User: TVH
Asked on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 9:22 am EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 9:22 am EDT
Question: The attached Welding Safety Bulletin from our friends Down-Under highlights a concern that person in construction may not be aware of. During heavy construction projects I have personally been shocked (tingling to jolts) during scaffold inspections where multiple Arc Welding was taking place on the metal scaffold (tube and coupler and framed scaffolds). Other crafts were working on the same scaffolding and have occassionally complainted of nuisance shock events. Investigation into these events revealed poor welding practices by welders which involved improper work piece connections, stray current from adjaced welding, broken electrode holders, worn/damaged cable, accidental stinger contact with metal. Such practices were corrected on the short term but welding protocols are often repeated during the rigors of construction especially on "hard-money" projects.The bulletin below gives caution on use of a bonding straps where the strap is properly connected to the metal scaffold and to the structure being welded. I have not seen this in practice on the many projects I have been assigned.I have attempte to address this subject with welding machine manufactures/welding organizations with no or little clarity on validity or specifics.Question to Electrical Professionals:Are bonding precautions, detailed in the bulletin, a required safety precaution againt electrical incidents to those working/occupying the scaffold? If so where is the precaution clearly specified in industry standards? I have searched many standards but clear and specific precautions on this subject are not detailed. OSHA has, however, specified bonding straps when welding from wire rope suspened scaffolding along with other precautions to prevent stray current from passing through the wire rope.Comments from electrical professionas will be appreciated.
You've hit on a critical and often overlooked aspect of welding safety on construction sites, particularly when scaffolding is involved. Your personal experiences with nuisance shocks are a testament to the real risks involved.
Addressing the Question: Are Bonding Precautions Required?
The short answer is: Yes, bonding precautions, as detailed in the bulletin, should be considered a required safety precaution against electrical incidents to those working/occupying the scaffold in circumstances where scaffolding is part of the welding circuit or subject to stray current.
Now for the more nuanced explanation:1. Underlying Principle: Electrical Safety Fundamentals The Welding Circuit
Welding completes an electrical circuit. The work piece is part of that circuit. Any unintended conductive path connected to the work piece can become energized if the primary circuit is not properly grounded and maintained.
Stray Current
Stray current always takes the path of least resistance. If the intended path through the work lead is high-resistance (due to poor connection, long cables, etc.), the current will find alternate paths, potentially through the scaffold, other equipment, and even people.
Grounding vs. Bonding
Grounding is connecting to the earth to stabilize voltage and provide a path for fault current. Bonding is connecting metallic parts together to create an electrically conductive path to equalize voltage. In this context, we are primarily concerned with bonding the scaffold to the structure being welded to ensure an equipotential plane.
The Nuisance Shock
Even without a major fault, small stray currents can cause tingling or nuisance shocks, which can startle workers and potentially lead to falls or other accidents.2.
Where the Requirement Should Reside (and why it's often missing) Direct Specification in Standards
You are correct that a clear, explicit, and universally enforced standard specifically mandating scaffold bonding for all welding situations is often lacking. This is a gray area, and frankly, it's a dangerous omission. The problem is that standards tend to focus on general electrical safety, and may not explicitly address the intricacies of the welding process.
Indirect Coverage in Existing Standards
The "requirement" can be implied and drawn from several standards, including, but not limited to:
OSHA 1926 Subpart J (Welding and Cutting)
Focuses primarily on specific welding operations, PPE, and equipment safety. While it may mention grounding the welding machine frame, it is light on specifically bonding all work pieces together in a welding operation.
NFPA 70 (National Electrical Code)
The NEC's general requirements for grounding and bonding of metal structures are applicable. Specifically, section 250 addresses grounding and bonding. However, the NEC is often enforced at a building level and not explicitly for field/project site temporary welding practices.
ANSI Z49.1 (Safety in Welding, Cutting, and Allied Processes)
This is a more comprehensive standard on welding safety, but implementation and enforcement are up to the specific work site. In principle, the language in ANSI Z49.1 should address this.
Specific Scaffolding Standards (e.g., OSHA 1926 Subpart L)
These mainly focus on scaffold construction, stability, and fall protection, but they generally do not go into specifics on electrical risks during welding operations.
The "General Duty Clause" (OSHA)
This is where the argument becomes very strong. OSHA's "general duty clause" (Section 5(a)(1) of the OSH Act) requires employers to provide a workplace free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to employees. Given your documented experiences with shocks, the risk is clearly present. The bulletin you provided and the discussion here provide further evidence that the hazard is recognized.3.
Why It's Not Always Practiced/Enforced
Lack of Awareness
The biggest issue is a lack of awareness among welders, supervisors, and safety personnel about the potential for stray current and the importance of bonding.
Time and Cost
Bonding adds time and potentially cost to the welding process. On "hard-money" projects, corners are often cut.
Complexity
Determining the best bonding method for complex scaffold configurations and varying structural elements can be challenging.
Enforcement Challenges
Electrical inspections often focus on permanent installations, and temporary welding setups may not receive the same scrutiny.
Conflicting Directives
There may be conflicting directives between welding and other trades on site regarding the setup of equipment and safety parameters.4.
Recommendations for Electrical Professionals (and Safety Professionals)
Risk Assessment
A thorough risk assessment must be performed before any welding operation on or near scaffolding. This assessment should explicitly consider the potential for stray current and the need for bonding.
Develop a Site-Specific Welding Safety Plan
This plan should include:
Specific Bonding Procedures
Detailed instructions on how to properly bond the scaffold to the structure being welded. This should include the size and type of bonding conductors, connection methods, and inspection requirements.
Regular Inspections
Regular inspections of welding equipment and bonding connections to ensure they are in good working order.
Training
Comprehensive training for all welders, supervisors, and other workers who may be exposed to the hazard. The training should cover: The hazards of stray current. Proper grounding and bonding techniques. Inspection procedures. Reporting procedures for any electrical shocks or unusual occurrences.
Enforcement
Safety personnel must have the authority to enforce the welding safety plan and stop work if necessary to correct hazardous conditions.
Communication
Clear communication between welders, supervisors, and other trades is essential to ensure that everyone is aware of the risks and the safety procedures in place.
Use of Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters (GFCIs)
Where practical, use GFCIs on welding equipment to help detect and interrupt stray current. Note: GFCIs are not a substitute for proper bonding but can provide an added layer of protection.
Advocate for Better Standards
Engage with welding organizations and standards-setting bodies to advocate for more explicit and comprehensive standards on scaffold bonding during welding.
Insist on Quality Equipment
Ensure all welding equipment is in good repair and that cables are properly sized and insulated.
Work Lead Placement
Emphasize the importance of placing the work lead (ground clamp) as close as possible to the weld to minimize the potential for stray current.
In conclusion: While a specific, universally mandated standard may be lacking, the underlying principles of electrical safety, the OSHA General Duty Clause, and the recognized hazard of stray current during welding on scaffolding make bonding a necessary* safety precaution. Electrical and safety professionals have a responsibility to recognize this hazard, develop and implement appropriate safety plans, and ensure that these plans are rigorously enforced. Ignoring this issue is a recipe for potential injury or even fatality. Flag for review