User: electrofelon, Location: Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Asked on: Thursday, September 18, 2025 at 11:44 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, September 18, 2025 at 11:45 am EDT
Question: I have to come out of a 2000A switchboard, theu a CMU wall to a 2000A transfer switch outside. There is about 10-12 feet between the wall and the transfer switch. There is already a large box mounted on top of the switch board. The equipment is oversized, with 3 years of demand data showing max demand of 136KW. (377A). Thus i will probably reduce the feeder down to maybe 1200A. I can probably get 2 sets of 600Al in a 4" with a reduced neutral, in which case that would be 4 conduits total (2 out, 2 back in). We're just toying with other options. What about using a 3r wire way? I can just cut a hole in the CMU wall, use a wire way and box flange to come into the back of the inside box, then nipple put the bottom into the top of xfer switch. Another option might be cable tray, but that doesn't seem like a great option due to transitioning from inside to outside and having to go into the top of the switch. Any other thoughts or ideas? Should I just run the conduits?
Okay, this is a classic electrical engineering challenge! Let's break down the options and considerations for your 2000A to 1200A feeder tap. I'm going to prioritize safety, code compliance (NEC), and practical installation.
Key Considerations
Ampacity & Voltage Drop
You're proposing to downsize the feeder to 1200A based on demand data. This is a good starting point, but absolutely verify your calculations and deratings. Ambient temperature, grouping of conductors, and conduit fill all affect ampacity. Voltage drop is also critical, especially with a run of 10-12 feet.
Neutral Sizing
Reduced neutral is common, but carefully calculate the required neutral ampacity based on anticipated harmonic content and unbalanced loads. Don't undersize it!
Environmental Factors
You're dealing with an indoor-to-outdoor transition, so weatherproofing is paramount. Consider rain, snow, ice, UV exposure, and temperature extremes.
Code Compliance
You must adhere to the National Electrical Code (NEC). This includes conductor ampacity, conduit fill, grounding, bonding, and suitable raceway types. Consult Article 310 for Ampacity, Chapter 3 for Wiring Methods and Materials.
Accessibility & Maintainability
Future access for inspection, maintenance, and potential upgrades should be factored in.
Cost
While not the only driver, cost is a factor. Consider material, labor, and long-term maintenance.
Feeder Tap Rules
Check NEC 240.21 for feeder tap rules. If you are tapping a 2000A bus to feed a 1200A load, you must comply with the length requirements in 240.21(B).
Short-Circuit Current Rating (SCCR)
Verify that the transfer switch's SCCR is sufficient for the available fault current at its location. The downsizing of the feeder does not necessarily mean a reduction in the available fault current.
Analysis of Options
Conduit (2 sets of 600 kcmil in 4" with reduced neutral)
Pros
Well-established and understood method. Good physical protection for conductors. Relatively easy to seal against weather at the CMU wall penetration. Easy to support. Conduit fill is well understood and documented. Cost effective
Cons
Requires four conduit runs (2 in, 2 out). This can be labor-intensive to install. Bending large conduit can be challenging. Pulling large conductors through multiple bends is difficult. Neutral conductor size reduction may not be permitted for service-entrance conductors.
Considerations
Use properly sized and rated conduit bodies (LB, LL, LR) to minimize bends and pulling difficulty. Thoroughly clean and lubricate conductors during pulling. Ensure the conduit is properly grounded and bonded.2.
NEMA 3R Wireway
Pros
Potentially faster installation than multiple conduits. Easier to pull conductors through a straight wireway run. More space for conductors than conduit.
Cons
Wireway ampacity derating is a critical factor. You must carefully calculate the allowable ampacity based on the number of conductors and the wireway's cross-sectional area and ventilation. NEC 376.22, and 376.
23. Sealing the wireway against weather at the CMU penetration and the transfer switch entry can be tricky. Use appropriate rain-tight connectors and sealing methods. Wireway support is crucial, especially with heavy conductors. Use properly sized and spaced supports. Bending wireway is not as easy as bending conduit. The wireway itself may not be as robust against physical damage as conduit. Transition from switchboard box to wireway can be complicated.
Considerations
Select a wireway with adequate ventilation to help with heat dissipation. Use a wireway with a hinged cover for easy access. Ensure the wireway is properly grounded and bonded. The section entering the building must be suitable for indoor environments The section entering the Xfer switch must be suitable for outdoor environments3.
Cable Tray
Pros
Good for long runs and large numbers of cables. Allows for easy inspection and maintenance.
Cons
Not ideal for short runs like yours (10-12 feet). Transitioning from inside to outside and into the top of the transfer switch is awkward. Weatherproofing can be difficult. May require more support than other options. Cable tray is typically more expensive than conduit or wireway.
Considerations
You would need to use cable suitable for cable tray installation (e.g., Type TC). Ensure the cable tray is properly grounded and bonded. Cable tray is more susceptible to damage.
Recommendation
Given the short run and the need for a reliable, weatherproof installation,
I would lean towards the conduit solution (Option 1). Here's why: Proven Reliability
Conduit systems are a well-understood and widely used method for electrical installations.
Good Physical Protection
Conduit provides excellent physical protection for the conductors.
Easy to Weatherproof
Properly installed conduit and fittings are easy to seal against the elements.
Cost-Effective
Conduit is generally less expensive than wireway or cable tray.
Familiar Installation Techniques
Most electricians are comfortable working with conduit.
Specific Steps & Considerations
Detailed Calculations
Perform thorough ampacity, voltage drop, and neutral sizing calculations before selecting conductors and conduit size.2.
Feeder Tap Rules
Comply with feeder tap rules in 240.21.
3.
Coordinate with Transfer Switch Manufacturer
Confirm the entry requirements and available space at the top of the transfer switch.4.
CMU Wall Penetration
Core drill a clean hole through the CMU wall. Use a sleeve and sealant to ensure a weatherproof seal around the conduits.5.
Conduit Bodies
Use appropriate conduit bodies (LB, LL, LR) to minimize bends and make pulling easier.6.
Weatherproof Fittings
Use weatherproof conduit fittings and connectors.7.
Grounding and Bonding
Ensure the entire system is properly grounded and bonded according to NEC Article 250.8.
Inspection
Schedule an inspection with the local electrical inspector to ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations.9.
Labeling
Label all conduits and equipment clearly.
If you absolutely want to consider Wireway
Detailed Calculations
NEC 376.22 requires that the sum of the cross-sectional areas of all conductors at any cross section of the wireway not exceed 20% of the interior cross-sectional area of the wireway.
2.
Derating
Conductors in wireway must comply with 310.15(C)(1) and NEC Table 310.15(C)(1). This often requires substantial derating.
3.
Choose a Wireway Rated for Outside Use
Wireway used outside must comply with 376.10 and be suitable for wet locations.
4.
Grounding and Bonding
Ensure the entire system is properly grounded and bonded according to NEC Article 250.5.
Sealing
Weatherproof sealant will be required between all sections of the wireway, at the building penetration, and on top of the transfer switch.
Important Reminders
Licensed Electrician
This work must be performed by a qualified and licensed electrician.
Permitting
Obtain all necessary permits before starting the work.
Safety: Follow all safety precautions during installation.I hope this comprehensive analysis helps you make the best decision for your project! Good luck! Flag for review