User: Coper, Location: united states
Asked on: Wednesday, September 24, 2025 at 7:16 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, September 24, 2025 at 7:39 am EDT
Question: Hello everyone,I’m relatively new in the estimating / contracting business, and I’ve faced some challenges getting bids to be both competitive and profitable. I’d like to learn from the community’s experience so I can improve my process.Here’s what I’m currently doing:I take off material lists from drawingsUse standard labor units (from manuals or past experience)Add overhead, profit margin, and contingenciesReview past projects to see cost variancesStill, I often see major deviations between my estimates and actual job costs.Questions I’d love your input on:What are the most common sources of error in estimates (hidden work, site conditions, delays, etc.) that new estimators might overlook?How do you build / refine your “labor hour database” for your team so your estimates get more accurate with time?Which estimating software tools do you find worth the investment (especially for small to mid-size contractors)?How do you include “risk / contingency” in your estimates (a flat %, line item, etc.)?When you finish a job, how do you compare estimate vs actual, and how do you use that feedback to adjust future bids?Thank you in advance for sharing your experience looking forward to learning from you all.
Okay, welcome to the exciting world of estimating! It's a continuous learning process, and your willingness to learn and adapt is the key to success. Let's break down your questions and provide some helpful insights
1. Most Common Sources of Error in Estimates (Especially for New Estimators):
You've identified some key areas, but let's dig deeper: Hidden/Unforeseen Conditions
This is HUGE. New estimators often don't have the experience to "see" problems that are likely to occur.
Subsurface Conditions
Soil composition, water table levels, existing utilities (especially underground). Always include some allowance for exploratory work or a geotechnical report. Assume the worst.
Existing Structures
Demolition complexities, unforeseen structural issues, asbestos/lead abatement (depending on the age of the building). Thorough site visits are crucial. Take pictures and videos.
Code Compliance
Changing regulations, requirements for upgrades not explicitly stated in the drawings. Verify the most current codes and ordinances with the city.
Incomplete/Ambiguous Drawings and Specifications
Assumptions
Never assume anything. If something is unclear, always get clarification in writing from the architect or owner. Document your Request For Information (RFI) process meticulously.
Scope Creep
Define the scope clearly in your proposal. If there is an area of the project that you did not include in the bid based on something that the architect told you, make sure to put it in the proposal. For example, "Plumbing fixture upgrades were not included in this bid based on verbal communication with the architect."
Underestimating Labor
This is where experience truly shines.
Access and Workspace
Is it a tight job site? Will workers have to carry materials long distances? Limited parking? All these affect productivity.
Crew Experience
Are you using your most efficient crews, or newer, less experienced ones? Factor in a productivity adjustment.
Weather Delays
Especially for exterior work, factor in realistic weather downtime.
Material Handling
Time spent moving materials around the site, staging, and protecting them is often underestimated.
Subcontractor Issues
Subcontractor Scope Gaps
Make sure exactly what each subcontractor is responsible for is defined to avoid overlaps or gaps in coverage.
Subcontractor Defaults
Have backup subcontractors in mind.
Permitting Delays
Factor in potential delays with permits and inspections, especially in busy municipalities.
2. Building/Refining Your Labor Hour Database
Detailed Time Tracking
This is the foundation.
Implement a System
Use a time tracking system (software or even simple spreadsheets) that breaks down labor hours by task and phase of the project. Force your field teams to use it consistently.
Track EVERYTHING
Don't just track "plumbing labor." Track "installing toilet," "running pipe," "testing system," etc. The more granular, the better.
Project Post-Mortems
Compare Estimated vs. Actual
At the end of each job, meticulously compare your estimated labor hours for each task to the actual hours spent. Analyze the variances.
Identify Root Causes
Why was the estimate off? Was it inaccurate labor units, unforeseen conditions, poor crew performance, or a combination? Document the reasons.
Adjust Labor Units Accordingly
Calculate New Averages
As you collect data, calculate average labor hours per unit (e.g., hours per square foot of drywall, hours per linear foot of piping).
