User: clemver, Location: PA
Asked on: Sunday, September 21, 2025 at 12:39 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, September 21, 2025 at 12:40 pm EDT
Question: Was doing a kitchen remodel, all new wiring. All dimmers were lutron caseta diva dimmers. Installed and powered up dimmer 1 for the recessed lights 1st, (12) wafer LEDs. Everything with those was working perfectly fine for a few weeks while I waited for the tape light.Installed and powered up tape light 1, everything was fine.Installed and powered up tape light 2.Then the ceiling lights started strobing. At 100% it was noticeable but not severe. At 50% it was straight up strobe lighting.When I had only 1 tape light section lit, didnt matter wich one, ceiling lights were fine. As soon as I had both tape lights on at the same time as the ceiling lights, ceiling would strobe. Other than the constant power that jumped from box to box they were not connected in any way.Each tape light dimmer controlled its own 24v dimmable power supply. At no point did I have issues with the tape light or dimming them, only the ceiling lights.Since the caseta dimmers dont use a nuetral, I swapped out the recessed lighting dimmer with a standard diva dimmer with a neutral connection and everything was fine. I've heard that dimmers that require a neutral can fix weird issues with lighting but I dont know or understand enough about interference or backfeed to know what the actual issue was. Any insight would be appreciated.
Okay, this is a fascinating problem with a few potential culprits. It sounds like you've done a good job isolating the issue. Let's break down the possible reasons why adding that second tape light caused your recessed lights to start strobing with the Caseta dimmer.
Understanding the Key Players & Problem Lutron Caseta Diva (No Neutral)
These dimmers are designed to "steal" a very small amount of current through the load (your lights) even when dimmed way down. This is how they power themselves when no neutral is available.
Standard Diva (Neutral)
These dimmers have a direct connection to the neutral wire, so they don't need to steal current through the load.
Wafer LEDs (Recessed Lights)
These are generally very efficient and have some level of internal power supply and dimming circuitry.
Tape Lights & Dimmable Power Supplies
The tape lights have their own 24V power supplies that you can dim via the Caseta dimmers.
The Strobe
The key symptom is that the recessed lights only strobe when both tape lights are turned on. This suggests an interaction between the two circuits created when they're both active.
Possible Causes (and Explanations)
Here are the most likely reasons, in order of likelihood, in my opinion:1. Shared Neutral/Return Path (Least Likely with new wiring, but worth checking!) The Problem
Even with new wiring, it's possible there's some unexpected shared neutral or ground connection somewhere in the circuit. When both tape light power supplies are drawing current, it can create a voltage fluctuation on the shared return path. The Caseta dimmer on the recessed lights is extremely sensitive to voltage changes as this is how it operates for dimming.
How It Affects the Caseta Dimmer
The Caseta needs a clean, stable return path to function correctly. If the neutral is "dirty" or fluctuating, it can cause the dimmer's internal circuitry to malfunction, resulting in the strobing.
Why the Neutral Dimmer Fixed It
The neutral-wired dimmer provides a direct path back to the panel. It's not relying on the shared neutral and is thus less sensitive to voltage fluctuations.
How to Check
Carefully inspect all wiring connections in the boxes involved (especially where the dimmers are). Look for accidental neutrals touching each other or any grounds that might be bridged together where they shouldn't be. Confirm that the neutrals are truly isolated to their respective circuits at the panel. Confirm that the grounds are connected correctly and securely at the panel.2. Inrush Current and Overload (Likely) The Problem
When the power supplies for the tape lights turn on, they initially draw a large amount of current (inrush current). This inrush current may cause a momentary voltage drop on the circuit, especially if the circuit is close to its maximum load. With modern LED lighting the circuit shouldn't be overloaded but this is worth checking.
How It Affects the Caseta Dimmer
Caseta Dimmers might struggle with low voltage and produce a strobe effect due to the power saving technologies they use to save electricity.
Why the Neutral Dimmer Fixed It
The neutral-wired dimmer, being less sensitive to minor voltage fluctuations, doesn't react the same way.
How to Check
Use an amp meter to check the current draw on the circuit when all the lights are on. Ensure it's well below the circuit breaker's rating. Try staggering the turn-on of the tape lights. If turning them on sequentially eliminates the strobing, inrush current is likely the issue. Consider using "soft-start" power supplies for the tape lights. These power supplies limit the inrush current.3.
Harmonics/Interference from Power Supplies (Possible) The Problem
LED power supplies, especially cheaper ones, can generate harmonic distortion on the AC line. This "dirty" power can interfere with the sensitive electronics in the Caseta dimmer.
How It Affects the Caseta Dimmer
The dimmer's internal control circuitry might misinterpret the distorted AC waveform, leading to erratic behavior.
Why the Neutral Dimmer Fixed It
The neutral-wired dimmer might have better filtering or be less susceptible to the harmonic distortion.
How to Check
This is difficult to diagnose without specialized equipment (an oscilloscope or power quality analyzer).
Try a different brand or model of tape light power supply. If the problem goes away, the original power supplies were likely the culprit.4. Capacitive Coupling (Less Likely, but Possible) The Problem
If the wiring for the tape lights and the recessed lights runs parallel for a significant distance, there's a chance of capacitive coupling. This means that voltage changes on one circuit can induce a small voltage on the other.
How It Affects the Caseta Dimmer
The Caseta dimmer might be picking up these small induced voltages, causing it to malfunction.
Why the Neutral Dimmer Fixed It
The neutral-wired dimmer might be less sensitive to this type of interference.
How to Check
This is very difficult to diagnose. Try rerouting the wiring so that the tape light and recessed light circuits are physically separated as much as possible.
Troubleshooting Steps to Take1. Double-Check All Wiring
This is always step one. Make absolutely sure all connections are tight, secure, and correct. Pay extra attention to neutral and ground connections.2.
Experiment
Turn on only one of the tape lights and see if the strobing occurs. This helps isolate if one particular power supply is the problem. Try dimming the tape lights to different levels. Does the strobing get better or worse? Try temporarily connecting the tape lights to a completely different circuit breaker. This will help rule out issues with the original circuit breaker or wiring upstream.3.
Replace Suspect Components
If you suspect one of the tape light power supplies, try replacing it with a different brand or model. If you have another Caseta dimmer, try swapping it in for the recessed lights dimmer. This will rule out a defective dimmer.
Important Safety Note: When working with electrical wiring, always turn off the circuit breaker to the circuit you're working on. If you're not comfortable working with electrical wiring, hire a qualified electrician.Let me know if you try any of these troubleshooting steps or have any other information. I'm happy to help you narrow down the cause and find a solution. Flag for review