User: Electromatic, Location: Virginia
Asked on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 3:56 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, September 30, 2025 at 3:56 pm EDT
Question: I have a control panel using an Eaton ELC controller for operation and for alarm outputs. The outputs OPEN on a fault. Recently, there have been some power issues at this location, and we've gotten multiple alarms. I'm thinking the power outage (before a generator kicks in) is opening these outputs, but that seems like a stupid design. Is this at all common?The Eaton manual says the controller will continue operating with a power loss of 5-10ms, but that's obviously way to quick for a utility-out, generator start, transfer situation. I've added a delay between the output going to alarm and when somebody gets notified, but the whole opening on fault seems crazy except for very certain situations.
You're right, it's a design choice that has pros and cons, and it's not universally preferred. Let's break down why it might be done this way, and what the implications are
Why "Open on Fault" is Used Sometimes:
Fail-Safe Operation
This is the most common reason. An "open" state can often be interpreted as a loss of power to the output circuit itself, or a wire being cut/disconnected. In certain critical applications, this is considered a safer state because it ensures the alarm must trigger if there's a system failure. Consider these scenarios:
Wire Cut
If the output closed to signal an alarm, and the wire was cut, the alarm wouldn't go off, potentially leading to a catastrophic situation.
Power Supply Failure
If the PLC's power supply fails, the "open on fault" configuration will ensure the alarm is activated.
Output Relay Failure
If the relay driving the output freezes in the closed position, a real alarm would be masked.
Supervisory Circuits
Opening the output can be part of a supervisory circuit. A supervisory circuit constantly monitors the integrity of the wiring and the end device. If the circuit is broken (open output), the alarm is triggered. This is commonly used in fire alarm systems.
Why it's Problematic in Your Case (Power Outages)
Nuisance Alarms
As you've discovered, power outages trigger false alarms. This leads to operator fatigue, desensitization to alarms ("alarm flooding"), and wasted time troubleshooting.
Interpreting the Alarm
Is the alarm a real fault, or just a temporary power glitch? This requires investigation, which is disruptive.
Is it "Stupid"?
Not necessarily stupid, but potentially inappropriate for your specific application. It's a trade-off between safety and practicality. A key question is: What are the consequences of not triggering an alarm in your application? If the consequences are severe (safety, equipment damage, etc.), then the "open on fault" design might be justified. If the consequences are less severe (minor downtime, inconvenience), then a different design might be more suitable.
Possible Solutions & Considerations
Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) for the PLC
This is the most robust solution. A UPS provides a continuous power supply to the PLC, bridging the gap between the utility outage and the generator startup. This is particularly important for PLC, HMIs and network equipment. Size the UPS appropriately to handle the PLC's power requirements for the entire generator transfer time.2.
Output Logic Change (If Possible)
If the PLC programming allows, you could consider changing the output logic to:
Closed on Fault
This eliminates the false alarm during power outages but introduces the potential fail-safe risks mentioned above. Carefully analyze the risks before making this change! Document your decision and reasons.
Pulse-Triggered Alarm
Instead of a constant open or closed state, the output could send a pulse when a fault occurs. The alarm system would then need to be configured to recognize this pulse and latch the alarm. This requires modifications to both the PLC program and the alarm system.
Monitor Power Status
Add a power supply monitor module to the PLC, and only allow the alarm outputs to activate if the PLC's power supply is within acceptable limits. This prevents alarms during power outages.3.
Output Filtering/Delay
You've already added a delay to the notification, which is good. Consider adding filtering within the PLC program itself. This could be in the form of a timer that must be active for a certain duration before the output is energized. This can help ignore momentary glitches. But be careful not to filter out genuine faults.4.
Alarm System Configuration
Can your alarm system be configured to ignore alarms from these specific outputs for a short period after a power loss? This would require integration between the power outage detection and the alarm system.5.
Battery Backup for Outputs
Some output modules have battery backup options. This would maintain the output state during a power loss.6.
Evaluate Risk
Perform a thorough risk assessment to determine the acceptable level of risk for your application. Consider the consequences of both false alarms and missed alarms.
Important Questions to Ask
What type of alarm system is receiving the outputs? (e.g., SCADA, DCS, simple alarm panel) What are the other alarms connected to the system? Are they similarly configured? What standards or regulations govern the system's operation? Some industries (e.g., fire safety, nuclear power) have specific requirements for alarm system design. Is there a documented rationale for the "open on fault" design? (e.g., in design documents, commissioning reports) Is there a history of issues with this design?Recommendation
Start with a UPS
This is the most straightforward solution to prevent false alarms due to power outages.
Thoroughly investigate the risk
Understand the implications of changing the output logic.
Consult with a qualified control system engineer
They can help you evaluate the risks and select the most appropriate solution for your application.*
Document all changes: Keep detailed records of any modifications made to the system.In summary, "open on fault" is a design choice with valid reasons, but it's not always the best choice. Carefully consider the risks and consequences before making any changes. A UPS is likely the best first step. Flag for review