Segment by Project Type
Labor units will vary depending on the type of project (residential, commercial, renovation, new construction). Keep separate databases for each.
Account for Complexity
Develop factors to adjust labor units based on the complexity of the work (e.g., difficult access adds 10%, intricate detailing adds 15%).
Regularly Review and Update
Labor costs, regulations, and techniques change. Always update your database.
3. Estimating Software Tools
For small to mid-size contractors, here are some options that offer good value:
Cloud-Based Options (Good for Collaboration)
Buildertrend/CoConstruct
More than just estimating; they offer project management, CRM, and client communication features. A good all-in-one option.
Procore
Project management software that can be used to track estimates, budgets, and actual costs.
Excel
You would be amazed at how many estimators use excel still. Excel is affordable and highly customizable to your needs. If you learn to use formulas you can build your own powerful estimating tool.
PlanSwift
Easy to learn, fast takeoff, and integration with popular pricing databases.
Stack
Cloud-based, modern interface, good for collaboration.
Key Considerations When Choosing Software
Ease of Use
If it's too complicated, your team won't use it.
Integration
Can it integrate with your accounting software (QuickBooks, Xero)?
Takeoff Capabilities
How easily can you take off quantities from digital plans?
Pricing Databases
Does it integrate with pricing databases like RSMeans or Craftsman?
Reporting
Can it generate the reports you need (e.g., cost breakdowns, material lists)?
4. Including Risk/Contingency in Estimates
There are several approaches:
Percentage of Total Cost
A common approach.
Vary the Percentage
Don't use a flat percentage for every job. Adjust it based on the complexity and risk of the project. Low Risk (Simple, Familiar): 5-10% Medium Risk (Some Unforeseen Potential): 10-15% High Risk (Complex, Many Unknowns): 15-20%+
Line Item for Specific Risks
This is more transparent and targeted.
Example
"Contingency for Subsurface Conditions - $5,000"
Justification
Be able to justify each contingency line item.
Escalation Clauses
For volatile material prices (lumber, steel, etc.), include an escalation clause that allows you to adjust the price if the cost of those materials increases significantly.
Combination
Often the best approach. Use a percentage for general unforeseen issues and line items for specific identified risks.
Transparency
Be upfront with the client about your contingency. Explain that it's there to cover unexpected issues and protect both of you.
5. Comparing Estimate vs. Actual and Adjusting Future Bids
This is the most crucial step. Without this feedback loop, you're flying blind.
Job Costing System
You need a system to track actual costs against your budget. Most accounting software (QuickBooks, Xero) have job costing features.
Detailed Variance Analysis
Compare Line by Line
Compare the estimated cost for each line item (labor, materials, subcontractors) to the actual cost.
Identify Significant Variances
Focus on the line items where there's a large difference between the estimate and actual.
Investigate the Root Cause
Why was the estimate off? Was it incorrect quantities, inaccurate labor rates, material price increases, waste, theft, or inefficiencies?
Document Lessons Learned
Create a Database
Keep a log of the variances and the reasons behind them. This becomes a valuable resource for future estimating.
Share with the Team
Discuss the lessons learned with your field teams and estimators.
Adjust Future Bids
Refine Labor Units
Use the data to refine your labor hour database.
Update Material Prices
Keep your material price database up-to-date.
Increase Contingency
If you consistently underestimate certain types of work, increase your contingency for those projects.
Adjust Your Estimating Process
Are there areas where you need to be more thorough or ask more questions?
Key Takeaways
Experience is the Best Teacher
The more projects you estimate and track, the better you'll become.
Communication is Key
Talk to your field teams, subcontractors, and suppliers. Get their input on costs and potential issues.
Never Stop Learning
Attend industry seminars, read trade publications, and network with other contractors.
Be Meticulous
Pay attention to detail, double-check your work, and always ask questions.*
Document Everything: Document your assumptions, your clarifications, and your change orders.Estimating is a blend of art and science. The science is the numbers and the software. The art is applying your experience and judgment to account for the unpredictable factors that can impact a project. Good luck! Flag for review