Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 250.20 and 250.21

User: Isaiah, Location: Baton Rouge

Asked on: Friday, September 26, 2025 at 7:50 am EDT
Answered on: Sunday, September 28, 2025 at 3:28 am EDT

Question: Is it possible to have a MV Primary with a MV secondary, delta-delta ungrounded system and still be code compliant?Enviado desde mi iPhone utilizando Tapatalk

Yes, it is possible to have a Medium Voltage (MV) Primary feeding a MV Secondary, delta-delta ungrounded transformer system and still be code compliant, BUT it's highly unusual and requires careful consideration of the specific application and applicable codes. Here's a breakdown of the considerations

Why it's unusual (and often discouraged):
Lack of Ground Fault Protection

The biggest problem with ungrounded systems is that the first ground fault will not cause a circuit breaker to trip. The voltage on the other two phases will rise to the line-to-line voltage, stressing the insulation and potentially leading to a second ground fault, which
will cause a trip. This is not ideal.

Transient Overvoltages

Ungrounded systems are prone to transient overvoltages during switching events and faults. These can damage equipment.

Personnel Safety

While the first ground fault won't trip a breaker, it does create a potential shock hazard if someone comes into contact with the faulted phase.


Difficulty in Locating Ground Faults

Finding the first ground fault in an ungrounded system can be challenging and time-consuming.

Code Requirements Generally Favor Grounded Systems

Modern electrical codes strongly favor grounded systems for safety and reliability reasons.

Conditions where it MIGHT be acceptable (and still code compliant, although often not the best practice)



Specific Industrial Applications

In certain critical industrial processes where an immediate shutdown due to a single ground fault would be catastrophic, an ungrounded system might be considered. This is VERY rare, and requires extensive justification and engineering analysis. Examples would be continuous process manufacturing where a shutdown could result in a hazardous chemical release, or something of that nature.

Very Old Installations

You might find these in very old facilities that predate modern grounding requirements. However, if you're making any modifications or expansions, bringing the system up to current code is almost always required.


Specialized Equipment

There might be specialized equipment designed specifically to operate on an ungrounded system. In this case, the equipment manufacturer's instructions and code requirements would need to be carefully followed.

Code Considerations (U.S. NEC)



Article 250 (Grounding and Bonding)

This article provides the general requirements for grounding and bonding electrical systems. It heavily favors grounded systems, but does allow for ungrounded systems under certain conditions.


Article 450 (Transformers)

This article covers the installation and protection of transformers. It will likely reference other articles that dictate grounding requirements.

Article 700 (Emergency Systems) / 701 (Legally Required Standby Systems)

Even in emergency or standby systems, grounded systems are generally preferred. Ungrounded systems are very unlikely to be permitted here.


Ground Fault Detection/Indication

If an ungrounded system is used, you will almost certainly need to provide ground fault detection and indication to alert personnel to the presence of a ground fault.

What you MUST do to be Code Compliant (if you're even considering this)


Consult the Applicable Codes

Thoroughly review the NEC (National Electrical Code) or the relevant local electrical code. Pay close attention to the articles related to grounding, transformers, and the specific type of system you are considering.2.

Engineering Analysis

Conduct a detailed engineering analysis to determine the suitability of an ungrounded system for your application. This analysis should consider: Transient overvoltages Ground fault protection requirements Equipment insulation levels Personnel safety The criticality of the load3.

Ground Fault Detection and Indication

Implement a robust ground fault detection and indication system. This should include alarms and indicators to alert personnel to the presence of a ground fault.4.

Overvoltage Protection

Provide adequate overvoltage protection, such as surge arresters or surge suppressors, to protect equipment from transient overvoltages.5.

Coordination Study

Perform a coordination study to ensure that protective devices are properly coordinated to minimize the impact of faults.6.

Approval from the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)

Before proceeding with an ungrounded system, obtain approval from the AHJ (the electrical inspector or other authority responsible for enforcing the electrical code). Be prepared to provide detailed documentation and justification for your design.

In summary

While
technically possible, an MV primary to MV secondary, delta-delta ungrounded system is very rare and generally discouraged due to safety and reliability concerns. It requires extensive justification, careful design, and approval from the AHJ. Unless there is a very* compelling reason to use an ungrounded system, a grounded system is almost always the better and more code-compliant choice. You're far better off considering a High Resistance Grounded system if you're concerned about nuisance tripping.

Recommendation:
Strongly consider alternative grounding methods, such as solid grounding, resistance grounding, or impedance grounding, before resorting to an ungrounded system. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer experienced in MV systems to determine the best grounding method for your specific application. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question