Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Short circuit study - Defining Impedance for Ground fault calculation

User: jesusrperezd, Location: California

Asked on: Wednesday, September 17, 2025 at 11:16 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 17, 2025 at 11:17 am EDT

Question: Hi all,There is a 480-277V (3ph 4w) feeder from a wye solid grounded system. I am analysing the available faults on this circuit at 20%, 50%, and 100% of the circuit length.For the Ground fault simulation, I have the option to add a "Fault impedance" in ohms to the calculation. I understand this value considers the impedance of the fault contact plus the return path to the source. It makes sense to consider a value to be realistic. The fault results vary significantly with impedance from 0 to 5 ohms.A folk told me that he always uses 0.5 ohms, another one said he prefers to do it with 0 ohms to obtain the largest value.I would like to have a consistent and logical method to analyse these cases. I believe this is crucial for coordinating protective devices and defining settings. My initial thought is to consider a value that represents the return through the EGCs, considering the sizes and length from the fault to the source.What are your thoughts on this?Thanks!

You've hit on a really important point in fault current analysis and protective device coordination: the value of fault impedance significantly impacts the calculated fault current and, therefore, the effectiveness of your protective devices. Let's break down the considerations and arrive at a logical approach

Why Fault Impedance Matters
Realistic Scenarios

A bolted fault (zero impedance) is rare in practice. In the real world, there's always
some impedance at the point of the fault and in the return path. Arcing, corrosion, loose connections, and even the physical properties of the materials involved all contribute to impedance.

Protective Device Performance

Protective devices (fuses, circuit breakers, relays) operate based on current magnitude. A lower fault current (due to higher impedance) can lead to delayed tripping or failure to trip altogether, increasing damage and hazard potential.

Coordination Challenges

Protective device coordination relies on time-current curves. If the actual fault current is significantly lower than your calculated bolted fault current, your coordination study will be invalid, leading to nuisance tripping or, worse, failure to clear a fault quickly.

Arguments for Different Approaches
0 Ohms (Bolted Fault)



Pros

Provides the
maximum available fault current. This gives a worst-case scenario for equipment withstand ratings and cable sizing. It's often used for initial design and equipment selection.

Cons

Unrealistic for ground faults. Ground faults inherently involve impedance through the earth return path and the fault arc. It can lead to over-sizing equipment and over-aggressive protective device settings. It may also lead to coordination problems since it assumes the highest possible current.

0.5 Ohms (Rule of Thumb)



Pros

A convenient and often used value when designing or checking the existing electrical infrastructure, can be used as a starting point, and the results are often within the acceptance criteria.

Cons

No logic or support from calculations of the installation or component properties


Calculated Impedance (EGC Return Path + Arc Impedance)



Pros

The
most accurate representation of a realistic ground fault. It accounts for the actual impedance of the EGC, conduit, and, critically, the arc itself. This allows for more precise protective device coordination.

Cons

More complex to calculate. Requires knowledge of conductor lengths, sizes, materials, and grounding system details. Estimating arc impedance can be challenging (see below).

Your Approach: Calculated EGC Impedance is the Best


Your initial thought of considering the return path through the EGCs is the correct and most logical approach for a detailed ground fault analysis, especially for protective device coordination. Here's how you can do it:1. Calculate EGC Impedance



Segment the Circuit

Divide the circuit into sections of uniform EGC type and length.


Determine EGC Reactance and Resistance

Use cable manufacturer data, NEC tables (Table 9), or software to determine the per-unit impedance (Ohms/foot or Ohms/meter) of the EGC conductor (copper, aluminum, or steel conduit). Remember to account for the effect of conduit material (ferrous vs. non-ferrous). Steel conduit has significantly higher impedance, especially at high frequencies.

Calculate Total EGC Impedance

Multiply the per-unit impedance by the length of each segment. Sum the impedance of all segments to get the total EGC impedance from the fault location back to the source (transformer neutral).2.

