User: MKobylka, Location: Canada
Asked on: Friday, September 19, 2025 at 1:42 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, September 19, 2025 at 2:18 pm EDT
Question: Hello,I am trying to figure out if it possible to add a backup to main the generator in case it does not start. This is for an off-grid set up.Solar Power is the main source of power with a 12kw inverter and battery back upWhen the batteries drop to a certain X determined level the inverter sends a signal to start the generatorThe generator powers all loads to the house and charges batteries.Once the Batteries are charged the generator shuts off and repeats.The inverter acts as the transfer switchThe main generator is a 18kw Generac running on LP. The secondary generator would be a Honda 7000Is there way to monitor if the Generac did not start and in that case would send a signal to the Honda to start?
Yes, it is definitely possible to add a backup generator and create a system that monitors the main generator's starting and switches to the backup if needed. Here's a breakdown of how you can approach this and the components you might need
Core Concept: Monitoring & Automated Transfer
The key is to monitor the main generator's output (or lack thereof) after the start signal has been sent and then trigger the backup generator. This requires a combination of control logic and switching mechanisms.
Here's a possible design
Generator Start Signal
As you already have, your inverter will send a signal to start the Generac when the battery level reaches a certain threshold (X). Let's assume this is a simple on/off signal (e.g., a voltage from a relay).2.
Monitoring the Generac Output
This is crucial. You need a way to detect if the Generac is actually running and producing power after receiving the start signal. Several methods are possible:
Voltage Sensing
A voltage sensor or relay connected to the Generac's output (AC voltage) can detect if it's producing power. This is a common and reliable approach. The sensor would output a signal (e.g., a contact closure) if the voltage is present and within a reasonable range (to avoid false triggers due to a brief start attempt).
Frequency Sensing
Similar to voltage, a frequency sensor can detect if the Generac is producing the correct AC frequency (e.g., 60 Hz in the US). This can be a more precise indicator than just voltage.
Current Sensing
While less common for this specific application, you could use a current sensor on the Generac's output. If the Generac is running and powering a load, it will be drawing current. This might be less reliable if the load is very light after start-up.3.
Timer/Delay
After the inverter sends the start signal to the Generac, introduce a timer. This delay is essential to allow the Generac time to start and stabilize. The timer's duration will depend on the Generac's typical starting time (e.g., 30-60 seconds).4.
Control Logic (Brain of the Operation)
This is where the signals from the voltage sensor and the timer come together. You need something to process these signals and make a decision. Options include:
Programmable Logic Controller (PLC)
PLCs are industrial-grade controllers designed for automation. They are robust and very flexible but can be more complex to program. A small PLC would be ideal for this application.
Microcontroller (Arduino, Raspberry Pi, etc.)
A microcontroller is a smaller, more affordable option. Arduino is particularly popular for DIY projects. You would need to write code to implement the logic. This option requires some programming skills but offers a lot of customization.
Smart Relay/Logic Relay
These are pre-programmed relays with built-in timers and logic functions. They are a good compromise between a PLC and a simple relay. Easy to program with simple logic diagrams. Schneider Electric Zelio Logic and Eaton easyRelay are examples.
Hardwired Relay Logic
Using a combination of relays, timers, and other components, you can build a hardwired logic circuit. This is the most "old-school" approach and can be challenging to design correctly.
The Control Logic needs to do the following
Wait for the timer to expire after the Generac start signal is given. If the Generac's output voltage (or frequency) is not detected after the timer expires, then send a start signal to the Honda generator. If the Generac's output voltage is detected before the timer expires, reset the timer and do nothing (Generac is running).5.
Honda Generator Start Signal
The control logic sends a signal to start the Honda generator when the Generac fails to start. The Honda 7000 typically has an electric start, so you'll need a relay to trigger this start circuit. Important: Consider the starting system requirements of the Honda. Some generators require a momentary start signal, while others need a sustained signal. The control system must provide the correct type of start signal.6.
