Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Different amp readings

User: stephen@spelectric, Location: Texas

Asked on: Thursday, September 25, 2025 at 9:26 am EDT
Answered on: Sunday, September 28, 2025 at 3:25 am EDT

Question: Good morningHere is my question - we have 2 different industrial recycling lines. I am using a fluke 376c meterThere is a 2000a MDP 480v 4wWe have a 10 section 26 motor MCC5 total vfd's 2 powerflex 525 and 3 powerflex 7551 - 422hp motor1 - 177hp motor1 - 40hp motorWhen i use my meter to read the total draw on this equipment i am reading 134amps each phase. The readings from each vfd and mcc are totaling 400+ amps.I can read 175a on the load side of the 422hp motor vfd without a load and on the line side i read 30amps each phase. Can anyone help me out with what is going on? I know the readings we are getting on the load side are correct but why is the line side so low?? In Speaking to a engineer he said our voltage and current are out phase and the PF is our problem. We other engineers who dont seem to be concerned with the problem.

Good morning! This is a complex situation, but we can break it down and explore potential causes and solutions. The discrepancy between your meter readings at the MDP and the sum of the individual loads is definitely a concern. Let's address the points you've raised

Understanding the Problem
Discrepancy

The core issue is the significant difference between the 134A measured at the MDP and the 400+A sum of the individual loads. This indicates something is fundamentally wrong with your measurement approach or the system itself.


VFD Line vs. Load

The 175A reading on the load side of the 422HP VFD (even without a load) is highly suspicious. A VFD should not draw that much current without the motor actually doing work. The 30A reading on the line side, however, seems relatively more plausible but needs further examination.

Engineer's Perspective (Power Factor)

Your engineer suggesting that out-of-phase voltage and current (low power factor) is contributing to the problem is highly relevant. Power factor significantly impacts the relationship between apparent power (kVA) and real power (kW).

Possible Causes and Troubleshooting Steps


Let's go through a methodical troubleshooting process:1. Verify Meter Accuracy and Placement



Meter Calibration

Ensure your Fluke 376C is properly calibrated. An uncalibrated meter can provide inaccurate readings.

Jaw Placement

Double-check the jaw placement around the conductors. Make sure the jaws are fully closed and properly aligned. Stray magnetic fields from nearby conductors can influence the readings.


Conductor Size and Meter Range

Verify the conductor size is within the Fluke 376C's specifications. Also, confirm you're using the appropriate current range on the meter. If the current is too low for the selected range, the reading may be inaccurate.

True RMS Meter

The Fluke 376C
is a True RMS meter, which is essential for accurately measuring the non-sinusoidal waveforms produced by VFDs. However, double-check the meter's settings to ensure it's set to True RMS AC current measurement.

Harmonics

VFD's create harmonics that can skew readings. Harmonics can falsely elevate current readings. If your meter has harmonic measurement capabilities, check the total harmonic distortion (THD) of the current.2.

Investigate the 422HP VFD



VFD Configuration

Carefully review the VFD parameters for the 422HP motor. Confirm that the motor nameplate data (voltage, current, frequency, horsepower, speed) is accurately programmed into the VFD.


VFD Status

Check the VFD's fault history and current status. Are there any active faults or warnings that might indicate a problem? Look for overcurrent, overvoltage, undervoltage, or drive fault warnings.

Motor Insulation Test

Disconnect the motor leads from the VFD output and perform a motor insulation resistance test (Megger test). A low insulation resistance can indicate a motor winding fault, which can draw excessive current.


VFD Output Voltage Balance

With the motor disconnected, check the output voltage balance of the VFD. The three phases should be nearly equal in voltage. Significant imbalances can indicate a problem with the VFD's output stage.

VFD Input Voltage

Check the voltage at the input of the VFD. Low voltage can cause the VFD to draw more current to maintain the output power.


Braking Resistor
: A braking resistor issue can falsely inflate the current.3. Power Factor and Reactive Power



Power Factor Measurement

Use a power quality analyzer (ideally) or a meter capable of measuring power factor to determine the power factor at the MDP. A low power factor (significantly below 0.8) indicates a large reactive power component.


Reactive Power Correction

If the power factor is low, consider installing power factor correction capacitors. These capacitors supply reactive power locally, reducing the current drawn from the utility. This would be done at the MDP.

Harmonic Mitigation

VFDs generate harmonic currents that can distort the voltage waveform and worsen the power factor. Consider installing harmonic filters to reduce the harmonic content in the electrical system.


VFD Line Reactors

Verify if line reactors are installed on the line (input) side of the VFDs. These reactors help to reduce harmonic distortion and improve power factor.4.

Simultaneous Measurements



Synchronized Readings

The most accurate way to determine the system's current draw is to take simultaneous current readings at the MDP
and at each of the individual loads (VFDs, MCC sections) using multiple meters at the same time. This eliminates the possibility of load fluctuations affecting the measurements.

Data Logging

If possible, use data-logging meters to record the current at the MDP and at key loads over a period of time (e.g., 24 hours). This will provide a better understanding of the load profile and identify any peak demands or unusual current fluctuations.5.

MCC Review
Load List

Verify the load list against each starter and ensure the motor is not oversized for the equipment that it's connected to.


Meter each starter individually to confirm the load to the correct equipment
Explanation of the Discrepancy

Here's why your total readings might be so different: Power Factor

The engineer is likely correct. VFDs, especially under light load, can have very low power factors. This means a significant portion of the current is reactive current (VARs), which doesn't contribute to real power (kW) and doesn't show up directly in the overall amp draw as simply the sum of the individual loads.


Harmonics

VFDs inject harmonics into the power system. Your Fluke 376C will measure the RMS value of the fundamental frequency current plus the harmonics. The harmonics contribute to the total current but may not be accurately reflected in the individual load calculations if those measurements aren't also taking harmonics into account.

Inrush Currents

Motor starting (even with VFDs) can cause temporary inrush currents that may not be captured by your spot measurements.


Load Diversity

Not all motors are running at their full rated load simultaneously. This "diversity factor" means the total demand current is less than the sum of the individual motor currents.

Measurement Error

As mentioned earlier, meter placement, calibration, and reading errors can contribute to the discrepancy.


VFD Efficiency

VFDs aren't 100% efficient. There are losses within the VFD that contribute to the current draw.*

Wiring Errors

While less likely, a wiring error somewhere in the system could cause unexpected current flow.

Recommended Actions
1. Prioritize Safety

Before working on any electrical equipment, ensure proper lockout/tagout procedures are followed.2.

Repeat Measurements Carefully

Double-check all your meter readings, paying close attention to meter placement, range, and settings.3.

Focus on the 422HP VFD

Investigate the 422HP VFD in detail. Its load-side current reading is a major red flag.4.

Measure Power Factor

Get a power factor reading at the MDP.5.

Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer:
This situation is complex and requires a thorough analysis. If you're not comfortable performing the troubleshooting steps outlined above, consult with a qualified electrical engineer with experience in power quality and VFD applications. They can perform a comprehensive power quality study and recommend appropriate solutions.By following these steps, you can systematically identify the root cause of the discrepancy and implement corrective actions to ensure the safe and efficient operation of your recycling lines. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question