailed load calculation for a representative unit. This is your strongest argument. If the calculation shows the required load is significantly less than 30A, you have a strong case.
Code References for Load Calculation
Refer to NEC Articles 220.10 through 220.61 for dwelling unit load calculations. Pay close attention to: 220.11: General lighting load (based on square footage). 220.12: Show window and receptacle loads (if applicable). 220.14: Other loads (fixed appliances, etc.). 220.52: Small appliance and laundry circuits (required for dwelling units). 220.53: Appliance demand factors (Table 220.53 may allow for reduced demand for certain appliances). 220.61: Optional calculation for additional loads.
Important Consideration: Overcurrent Protection
Remember that 10 AWG wire is typically only rated for 30A (based on NEC Table 310.16 in the 75°C column, which is generally the default). You absolutely cannot protect it with a 60A breaker, regardless of any load calculations. That would be a major safety violation.
What to Do
Perform Detailed Load Calculations
Do this for a typical unit.2.
Present the Calculations to the Inspector
Show them your work. Be prepared to defend your assumptions.3.
Consider a Compromise
If the load calculation is close to 30A, consider upgrading to 40A breakers and slightly larger conductors (8 AWG), which would provide a little extra capacity without requiring a complete overhaul. This can sometimes be a good way to satisfy a cautious inspector.4.
If Necessary, Appeal
If you believe the inspector is wrong and unwilling to compromise, you may have the option to appeal to a higher authority within the city's building department.
Regarding Replacing Panels and Existing Flex Conduit as Ground
Replacing Panels = Grounding Upgrade is Reasonable
This is a valid point. When you replace panels, you're essentially modernizing the system. It is now required by current code to have a separate equipment grounding conductor run to each panel. Previously, you could get away with the conduit acting as ground but not anymore.
Existing Flex as Ground
This is a code violation if it doesn't meet current standards. Flexible metal conduit (FMC) can be used as an equipment grounding conductor only if it meets specific requirements (NEC 250.118(5)). Generally, it's unlikely that the existing flex meets those requirements (e.g., being listed for grounding, having proper fittings, being short enough, etc.). What to Do
You need to install a separate equipment grounding conductor (typically green or bare copper) within the flex conduit. This is the safest and most code-compliant solution.
Regarding Gas Pipe Bonding
Likely Correct
Local codes often have very specific requirements for gas pipe bonding. The code generally requires bonding the gas pipe at the service entrance, but not in between each meter. Check the local gas company's regulations, they likely have more specific requirements.
Regarding Ridiculous Corrections
No Main Ground Wire in Main Service Disconnect
This is where it gets really specific to the local utility's rules.
Possible Rationale
Some utilities have specific grounding configurations they prefer to ensure proper coordination of their protective devices. They may want the primary ground connection located at the meter to ensure that any faults on the utility side are cleared properly.
What to Do
You must comply with the utility's requirements. There is no fighting this. They dictate how the service is connected. Get their grounding diagram or specific instructions.2.
No Parallel Service Feeders
NEC Allows Parallel Conductors (with conditions)
The NEC does allow parallel conductors (310.10(H)) if each conductor is 1/0 AWG or larger, and all conductors are the same length, same material, same termination method, etc. to ensure equal current sharing.
Utility Disallows
Again, this may be a utility-specific rule. They may have had problems with improperly installed parallel conductors causing unbalanced loads or overheating.
What to Do
You must comply with the utility. If you have already installed this set up you will need to modify it based on what they say.3.
No LB on the Service Mast
Questionable
This is highly unusual. An LB (or similar fitting) is often necessary to make a proper transition from the service mast to the meter enclosure.
Possible Rationale
The inspector or utility may have had issues with LBs being improperly installed (e.g., not weatherproof, not properly supported, being used in areas not rated for wet locations).
What to Do
Ask for Clarification (Politely)
"I understand you don't want an LB, but can you show me an example of how you'd like this 90-degree bend to be made while maintaining a weatherproof seal and proper support?"
Document the Conversation
Keep a record of the inspector's instructions.
Utility Specific
They may have specific guidelines.
General Advice
Document Everything
Keep meticulous records of all communications with the inspector, any code sections cited, and any directives given.
Be Respectful but Firm
Maintain a professional and respectful demeanor, but don't be afraid to politely question and challenge questionable interpretations of the code.
Know Your Codes
Familiarize yourself with the NEC (National Electrical Code), any applicable state codes, and the specific local amendments that the city has adopted. Knowing the code gives you a solid foundation for your arguments.
Talk to Other Electricians
See if other electricians in the area have had similar experiences with this inspector and what strategies they have used.
Consider a Second Opinion
If you're consistently running into issues with this inspector, you might consider getting a second opinion from another qualified electrician in the area.
Appeal if Necessary: If you feel you are being unfairly treated, and you have exhausted all other options, you have the right to appeal the inspector's decision to a higher authority within the city's building department.Good luck! Dealing with stringent inspectors can be frustrating, but with preparation, documentation, and a professional approach, you can usually find a resolution. Flag for review