User: Joethemechanic, Location: Hazleton Pa
Asked on: Saturday, September 20, 2025 at 3:17 pm EDT
Answered on: Saturday, September 20, 2025 at 3:20 pm EDT
Question: I've got a ton of these 3 phase molded case breakers that came from a large plant's storeroom that I bought the contents of at auction some years back. S?o mI have no history on them. I made my money back by like tenfold and still have some stuff left, so I don't really have anything into them.So if I wanted to use them, how can they be tested? Are there any reputable companies doing testing and repair? Is it even worth having it done or are they paperweights?
Okay, that's a common situation with auction purchases. Here's a breakdown of how to approach using or disposing of those 3-phase molded case circuit breakers (MCCBs)
The Risks and Considerations
Safety First
You have absolutely no history on these breakers. That means they could be compromised. A faulty breaker can be incredibly dangerous. It might fail to trip under overload or short circuit conditions, leading to fires or equipment damage. Or, it could trip prematurely, causing nuisance outages.
Hidden Damage
Breakers can be damaged by:
Overloads
Repeated overloads can weaken the internal components.
Short Circuits
Severe short circuits can damage contacts and trip mechanisms.
Moisture/Corrosion
Storage in damp environments can lead to corrosion and malfunction.
Age/Deterioration
Even without abuse, the components in a breaker degrade over time (springs lose tension, lubricants dry out, etc.).
Liability
If you install a faulty breaker and it causes damage or injury, you could be held liable. This is especially true if you knew you had no history on the device.
Code Compliance
In most jurisdictions, electrical work (including breaker replacements) must be done by qualified electricians and must comply with local electrical codes. Using untested/uncertified breakers could violate code.
Potential Benefits
Resale Value
If tested and certified good, they do have resale value, especially if they are newer models or specific brands that are in demand.
Personal Use
If you are qualified and fully understand the risks, tested breakers could be used for personal projects.
How to Approach Testing
Testing MCCBs effectively requires specialized equipment and expertise. Here's a breakdown of the testing needed:1. Visual Inspection
This is the first step:
Exterior
Look for cracks in the case, signs of overheating (discoloration, melting), loose parts, or corrosion.
Contacts
If possible (sometimes you can get a view inside), check the contacts for pitting, burning, or excessive wear.
Markings
Ensure the breaker's markings (voltage, amperage, interrupting rating) are legible.2.
Insulation Resistance Test (Megger Test)
This verifies the insulation between the breaker's terminals and the case. A low insulation resistance reading indicates potential leakage and a high risk of failure. You'll need a megohmmeter (often called a "megger"). This is a standard electrical testing tool. Typically, you'd want a reading of several megohms or higher.3.
Contact Resistance Test (Micro-Ohmmeter)
This measures the resistance of the current path through the breaker's contacts when closed. High contact resistance can cause heat buildup and voltage drop. You'll need a micro-ohmmeter.4.
Trip Time Testing
This is the most important test. It verifies that the breaker trips within the specified time-current curve published by the manufacturer. You must inject specific currents into the breaker to simulate overload and short-circuit conditions and measure the trip time. This requires specialized breaker testing equipment:
Primary Injection Testing
This injects high currents (sometimes hundreds or thousands of amps) directly into the breaker's main terminals. It's the most accurate way to test the breaker's overall performance. This equipment is expensive and requires specialized training to operate safely.
Secondary Injection Testing
This injects a lower current into the breaker's trip unit (if it has one). It's less comprehensive than primary injection but can be useful for testing specific trip functions.
Reputable Testing and Repair Companies
Yes, there are many reputable companies that specialize in testing, refurbishment, and repair of circuit breakers. Here's how to find them: Google Search
Search for "circuit breaker testing services" + your city or region.
Electrical Testing Associations
Organizations like NETA (InterNational Electrical Testing Association) and PEA (Professional Electrical Apparatus Reconditioning League) have directories of accredited testing companies. Look for companies that are NETA-certified.
Electrical Contractors
Some large electrical contractors have their own testing departments.
Switchgear Manufacturers
Some manufacturers offer testing and refurbishment services for their own equipment.
Is Testing Worth It?
This is the key question. Here's how to decide: Cost of Testing
Get quotes from several testing companies. The cost can range from \$50-\$100+ per breaker for basic testing to several hundred dollars for comprehensive testing and refurbishment. The cost will depend on the size/type of breaker, and the amount of testing you want to do.
Breaker Value
Research the current market value of the specific breaker models you have. Consider these factors:
Age
Older breakers are generally worth less.
Brand
Some brands are more desirable than others.
Amperage/Voltage
High-amperage and high-voltage breakers are typically worth more.
Interrupting Rating
A higher interrupting rating (e.g., 65kA, 100kA) generally increases the value.
Condition (assumed)
Assume the worst-case scenario; that is, assume they are in unknown condition.
Quantity
Testing a large batch of breakers is more cost-effective per unit than testing just a few.
Your Needs
Resale
If you want to resell them, testing and certification are essential to get a good price and avoid liability. Buyers will want proof of proper functioning.
Personal Use
If you are qualified and comfortable with the risk, you might consider using a few tested breakers for your own projects (but proceed with extreme caution).
Scrap Value
If testing is too expensive relative to the breaker's value, you can sell them for scrap. Breakers contain copper and other metals.
Recommendations1. Start with Visual Inspection
Carefully inspect all the breakers. Discard any that show obvious signs of damage.2.
Identify Breakers
Make a detailed inventory of the breakers, noting the manufacturer, model number, voltage, amperage, interrupting rating, and any other relevant information.3.
Research Value
Use online resources (eBay, industrial supply websites) to get an idea of the current market value of the breakers.4.
Get Testing Quotes
Contact several reputable testing companies and get quotes for testing. Explain that you have a quantity of used breakers with unknown history.5.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Compare the cost of testing to the potential resale value of the breakers.6.
Make a Decision
If testing is cost-effective
Proceed with testing. Consider testing a small sample first to get an idea of the overall condition of the batch.
If testing is not cost-effective
Consider selling the breakers for scrap or donating them to a vocational school or training program (where they can be used for educational purposes). Do not sell them to someone who intends to install them without proper testing.7.
Documentation
Keep detailed records of all testing results, repairs, and certifications.
Crucial Warning
Never install a breaker with an unknown history in a critical application without thorough testing and certification. The risk of failure is too high. Do not attempt to test high-voltage/high-current breakers yourself unless you are a qualified electrical technician with the proper equipment and training.* Always follow all applicable safety procedures when working with electrical equipment.
By following these steps, you can make an informed decision about how to handle your inventory of used circuit breakers and minimize your risk. Good luck! Flag for review