User: aLWAYS_lEARNING-112532, Location: Fl
Asked on: Thursday, September 25, 2025 at 12:53 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, September 28, 2025 at 3:26 am EDT
Question: Per NEC, do all breakers in this life safety circuit need selectivity, or only need selectivity between the main swgr breaker and all downstream breakers. Right now I have overlap between feeder ls and ls main
Okay, let's break down the NEC requirements for selective coordination in life safety systems and address your specific situation.
Understanding Selective Coordination in Life Safety Systems
The primary goal of selective coordination is to ensure that a fault on a branch circuit or feeder will only trip the closest upstream overcurrent protective device (OCPD) to the fault. This prevents a widespread power outage that could compromise essential life safety functions.
NEC Requirements (Key Sections)
The key NEC section for this discussion is NEC 700.27, Coordination. While there isn't a single, universal, crystal-clear statement of "all breakers must have selectivity," the effect is often very close to that, depending on the specific life safety system and the requirements for the facility.Here's how to interpret it: 700.27
"Emergency system(s) overcurrent devices shall be selectively coordinated with all supply-side overcurrent protective devices."
Interpretation of "all supply-side overcurrent protective devices"
This is the critical point. This means coordination needs to occur between all devices from the load side all the way to the source (including the utility).
Applying it to Your Situation
You stated: "Right now I have overlap between feeder LS and LS main". This needs to be fixed.
Addressing Your Specific Scenario1. Identify the Life Safety System
What specific life safety system are we talking about? (Emergency Lighting, Fire Pumps, Emergency Voice/Alarm Communication Systems, etc.) The specific requirements might slightly differ based on the type of system.2.
The Main Breaker and Downstream Breakers
As 700.27 requires, all supply side devices to be selectively coordinated, including the main service breaker and any downstream feeder and branch circuit breakers.
The Coordination Study
A detailed coordination study is essential. This study should: Analyze the available fault current at each point in the system. Determine the time-current curves (TCCs) of all the OCPDs involved. Demonstrate that the downstream breakers will trip before the upstream breakers for any fault within their zone of protection. Consider the impact of arc flash hazards and potential mitigation strategies.3.
The Overlap
The fact that you have overlap between the feeder LS (Life Safety) breaker and the LS main breaker is a problem. It means that a fault on the feeder could cause the main breaker to trip, potentially disabling the entire life safety system. This violates the intent of selective coordination.
Solutions Adjust Breaker Settings
This is the most common and often the most cost-effective solution. Adjust the settings of the overcurrent relays to provide the required selectivity. This may involve adjusting time delay settings or instantaneous trip settings. This must be verified by a qualified professional.
Use Different Breakers
If settings adjustments are not sufficient, you may need to replace one or more of the breakers with types that offer better coordination characteristics. Consider using breakers with different trip curves (e.g., inverse time vs. very inverse time). Using current-limiting breakers can also improve coordination in some cases.
Zone Interlocking
Consider using a zone interlocking scheme if you are working with breakers that support this feature. Zone interlocking allows the breakers to communicate with each other and coordinate their tripping behavior.
Fuses
Fuses are inherently selective. They may be a solution for some of your coordination problems, but their non-reclosing nature may not be acceptable for all applications.
Important Considerations
Qualified Professional
A licensed electrical engineer or qualified electrical contractor must perform the coordination study and implement any changes to the overcurrent protection system. This is not a DIY project.
Documentation
Keep thorough documentation of the coordination study, including TCCs, breaker settings, and any changes made to the system.
Regular Review
Review the coordination study periodically (e.g., every 3-5 years) to ensure that it remains valid, especially if there have been any changes to the electrical system.
In summary, while the NEC doesn't explicitly say that every breaker must be selective with every other breaker, the requirement for coordination between all supply-side devices in emergency systems effectively necessitates a high degree of coordination throughout the entire system. Your overlap issue must be addressed to comply with the NEC and ensure the reliability of your life safety system. Flag for review