Transfer Switch (Backup)
Because your Inverter is already acting as the main transfer switch, it is possible to use the existing inverter to take over power from the Honda. This may require some adjustment to the programming of the inverter. If the Inverter cannot take over power, a second transfer switch would be required that switches the house loads from the non-functioning Generac to the Honda. This must be a properly rated Automatic Transfer Switch (ATS) to avoid back-feeding. A 7000-watt generator can handle a significant portion of your home's loads, but it likely won't be able to handle everything the 18kW Generac can. You'll need to consider load management strategies.7.
Safety Interlocks
Very important!
Generac Lockout
Prevent the Honda from starting if the Generac is running. This avoids potential conflicts and damage.
Voltage/Frequency Monitoring of the Honda
Ensure the Honda is producing stable power before connecting it to the house loads.
Proper Grounding
Ensure both generators and the system are properly grounded.
Overcurrent Protection
Make sure your wiring and breakers are appropriately sized for both generators.
Example Implementation (Arduino-Based)
This is a simplified example to illustrate the concept.arduino// Define pin connectionsconst int generacStartPin = 2; // Output from inverter to Generac startconst int generacVoltagePin = 3; // Input from Generac voltage sensor (HIGH if voltage present)const int hondaStartPin = 4; // Output to Honda start relayconst int generacFailedPin = 5; // Output to an indicatorconst unsigned long startDelay = 60000; // Delay in milliseconds (60 seconds)unsigned long startTime;bool generacStarted = false;void setup() {pinMode(generacStartPin, INPUT);pinMode(generacVoltagePin, INPUT_PULLUP); // Use internal pull-up resistorpinMode(hondaStartPin, OUTPUT);pinMode(generacFailedPin, OUTPUT);digitalWrite(hondaStartPin, LOW); // Ensure Honda is not started initiallydigitalWrite(generacFailedPin, LOW); // Ensure Generac Failed isn't started initiallySerial.begin(9600);}void loop() {// Check if Generac start signal is receivedif (digitalRead(generacStartPin) == HIGH && !generacStarted) {Serial.println("Generac Start Signal Received");startTime = millis();generacStarted = true;}// Check if Generac is running after the delayif (generacStarted && (millis() - startTime >= startDelay)) {if (digitalRead(generacVoltagePin) == LOW) { // LOW means NO voltage detectedSerial.println("Generac Failed to Start! Starting Honda");digitalWrite(hondaStartPin, HIGH); // Start HondadigitalWrite(generacFailedPin, HIGH); // Turn Generac Failed Indicator ON// ADD CODE HERE TO ENSURE HONDA CAN START UP BEFORE CUTTING SIGNAL} else {Serial.println("Generac Started Successfully");generacStarted = false;}}delay(100); // Small delay to avoid excessive CPU usage}
Important Considerations
Professional Installation
This project involves working with AC power and complex electrical systems. It's highly recommended that you have a qualified electrician design, install, and test this system to ensure safety and compliance with local codes.
Wiring
Use properly sized and rated wiring for all connections.
Testing
Thoroughly test the system under various load conditions. Simulate a Generac failure to ensure the Honda starts and the transfer switch operates correctly.
Load Management
The Honda 7000 likely has a lower capacity than your Generac. Consider using load management to shed non-essential loads when the Honda is running to prevent overloading it. This can be done through smart outlets or a load shedding controller.
Generator Maintenance
Regularly maintain both generators according to the manufacturer's recommendations.
Remote Monitoring
Consider adding remote monitoring capabilities so you can check the status of the system from a distance.
Components You'll Likely Need
Control Logic (PLC, Microcontroller, Smart Relay)
Choose the option that best matches your skills and budget.
Voltage Sensor
To detect the Generac's output voltage.
Relays
For switching the Honda start signal and other control functions.
Automatic Transfer Switch (ATS)
If needed, based on inverter capabilities.
Timer
If the control logic doesn't have a built-in timer.
Wiring, Connectors, Enclosures
To build and house the system.
Fuses/Circuit Breakers
For safety and protection.
Load Management System (Optional): To shed non-essential loads when the Honda is running.By carefully planning and implementing this system, you can significantly improve the reliability of your off-grid power setup and ensure a continuous power supply even if the main generator fails. Remember, prioritize safety and consult with qualified professionals. Flag for review