Consider Arc Impedance



Arcing Faults are Common

Most ground faults start as arcing faults. The arc itself adds significant impedance.

Estimating Arc Impedance

This is the trickiest part. There are several empirical formulas available, but they are just estimations. A common formula, often used in software, is based on Stokes and Oppenlander:
`Va = 20L` (for low voltage) Where: `Va` = Arc voltage (volts) `L` = Arc length (inches) You'll need to estimate the arc length. This is influenced by the voltage, available fault current, and the physical configuration of the fault. For example, an arc in a confined space (inside a panel) will likely be shorter than an arc in open air. For 480V systems, assume an arc length between 1/2 inch to 3 inches.

Convert to Impedance

To convert arc voltage to impedance, use Ohm's Law (Z = V/I). You need to estimate the arc current. You can iterate:
Assume an initial arc current based on the calculated fault current with only EGC impedance. Calculate the arc voltage using the formula above. Calculate the arc impedance (Z = Va / Ia). Add the arc impedance to the EGC impedance. Recalculate the fault current with the total impedance (EGC + Arc). Repeat until the arc current converges.

Alternative Approach

Some software packages allow you to directly input an estimated arc resistance or voltage drop. This can simplify the process.3.

Consider Contact Resistance

The resistance at the point of contact where the fault occurs. Usually, these values are low (milliohms) but must be considered in the calculation.4.

Total Fault Impedance

Add the EGC impedance, estimated arc impedance, and contact resistance. This is the value you'll use in your fault current calculations.

Example

Let's say you have a 50-foot run of 3/0 AWG copper EGC in steel conduit. You estimate the arc length to be 1 inch.1.

EGC Impedance

Using NEC Table 9, find the AC resistance and reactance of 3/0 copper in steel conduit. Let's assume you find R = 0.05 Ohms/1000ft and X = 0.06 Ohms/1000ft. R_egc = (0.05 Ohms / 1000 ft) 50 ft = 0.0025 Ohms X_egc = (0.06 Ohms / 1000 ft) 50 ft = 0.003 Ohms Z_egc = √(R_egc^2 + X_egc^2) = 0.0039 Ohms2.

Arc Impedance

Va = 20 1 inch = 20 V Assume an initial fault current of 1000A (based on a bolted fault calculation with only EGC impedance). Za = 20 V / 1000 A = 0.02 Ohms3.

Total Fault Impedance

Z_total = Z_egc + Za = 0.0039 Ohms + 0.02 Ohms = 0.0239 Ohms

Software Makes it Easier


Specialized electrical power system analysis software (e.g., ETAP, SKM PowerTools, EasyPower) greatly simplifies this process. They have built-in databases of conductor impedances and often include arc flash calculation modules that incorporate arc impedance models. They allow you to easily model different fault locations and perform iterative calculations.

Important Considerations



Multiple Grounding Paths

If there are multiple parallel grounding paths (e.g., metallic conduit
and a dedicated EGC), you need to calculate the equivalent impedance of the parallel paths.

Transformer Grounding Impedance

Be sure to include the impedance of the grounding resistor or impedance grounding system at the transformer neutral (if applicable).

Conservative Approach

When in doubt, err on the side of
slightly* higher fault impedance for protective device coordination. This ensures that your protective devices will still operate correctly even if the actual fault impedance is a bit lower.

In Summary:


While using 0 Ohms provides a worst-case scenario for equipment sizing, it's crucial to incorporate realistic fault impedance, especially when coordinating protective devices. Calculating the EGC impedance and estimating arc impedance gives you the most accurate representation of real-world ground fault conditions. Software tools can make this process much more manageable. Remember to document your assumptions and calculations clearly. Using software is really useful to test scenarios with a reasonable level of detail.By adopting this approach, you'll ensure your protective devices are properly coordinated and can effectively clear ground faults, minimizing damage and enhancing safety. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question