User: Petergg98, Location: New Hampshire
Asked on: Monday, September 29, 2025 at 12:00 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, September 29, 2025 at 12:00 pm EDT
Question: Hello,I have a 480Vac/3Ph contactor with 120Vac coil. The specifications for the coil are 1100VA (9.16A) closing power and 12VA (0.1A) Holding Power. I believe I'd size my breaker for the holding current and choose the correct trip curve to ride out the quick closing current of the Coil. Example: a 2A miniature CB with a "C" trip curve (x5-10) so the breaker should trip if the closing power hits 10A. I'd love some advice/ recommendations.
You're on the right track, but let's refine the process and consider some important safety factors. Here's a more detailed breakdown of how to size the breaker for your contactor coil, along with recommendations
1. Understanding the Requirements:
Closing (Inrush) Current
This is the high current the coil draws momentarily to energize the contactor and close the contacts. It's short-lived but can be significantly higher than the holding current. Your coil is specified at 9.16A.
Holding Current
This is the much lower current needed to keep the contactor energized and the contacts closed after the initial closing. Your coil is specified at 0.1A.
Trip Curve
This defines how quickly a circuit breaker will trip at different multiples of its rated current. "C" curves are a good starting point, but we need to verify.
2. Calculating and Choosing a Breaker
Nominal Current
The primary consideration for the breaker size is the holding current plus a safety margin. Aim for at least 125% of the holding current. `Holding Current x 1.25 = Breaker Current` `0.1A x 1.25 = 0.125A`
Standard Breaker Sizes
Since 0.125A is not a standard breaker size, you need to move to the nearest larger standard size. This is usually 1A or 2A, depending on the manufacturer and available options.
Trip Curve Verification (Critical)
This is where it gets more nuanced. The breaker must withstand the inrush current (9.16A) for the short duration of the contactor closing without tripping.
Consult Breaker Datasheets
This is the most important step. Find the Time-Current Characteristic (TCC) curve for the specific breaker you are considering. These curves show how long it takes for the breaker to trip at different multiples of its rated current.
Example
If you choose a 2A breaker, check the TCC curve to see how long it takes to trip at 9.16A (which is ~4.58 times the rated current). You need to ensure that this time is longer than the contactor's closing time (typically in milliseconds).
C Curve Considerations
"C" curve breakers typically trip between 5-10 times the rated current, but this can vary widely between manufacturers. A "C" curve might work, but don't assume. Always verify with the datasheet.
D Curve Option
If a "C" curve doesn't reliably handle the inrush, a "D" curve breaker (10-20 times the rated current) is a more robust choice. However, "D" curves offer less overload protection, so only use them if necessary.
Important
Over specifying the CB is not an effective method for ride through of inrush current, rather using a CB appropriate for motor start up is the correct method. This method will provide the inrush allowance as well as the appropriate protection in the event of an over current/ short circuit.
3. Recommended Approach Start with a 1A or 2A breaker
Select a miniature circuit breaker (MCB) from a reputable manufacturer.
Get the Datasheet
Download the complete datasheet for the chosen breaker model.
Analyze the TCC Curve
Carefully examine the TCC curve. Ensure the breaker will not trip within the expected closing time of the contactor coil at 9.16A.
Test (Highly Recommended)
If possible, prototype the circuit and test the breaker's behavior when the contactor is energized. This is the best way to confirm your calculations and selections.
Consider In-Line Series Inductor
This method is effective but comes with additional cost and space constraints.
4. Safety Factors and Best Practices
Oversizing Considerations
While you want to avoid nuisance tripping, don't drastically oversize the breaker. Too large a breaker provides inadequate protection against overloads and short circuits.
Wire Sizing
Select wiring appropriate for the breaker size and the anticipated load (the holding current + a safety factor). Consult the National Electrical Code (NEC) or your local electrical codes for proper wire sizing.
Voltage Rating
Ensure the breaker has a voltage rating that matches or exceeds the circuit voltage (120VAC in this case).
Manufacturer's Instructions
Always follow the manufacturer's installation instructions for both the contactor and the circuit breaker.
Qualified Personnel
Electrical work should only be performed by qualified and licensed electricians.
Example (Illustrative - Requires Datasheet Verification)
Let's say you choose a 2A "C" curve breaker from Manufacturer X. You download the datasheet and the TCC curve shows that at 4.58 times the rated current (9.16A), the breaker takes at least 0.1 seconds to trip. If the contactor closes in, say, 20 milliseconds (0.02 seconds), the breaker should ride through the inrush without tripping. However, you must verify this with the specific breaker's datasheet.
*In summary, don't rely on generic assumptions about trip curves. Get the datasheets, understand the TCC curves, and test your circuit whenever possible to ensure reliable and safe operation. Flag for review