Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Building or structure disconnecting means

User: hhsting, Location: Glen bunie, md, us

Asked on: Sunday, September 21, 2025 at 12:24 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, September 21, 2025 at 12:24 pm EDT

Question: I have Multibuilding Campus Style Complexes that comply with NEC 2017 Article 695.3(C). I have a customer-owned transformer that feeds the fire pump to the Fire Pump Building. The customer-owned transformer is located outside, and secondary conductors come into the Fire Pump Building fire pump controller disconnecting means. The customer-owned transformer is located outside, about 40 feet or more from the Fire Pump Building. The Fire pump Building also has another feeder feeding into Panelboard A with a main breaker for lights, receptacles, and unit heaters.So the fire pump controller disconnecting means I don’t see it as building or structure disconnecting means, because it just disconnects the fire pump. The Panelboard A main breaker is also not a building or structure disconnecting means because it disconnects the light, power, and unit heaters, but not the fire pump.My question is for the enforcement of NEC 2017 Article 250.32(B)(1) “…An equipment grounding conductor, as described in 250.118, shall be run with the supply conductors and be connected to the building or structure disconnecting means and to the grounding electrode…”. What would be considered as my building or structure disconnecting means in my case?

You've accurately identified the issue and the relevant code section. Let's break down why you're struggling to find a "building or structure disconnecting means" in this scenario, and what your options are based on NEC 2017.

Understanding the Problem

Article 250.32(B)(1) is designed to ensure proper grounding in separately derived buildings or structures. The key words are "building or structure disconnecting means." The intention is to ground the electrical system at the point where power enters the building.In your case, the problem is that the fire pump system is intentionally designed to bypass the building's normal service entry. The fire pump receives power directly from a dedicated transformer, and that connection is intended to be as direct and reliable as possible. Fire Pump Disconnect

You are correct that the fire pump controller disconnect is
not the building disconnecting means. It's simply a disconnect for the fire pump itself.

Panelboard A Main Breaker

Similarly, the Panelboard A main breaker is not the building disconnecting means for the fire pump system. It controls power to other building loads, not the fire pump.

So, What's the "Building or Structure Disconnecting Means" in Your Situation?


Since the fire pump system is specifically designed with its own power source, bypassing the building's main service, you likely do not have a "building or structure disconnecting means" that applies to the fire pump feed as contemplated by 250.32(B)(1).

Possible Solutions and Interpretations (Consult with the AHJ!)

Given the specific nature of your fire pump system and the intent of the code, here are a few interpretations, none of which should be implemented without approval from your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ).1. The Transformer as the "Disconnecting Means"

This is likely the most applicable interpretation, but it will require AHJ acceptance. Since the transformer is dedicated to the fire pump and located outside the building, and the connection is direct and the transformer is customer owned, the AHJ may consider the transformer to be acting as the equivalent of the "disconnecting means" for the purposes of the fire pump system. In this case: You would ground the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) coming from the transformer at the transformer itself, and run that EGC along with the secondary conductors to the fire pump controller disconnect. The grounding electrode system required by 250.32(A) would be located at the transformer. This approach keeps the fire pump system isolated from other ground paths in the building, which is consistent with the intent of Article 695.2.

250.32 (A) Grounding Electrode Connection
(A) Grounding Electrode System. The grounding electrode system at each separate building or structure shall be made as described in 250.50. One or more of the following electrodes shall be used:(1) Metal water pipe as described in 250.52(B)(1)(2) Metal frame of the building or structure as described in 250.52(B)(2)(3) Concrete-encased electrode as described in 250.52(B)(3)(4) Ground ring as described in 250.52(B)(4)(5) Rod and pipe electrodes as described in 250.52(B)(5)(6) Other listed electrodesIf you have any of these electrodes in your fire pump building, and the panelboard A is grounded to one of these electrodes, it is possible that the AHJ may accept connecting the EGC coming from the transformer to the Panelboard A ground. This option is highly dependent on the local AHJ.
3. Petition for Variance

If none of the above options are satisfactory to the AHJ, you may need to petition for a variance. A variance is a formal request to be exempted from a particular code requirement. You'll need to justify why the code requirement is impractical or unsafe in your specific situation and propose an alternative solution that provides an equivalent level of safety.

Important Considerations



Fire Pump Specific Requirements

Always remember that Article 695 (Fire Pumps) takes precedence over other code sections if there is a conflict. The paramount goal is to ensure the reliable operation of the fire pump.

Coordination with Fire Protection Engineer

Discuss this issue with your fire protection engineer. They can provide valuable insights into the overall fire protection system design and may have specific grounding recommendations.


Documentation

Document all discussions with the AHJ and any interpretations or variances granted.

In Summary

Your situation is unique because of the dedicated power source for the fire pump. Article 250.32(B)(1) is designed for typical separately derived buildings with a main service. Your best approach is to:1.

Consult with your AHJ.
2. Propose grounding the EGC from the transformer to the transformer.3. Be prepared to discuss alternatives and potentially request a variance if necessary.

Good luck! Remember that the AHJ's interpretation is final, and the goal is to ensure a safe and reliable fire protection system. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question