Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Comparative Flow Sensors?

User: travish, Location: Central North Carolina

Asked on: Tuesday, September 23, 2025 at 3:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, September 23, 2025 at 3:50 pm EDT

Question: Hey,I have an application at work I need some help with. We have a 45 ton chiller (water) that is the cooling source for an injection molding plant. We have 11 injection machines that we run over night unattended. I would like to verify water flow both to and from each machine, to know that there isn't a water leak at the machines. So I need to know volume of flow, to and from, I need analog feedback. I would compare the feedback from "supply" line with "return" line at each machine with a plc, and turn off the water to the machine with an Asco Valve, if there was a substantial difference between the 2 I would know there was a water leak.The logic and control is very simple, but not easy to pay for. I was shocked at how expensive flow sensors with feedback are. I would need 22 sensors to complete the project. is there an economical way to accomplish this? or does anyone know an easier way to do it?thanks for any adviceTravis

You're right, instrument-grade flow sensors with analog feedback can be surprisingly expensive, especially when needing so many. Let's break down the problem and explore some alternative and potentially more cost-effective approaches.

Understanding the Challenge Cost

22 flow sensors + PLC integration = significant upfront investment.


Complexity

Installation of 22 flow sensors + wiring to PLC = significant labor.

Reliability

22 more points of failure in your system.


Accuracy Requirement

You don't need super-precise flow measurement, you primarily need leak detection. A substantial difference is what you're looking for.

Potential Solutions and Ideas


Here are some ideas ranging from lower-cost but less accurate to more sophisticated, but potentially more effective long-term.1. Differential Pressure (DP) Measurement with Orifice Plates/Venturi



Concept

Use a simple orifice plate or venturi in the line to create a pressure drop proportional to flow. Measure the differential pressure across the orifice with a DP transmitter.


Pros

DP transmitters are generally cheaper than flow sensors. Orifice plates/Venturi are very durable and have no moving parts. Relatively simple to install.

Cons

Less accurate than dedicated flow meters. Accuracy will be adequate for leak detection. Requires calibration for your specific fluid and pipe size. Needs straight pipe runs upstream and downstream of the orifice.

How to Implement

Calculate the required orifice size for your expected flow rate range. There are online calculators for this. Install the orifice plate/venturi in each supply and return line. Connect DP transmitters across each orifice. Calibrate the transmitters. Program your PLC to monitor the pressure difference. Set an alarm threshold for what you consider a significant difference (e.g., a certain percentage drop in return pressure compared to supply).2.

Paddle Wheel Flow Sensors (with a Caveat)



Concept

A paddle wheel spins in the flow, and the rotation is measured.

Pros

Generally less expensive than other flow meter technologies. Easy to install in-line. Can output a frequency signal directly proportional to flow (easy for PLC integration).

Cons

Can be less accurate, especially at very low flow rates (which may be relevant for leak detection). Moving parts mean potential for wear and tear. Can be sensitive to debris in the fluid.

Caveat

I mention this for completeness, but I'm hesitant to recommend them for this application due to accuracy concerns and potential for fouling in an industrial environment. If you
do consider them, look for industrial-grade versions specifically designed for dirty water.3.

Ultrasonic Clamp-On Flow Meters (for Monitoring, Not Control)



Concept

Clamp-on sensors measure flow through the pipe wall, without direct contact with the fluid.

Pros

Non-invasive installation (no pipe cutting). No pressure drop. Can be used on a variety of pipe sizes and materials. Portable units allow you to move the meter around to different machines.

Cons

Typically more expensive per sensor than the DP method. Can be affected by air bubbles or solids in the fluid. Signal can be weaker on larger pipes.

How to Implement (Different Approach)

Instead of installing 22 sensors, consider buying one or two portable clamp-on ultrasonic flow meters. During setup, measure the flow rates at each machine's supply and return lines manually. Record these "normal" flow rates in your PLC system (or in a spreadsheet). Your PLC then monitors the chiller system performance: overall chiller outlet temp/pressures, chiller inlet temp/pressures, and pump amp draws. If the chiller system experiences a change, you can then manually check each machine with the portable flow meter to identify leaks. This approach is less automated, but significantly reduces upfront cost.4.

Pressure Monitoring Only (Indirect Indication)



Concept

Monitor the supply pressure at each machine. A sudden drop in pressure could indicate a leak.

Pros

Very inexpensive (pressure transducers are much cheaper than flow sensors). Simple installation.

Cons

Indirect indication – doesn't directly measure flow. May not be sensitive enough to detect small leaks. Pressure changes can be caused by other factors (e.g., changes in chiller load, pump performance).

How to Implement

Install pressure transducers at the supply line to each machine. Establish a baseline pressure for each machine under normal operating conditions. Monitor the pressure and trigger an alarm if it drops below a threshold.5.

Flow Indicators (Visual)



Concept

Install a clear tube with a ball or paddle that is visible and indicates flow.

Pros

Very inexpensive. No electricity needed.

Cons

Requires manual observation - not automated. Provides only a rough indication of flow, not precise measurement.

How to Implement

Install in supply and return lines. Operators visually check flow indicators during routine rounds. Use in conjunction with pressure monitoring for additional feedback.6.

Modified Conductivity Sensors
Concept

Place a "high" and a "low" conductivity sensor in the return line. Place a known, small amount of salt in the supply line. If a leak occurs, the high and low conductivity sensors will experience the salt concentration changes at different times, which could indicate a leak.


Pros

Sensors are very inexpensive. Requires only small amount of salt.

Cons

Will require some experimentation. The system will require additional salt periodically. May not be accurate.

Which Approach is Best?


It depends on your budget, accuracy needs, and level of automation desired. Here's a quick summary: Lowest Cost, Least Automation

Pressure monitoring only or visual flow indicators (supplemented with occasional manual checks).


Good Balance of Cost and Automation

Differential pressure measurement with orifice plates/venturi. This is likely your best bet.

Higher Cost, Most Flexible (But Fewer Sensors)

Portable clamp-on ultrasonic flow meter for periodic checks.


Highest Cost, Most Automation

Dedicated flow sensors with analog output (but you already know this is expensive).

Important Considerations



Fluid Compatibility

Ensure any sensors you choose are compatible with the water in your system (especially if it contains additives).


Pipe Size

Select sensors appropriate for the pipe size in your system.

Accuracy vs. Cost

Think about how much accuracy you
really need for leak detection. A ballpark figure might be sufficient.

Maintenance

Consider the maintenance requirements of each sensor type.

Recommendations
1. Start with a pilot project. Implement the differential pressure method (orifice plates + DP transmitters) on one machine. Evaluate its performance and accuracy before investing in the full system. This will help you refine your design and calibration.2. Thoroughly evaluate the clamp-on ultrasonic flow meter option. Borrow or rent a unit to test its accuracy and reliability in your specific environment.3. Consider pressure monitoring as a first line of defense. It's a cheap and easy way to get some indication of potential problems.By carefully considering these options and starting with a small-scale test, you can find a leak detection solution that meets your needs without breaking the bank. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question