User: Seven-Delta-FortyOne, Location: Humboldt
Asked on: Wednesday, September 17, 2025 at 12:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 17, 2025 at 12:30 pm EDT
Question: I have decorative exterior lighting going in the side of a round concrete column.I have not seen a round masonry box. I’m thinking I’ll use these, and use the ears to tie wire the box to the rebar before the pour.
You're on the right track thinking outside the box (pun intended!). A standard masonry box won't work on a curved surface. Here's a breakdown of your idea and some alternative approaches
Your Idea: Standard Masonry Box with Wire Tie-In
Pros
Relatively inexpensive. Provides a standard junction box for future wiring connections. The ears on the box do provide a means of securing it.
Cons
Difficult to Achieve a Flush Finish
You'll need to ensure the box is perfectly positioned so the face is flush with the concrete surface. Any slight misalignment will be very noticeable and difficult to fix.
Concrete Flow Around the Box
Concrete doesn't always flow perfectly around obstructions, especially on a curved surface. You might end up with voids or honeycombing around the box, weakening the concrete in that area.
Box Distortion
The pressure of the wet concrete during the pour could potentially distort the box, especially if it's a lightweight metal or plastic.
Bonding Issues
The smooth surface of the box doesn't bond well with the concrete. This can lead to water ingress over time.
Potential for Rust (Metal Boxes)
Even if the box is galvanized, contact with wet concrete can accelerate corrosion.
Not Code-Compliant (Potentially)
Local electrical codes may have specific requirements for boxes embedded in concrete, particularly regarding protection from moisture and corrosion.
Alternatives and Recommendations
Here's a more robust and professional approach:1. Pre-Fabricated Embedment Boxes (Best Option)
Description
These are specifically designed for embedding in concrete. They often have a rough exterior surface to promote bonding, reinforced construction to withstand the pour pressure, and provisions for water-tight conduit connections. Look for boxes with "concrete pour sleeves" or similar terminology.
Brands
Search online for "concrete embedment boxes" or "concrete pour boxes." Many electrical supply houses carry them. Specific brands include names like Carlon, Hubbell Wiegmann or Crouse-Hinds.
Benefits
Designed for concrete pours, minimizing the risks of voids and box distortion. Ensure a strong, watertight seal for electrical connections. Often come with mounting plates for easy fixture attachment. Typically code-compliant.
Considerations
More expensive than standard masonry boxes.2.
Custom-Built Formwork (For Unique Situations)
Description
If you absolutely need a specific shape or size that you can't find pre-made, you can create a mold to form a recessed area in the concrete.
Process
Build a form from wood, plastic, or other suitable material that matches the desired recess. Ensure it's strong enough to withstand the concrete pressure. Coat the inside of the form with a release agent (form oil) to prevent the concrete from sticking. Secure the form to the rebar cage before the pour. After the concrete has cured, carefully remove the form.
Benefits
Maximum flexibility in terms of size and shape.
Considerations
Requires woodworking/fabrication skills. Time-consuming. Still needs a properly rated junction box inside the recess. Ensure proper drainage and sealing of the recess.3.
Surface Mounting with Specialized Hardware
Description
This avoids embedding anything in the concrete altogether. You would drill into the cured concrete and use expansion anchors to mount a weatherproof junction box to the surface.
Process
Use a rotary hammer drill with a masonry bit to create holes for the anchors. Insert appropriate expansion anchors (e.g., wedge anchors, sleeve anchors) into the holes. Attach a weatherproof junction box to the anchors. Use weatherproof fittings and conduit to connect the wiring to the box.
Benefits
Avoids issues with concrete flow and box distortion. Easier to install and maintain.
Considerations
The box will be visible on the surface of the column. Requires careful drilling to avoid damaging the concrete. Requires high-quality anchors for a secure and lasting installation. The aesthetics may not be ideal.
Important Considerations for Any Method
Waterproofing
Concrete is porous. Ensure all penetrations (conduit entries, fixture mounting points) are properly sealed to prevent water from entering the box and causing corrosion or electrical hazards. Use waterproof fittings, sealants, and gaskets.
Conduit
Run conduit to the box location before the concrete pour (if you're embedding a box). Use rigid metal conduit (RMC) for maximum protection. Ensure the conduit is securely anchored to the rebar cage. Avoid PVC conduit inside the concrete, as it can crack over time.
Rebar Clearance
Maintain proper clearance between the box and the rebar to allow for adequate concrete coverage. Check local building codes for minimum clearance requirements.
Electrical Code
Follow all applicable electrical codes (NEC in the US, or your local equivalent) for wiring in concrete. This includes using the correct type of wire (e.g., THWN) and providing proper grounding.
Grounding
The metal box and all metallic components (conduit, fixtures) must be properly grounded.
Recommendations
Use pre-fabricated embedment boxes designed for concrete pours. This is the best practice for a professional and reliable installation. Research different manufacturers to find boxes that meet your specific needs.2. Consult with a qualified electrician or concrete contractor. They can advise you on the best approach for your specific situation and ensure that the installation is done safely and in compliance with all applicable codes. They can also guide you on the proper selection of boxes, conduit, and wiring for concrete applications.
In summary, while using a standard masonry box might seem like a quick and cheap solution, it's likely to lead to problems down the road. Investing in the right materials and expertise will result in a more durable, reliable, and safe lighting installation. Flag for review