User: Little Bill, Location: Tennessee NEC:2017
Asked on: Friday, September 19, 2025 at 5:26 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, September 19, 2025 at 5:27 pm EDT
Question: Had a guy call me to check out a hum and buzzing noise in the panel. The hum seemed to not be anything I would worry about as I've heard that before. However, when breaker for the air handler for the AC unit was turned off and back on, you could hear the buzzing/arcing sound.I checked all the lugs and terminals for breakers and all were tight. There is an outside disconnect so I checked the lugs there and all was good.Also had the POCO come and check their connections and all was good there.The noise seemed to be coming from the main breaker. The panel is a SqD Homeline 200A main breaker. So I was going to contact them.They also wanted me to change out some dimmers for regular switches as their LED lights would sometimes flicker badly when on the dimmer. The dimmers had been changed by me just a few weeks ago. But the guy said the lights started to flicker again. I told him the LED lights, which are the wafer recessed type lights, were probably not working right with the dimmers. The dimmers were 3-way and I didn't have any 3-way regular switches with me.The guy said he would pick some up and change them out.Here's the odd part.He called me a while ago and said he got them changed. He says all the flickering, humming and buzzing have stopped. I knew the flickering would stop, but what would changing dimmers out for regular switches have to do with the arcing/buzzing sound coming from the panel?I told him to keep an eye on it and listen for the arcing sound. I am not convinced that it has stopped!
You're right to be skeptical. While it's great the flickering stopped, the arcing/buzzing in the panel is a serious concern that likely has nothing to do with the dimmer switches. Here's a breakdown of why and what could be happening
Why the Dimmers Aren't the Cause of the Panel Issue:
Different Circuits
The dimmer switches are on a lighting circuit, likely a 15A or 20A breaker. The AC handler breaker is a completely separate, higher-amperage circuit (usually 30A-60A depending on the unit).
Load
Dimmers control the amount of power flowing to the lights. The AC handler breaker controls the entire AC handler load. A malfunctioning dimmer might cause issues on its circuit (flickering, dimming irregularities), but it can't directly create a high-current arcing condition on the main breaker or the AC handler circuit.
Nature of the Issue
Arc faults are usually caused by loose connections, damaged insulation, or other electrical faults. Dimmers don't create those conditions on other circuits.
Possible Explanations for Why the Sound Seems to Have Stopped (and Why It's Probably Temporary)
Coincidence
The arcing might have temporarily subsided on its own. It could be intermittent.
Placebo Effect
The homeowner wants the problem to be fixed, so they're subconsciously less aware of the noise.
He Adjusted Something Without Realizing It
Maybe while fiddling with the light switches, he inadvertently jiggled something related to the panel or AC disconnect (unlikely, but possible).
Temperature/Load Fluctuation
The arcing could be related to the temperature of the panel or the load on the system. Changing the lights could indirectly affect this if it changes the overall house load, but this is a weak explanation.
Simply Didn't Notice
He might not have noticed the buzzing sound.
Why You Need to Investigate Further
Arcing/buzzing in an electrical panel is a serious fire hazard. Here's what you need to do:1.
Go Back ASAP
Don't rely on the homeowner's word. You must personally verify if the noise is truly gone.2.
Turn Off Power and Inspect the Main Breaker
Safety First
ALWAYS turn off the main breaker before touching anything inside the panel. Verify it's off with a meter.
Look Closely at the Main Breaker
Look for signs of overheating, discoloration, melting, or any damage. Pay close attention to the connections on the breaker.
Feel for Heat
Carefully touch the main breaker (AFTER turning off the power) to see if it feels excessively hot.3.
Inspect the AC Handler Breaker Again
Even though you tightened the lugs, double-check. Look for signs of arcing (blackening, burning) around the breaker and the bus bar it connects to.4.
Consider Breaker Replacement
Even if you don't see obvious damage, if you suspect the main breaker or the AC handler breaker is the source of the noise, consider replacing it. Breakers can fail internally.5.
Infrared Camera (If Available)
An infrared camera can help you spot hotspots inside the panel that could indicate loose connections or overheating components.6.
Consult a Specialist
If you're uncomfortable diagnosing the problem or if replacing the breakers doesn't solve it, consult a qualified electrician who specializes in panel repair.7.
Contact SqD (Square D)
As you planned, contacting Square D and describing the situation is a good idea. They might have seen this issue before.
Important Considerations
Age of the Panel
How old is the panel? Older panels are more prone to problems.
Amperage Draw
Is the AC handler drawing more amperage than it's rated for? An overworking AC unit could be stressing the breaker. (Use an amp clamp to check this).
Load Calculation
Has the homeowner added significant electrical loads recently? The panel could be overloaded. A load calculation is a good idea.*
Homeline vs QO
Homeline panels are generally considered a more economical line than Square D's QO line. While they're perfectly safe when installed and maintained correctly, they might be more susceptible to certain types of issues over time.
In Summary:
The dimmer switch replacement is almost certainly unrelated to the arcing/buzzing noise. Don't be lulled into a false sense of security. Go back, thoroughly investigate the panel, and take the necessary steps to ensure the electrical system is safe. The arcing sound is a serious red flag and needs to be addressed immediately. Flag for review