User: aLWAYS_lEARNING-112532, Location: Fl
Asked on: Monday, September 29, 2025 at 2:17 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, September 29, 2025 at 2:27 pm EDT
Question: Can you safely collect data for an arc flash study with no PPE? For example, electricians wearing PPE remover covers and you then come in the room and write down breaker model / conductor sizes staying back at least 18" from the gear. This would be mainly for 480V and 208V switchboards and panel boards
No, it is absolutely not safe to collect data for an arc flash study with no PPE, even if electricians have temporarily removed their PPE and you are staying back 18 inches.Here's a breakdown of why and the risks involved: Arc Flash Hazard Exists Continuously
An arc flash hazard exists whenever energized electrical equipment is open and exposed. Even if the equipment is closed, there are still conditions that can cause equipment failure leading to an arc flash incident. Removing PPE, even temporarily, increases the risk of injury. The 18-inch distance provides some protection, but it is not a guaranteed safe zone in the event of an arc flash.
Potential for Unexpected Events
Electrical systems can be unpredictable. Here are just a few potential scenarios:
Equipment Failure
A component inside the panel could fail while you are near it, triggering an arc flash.
Accidental Contact
Someone working in the panel could accidentally cause a short circuit.
Pre-existing Condition
There could be an existing fault or degradation within the equipment that you are unaware of.
The Human Element
Even with trained electricians, human error is possible. Someone could make a mistake that leads to an arc flash event.
"PPE Removal Covers" Offer Limited Protection
I'm not familiar with a specific product called "PPE removal covers." I would ask to review the documentation for that device before making a judgment.
Staying 18 Inches Away is Not a Guaranteed Safety Zone
The safe approach distance, even for qualified persons, depends on the voltage level, the arc flash boundary, and the calculated incident energy level. At 480V and 208V, a distance of 18 inches may be within the Arc Flash Boundary and the limited approach boundary.
OSHA Regulations
OSHA regulations (specifically NFPA 70E) require that qualified persons working on or near energized equipment wear appropriate PPE based on the arc flash hazard analysis. Not wearing PPE in such situations is a direct violation of these regulations.
Safer Alternatives for Data Collection
De-energize Equipment
The safest way to collect data is to de-energize the equipment. This eliminates the arc flash hazard entirely.2.
Qualified Person with Proper PPE
A qualified person who has received arc flash safety training and understands how to select and use appropriate PPE should collect the data.3.
Remote Data Collection
Use remote data collection methods whenever possible. This could involve using infrared cameras to assess equipment condition without opening panels or using remote monitoring systems.
Key Takeaways
Never compromise on safety when working with electrical equipment. An arc flash hazard exists whenever energized equipment is exposed. Always follow OSHA regulations and NFPA 70E guidelines. Prioritize de-energizing equipment whenever possible. If working on energized equipment is unavoidable, use appropriate PPE and follow safe work practices.* Consult with a qualified electrical safety professional or engineer for guidance.In conclusion, collecting data for an arc flash study without proper PPE, even with the described circumstances, is unsafe and should not be done. Flag for review