User: DDuffeInc, Location: Texas
Asked on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 1:18 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 1:19 pm EDT
Question: We completed an industrial plant and seem to be having issues getting the Switchgear Study completed. We have several cabinets which feed from a 480/240 transformer and they are over the 25 feet distance. We seem to be having issues with Section 240.21 of the NEC. We were told there is may be an exception in the 2023 code which allows the transfomer to be protected by the primary side breaker in an industrial facility. I figured this was the place to go and ask about this so here I am. Can anyone help us with the code interpetation with the 240.21 Code issues with the delta/delta transformer?
Okay, let's break down NEC 240.21 and the potential exception you're referring to for your 480/240 Delta-Delta transformer setup in an industrial environment, particularly with those feeder runs exceeding 25 feet.
Understanding the Core Problem: 240.21 - Overcurrent Protection of Feeder Conductors
NEC 240.21 generally dictates where overcurrent protection (OCP) devices must be located to protect feeder conductors. The fundamental principle is to protect conductors at their point of supply (where they receive power). The closer the OCPD is to the source, the better the protection. The general rule is 240.21(B) requires protection at the point of supply.The problem with your situation, as you correctly identify, is the feeder conductors run more than 25 feet from the transformer secondary terminals to the distribution cabinets. This creates a situation where the feeder conductors are vulnerable to overcurrents between the transformer and the distribution cabinets.
The Standard "Tap Rule" Exceptions in 240.21
The NEC has specific "tap rules" that allow conductors to be tapped from a larger feeder without immediate overcurrent protection at the tap point, provided certain conditions are met. These tap rules (found in 240.21(B)) are exceptions to the general rule that feeders must be protected at their point of supply. They are very specific and must be followed exactly. The most relevant for this discussion might be: 240.21(B)(3) 10-foot Tap Rule
This is unlikely to apply to you, but let's mention it for completeness. It allows a tap up to 10 feet long without overcurrent protection at the tap point, if: The ampacity of the tap conductors is not less than: The calculated load. The rating of the OCPD at the termination of the tap conductors. The tap conductors are enclosed in a raceway. The tap conductors do not extend horizontally beyond the equipment they supply.
240.21(B)(5) 25-foot Tap Rule
This is likely the closest existing rule, but since your feeders are over 25 feet, it doesn't directly apply. It allows a tap up to 25 feet long without overcurrent protection at the tap point, if: The ampacity of the tap conductors is not less than 1/3 the rating of the OCPD protecting the feeder. The tap conductors terminate in a single OCPD that will protect the tap conductors at their ampacity. The tap conductors are protected from physical damage and are enclosed in a raceway.
The Potential Exception You're Hearing About (Likely 240.21(C)(6) for Industrial Installations)
Okay, here's the crucial part. You're likely hearing about a change or clarification that has been discussed and potentially adopted for the 2023 NEC regarding transformer secondary conductors in industrial installations. This revolves around 240.21(C)(6) which has been modified to specifically address these scenarios.
Key aspects of the exception 240.21(C)(6) (as proposed and potentially adopted in the 2023 NEC – verify this with your local jurisdiction's adoption of the 2023 code)
Applies to Industrial Installations
This is critical. It's specifically for industrial facilities where qualified personnel are continuously available to oversee the electrical system.
Conditions for the Exception
Engineering Supervision
The entire installation must be designed and installed under engineering supervision.
Coordination Study
A coordinated short-circuit and overcurrent protective device study must be performed.
Primary Protection
The primary OCPD must protect the transformer from overload and fault conditions. The coordination study will demonstrate this.
Secondary Protection
OCPDs must be provided on the secondary side of the transformer to protect downstream circuits and equipment.
Marking
The transformer and associated equipment must be clearly marked to indicate that the secondary conductors are protected by the primary OCPD under the conditions of the coordination study.
How This Helps You
If your industrial plant meets the requirements of 240.21(C)(6), and if your local jurisdiction has adopted the 2023 NEC with this provision, you may be able to protect the transformer secondary conductors with the primary OCPD, even with runs exceeding 25 feet, provided you have a properly engineered and documented coordination study.
Crucial Steps You MUST Take
Verify Local Code Adoption
ABSOLUTELY CONFIRM whether your local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) has adopted the 2023 NEC (or whatever edition is current in your area) and if they have made any amendments or deletions to it. This is the most important step. The rules can vary locally.2. Consult a Qualified Electrical Engineer
You need a licensed electrical engineer experienced in power system studies and industrial installations. They can: Determine if your facility qualifies for the exception in 240.21(C)(6). Perform the required short-circuit and overcurrent coordination study. This is not a simple task. It requires detailed knowledge of the transformer characteristics, feeder impedances, and the characteristics of all OCPDs in the system. Document the study properly. Specify the correct OCPD settings. Provide the required markings for the equipment.3.
Submit to AHJ
Submit the engineered drawings, coordination study, and equipment specifications to your local AHJ for review and approval before making any changes. Get their blessing in writing.4.
Implement the Design
Install the system exactly as specified in the approved design.5.
Keep Records
Maintain meticulous records of the design, the coordination study, the equipment specifications, and the AHJ approval.
Important Considerations
Delta-Delta Transformer Concerns
Delta-delta transformers can have specific challenges related to fault current contributions and harmonic distortion. The coordination study must address these.
Coordination Study Complexity
A proper coordination study is not just about protecting the transformer. It's about ensuring selective tripping. This means that if a fault occurs downstream, the closest OCPD to the fault should trip first, minimizing the impact on the rest of the system.
Qualified Personnel
The "qualified personnel" requirement in an industrial setting is very important. This means trained and experienced electricians and engineers who understand the electrical system and can respond appropriately to issues.
Safety
Even with proper coordination, appropriate PPE must be worn.
In summary
Don't rely on hearsay about code changes.
Verify the code requirements with your AHJ, and engage a qualified electrical engineer to perform the necessary study and design the system. This will ensure compliance, safety, and reliability. Ignoring these steps could lead to code violations, safety hazards, and equipment damage. Flag for review