User: JoeNorm, Location: WA
Asked on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 9:19 am EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 9:20 am EDT
Question: I have a high-end client with a new carport. We are installing LED strip along the whole stone perimeter for accent lighting that also will help illuminate the space.I am wondering what the best way to switch the lighting would be? The simplistic would be a photo-cell right? But when they are not there(most of the time) those lights are still working overnight for no reason.Would a motion sensor make sense here? There would have to be two, one higher on the drive catch the approach and the other at the carport to come on when people are moving close by.Any suggestions if you have done something similar?
Okay, this is a fun project! Accent lighting with functionality is a great blend. Here's a breakdown of ideas for switching the LED strip lighting, considering your client's desire for efficiency and a touch of elegance
Factors to Consider:
Client's Preferences
How much control do they want? Do they like technology? Do they want a "smart" home integration?
Aesthetics
The placement of the sensor(s) needs to be discreet and blend with the carport's design.
Budget
Some solutions are significantly more expensive than others.
Frequency of Use
If the carport is used heavily, a simpler solution might be better. If it's rarely used, a more sophisticated, energy-saving option is ideal.
Solutions and their Pros/Cons
Photocell (Simple, but Inefficient)
Pros
Simplest installation. Least expensive.
Cons
Wastes energy during periods when the carport is not in use. Doesn't offer any control over the lighting schedule. Can trigger unnecessarily on cloudy days.2.
Motion Sensor (Improved Efficiency)
Pros
Turns lights on only when needed, saving energy. Provides a sense of security.
Cons
Might trigger unnecessarily due to animals or other movement. Multiple sensors might be needed for optimal coverage. Aesthetics of sensors can be a concern. Potential for "false" activation - think cats, leaves blowing, etc.
Implementation Recommendations for Motion Sensors
Two-Sensor System
This is likely the best approach for your scenario.
Driveway Sensor (Long Range)
Mount a long-range, driveway-oriented motion sensor relatively high, aimed towards the street/driveway entrance. Choose one with adjustable sensitivity and range to minimize false positives.
Carport Sensor (Short Range)
Mount a second sensor near the carport entrance, focused on detecting movement within the carport area. Again, adjustable sensitivity is key.
Adjustable Sensitivity & Range
Crucial for minimizing false positives. Experiment with these settings after installation.
Timer Function
Choose sensors that allow you to set the "on" time after motion is detected. A shorter time (e.g., 5-10 minutes) is often sufficient and saves energy.
Sensor Placement
Conceal the sensors as much as possible. Consider painting them to match the stone.3.
Smart Lighting System (Most Flexible & Efficient)
Pros
Ultimate control and customization. Can be integrated with other smart home devices. Schedule-based lighting (e.g., lights on only during certain hours). Motion sensor integration for even greater efficiency. Remote control via smartphone app. Geofencing (lights turn on when client approaches home).
Cons
Most expensive option. Requires more complex installation and setup. May require a smart home hub.
Implementation Recommendations for Smart Lighting
Smart Dimmer/Controller
Install a smart dimmer or LED controller that is compatible with your LED strips.
Smart Home Hub
A hub like SmartThings, Hubitat, or Homey may be needed to centralize control and integrate with other devices (motion sensors, etc.). Some controllers may work directly with Wi-Fi.
Motion Sensor Integration
Use smart motion sensors (e.g., Philips Hue, Aqara) that communicate with the hub. You can then create automations: "If driveway motion sensor detects movement after sunset, turn on carport lights to 50% brightness."
Scheduling
Set a schedule for the lights to turn off completely at a certain time each night (e.g., 1 AM).
Geofencing
Configure the system to turn on the lights automatically when your client's smartphone enters a defined "geofence" around their home.
Voice Control
Integrate with Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant for voice control.4.
Timer with Manual Override
Pros
Relatively simple and inexpensive. Allows for scheduled lighting with the option to manually turn the lights on or off.
Cons
Requires manual adjustment of the timer settings. Doesn't automatically adjust to changing daylight hours. Still uses energy during scheduled times, even if the carport is not in use.
Which is Best for Your Client?
I would recommend that you offer the client both the Motion Sensor set up and Smart System set up as options with clear explanations of cost, pros, and cons. Be sure to inquire about any smart home technologies they currently use. If the client is very concerned about energy waste and is not tech adverse, the Smart Lighting system is probably the best solution. If the client is looking for a balance of efficiency and simplicity, the Motion Sensor approach may be the better choice.
Important Considerations for LED Strip Installation
Waterproofing
Ensure the LED strips and all connections are rated for outdoor use and are well-sealed against moisture.
Voltage Drop
Long runs of LED strip lighting can suffer from voltage drop. Use a higher voltage system (24V) and/or run power to the strip from multiple locations to prevent dimming at the end of the run.
Heat Dissipation
Consider using aluminum channels to help dissipate heat from the LED strips, especially if they are high-power.*
Dimming: Make sure the LED strips are dimmable if your client wants that option.By presenting your client with these options and explaining the pros and cons of each, you can help them make an informed decision that meets their needs and budget. Good luck! Flag for review