User: ABS, Location: Oregon
Asked on: Wednesday, October 1, 2025 at 8:14 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, October 1, 2025 at 8:15 pm EDT
Question: Installed a 320 service feeding two service rated 200a transfer switches on the wall of a pump house 20 feet from the main house, one of the transfer switches feeds a new panel in an addition being built. Conduit Underground into the crawl space and then SER to feed the panel on an interior wall, inspector is requiring an additional disconnect on the outside wall of the addition for the feeders to go through. I thought that with the service/emergency disconnect location being as close as it is that I was ok. Thoughts? Anyone else run into something similar? Was going to post a photo of everything to make it easier to see the layout but I can’t figure out how to get it from my phone album onto the post.
Okay, let's break this down. Your situation involves a service-rated transfer switch acting as a service disconnect and a feeder running from it to a panel in an addition. The inspector is calling for an additional disconnect at the point where the feeder enters the addition.Here's a summary of the situation: 320A Service
Feeding the pump house.
Service-Rated 200A Transfer Switches
Located on the pump house wall, 20 feet from the main house. These are your service disconnects. One feeds a panel in an addition to the main house.
Underground Conduit
From the pump house to the crawl space under the addition.
SER Cable
From the crawl space to the panel inside the addition.
Inspector Requirement
A disconnect is required on the exterior wall of the addition where the feeder (SER cable) enters.
Relevant Code Considerations (NEC, but always check your local amendments)
230.70 Location
This section dictates the location of service disconnecting means. It emphasizes readily accessible and near the point of entrance of the service conductors. In your case, the transfer switches on the pump house wall are acting as your service disconnects. This is generally acceptable as long as they meet all the other requirements.
225.31 Disconnecting Means
This section applies to outside feeders and branch circuits. It requires a readily accessible disconnecting means, suitable for use as service equipment, to be located either inside or outside where the conductors enter a building or structure. This is likely what the inspector is citing.
225.32 Maximum Number of Disconnects
For a building or other structure supplied by a feeder(s) or branch circuit(s), the disconnecting means shall consist of not more than six switches or six sets of circuit breakers mounted in a single enclosure, in a group of separate enclosures, or in or on a switchboard or switchgear.
338.10 Uses Permitted.
Type SER cable shall be permitted for use as service-entrance conductors and shall be installed in accordance with Article 230. Type SER cable shall be permitted for use in the following locations:(1) As branch circuits or feeders installed in accordance with Parts II and III of Article 334.
Why the Inspector Might Be Requiring the Additional Disconnect
Feeder vs. Service Entrance Conductors
The inspector is likely treating the conductors from the pump house to the addition as a feeder, not as service entrance conductors. The location of the service disconnect is 20' away from the house and in a separate building. Since the conductors are installed as a feeder to the addition, 225.31 would require a disconnect to be installed at the addition.
2.
Fire Safety
The primary concern is fire safety. If there's a fault in the addition, firefighters need to be able to quickly disconnect power at the building without having to run to the pump house.
Arguments You Could Make (But Be Prepared to Lose)
Proximity of Service Disconnect
You can argue that the pump house is very close, and the transfer switches are readily accessible. However, the inspector may not consider 20 feet "near" enough, and the fact that it's in a separate building is likely the deciding factor.
Redundancy
You can argue that adding another disconnect creates unnecessary redundancy.
Likely Outcome and Recommendations
The inspector is likely correct based on the NEC interpretation and the wording of 225.31. Arguing might be a waste of time and create friction. Install the disconnect. The easiest solution is to install a service-rated disconnect on the exterior wall of the addition where the SER cable enters. Make sure it's readily accessible. Consider a disconnect with overcurrent protection. This could double as your feeder protection (fuses or a breaker). Verify Local Amendments
Double-check your local jurisdiction's amendments to the NEC. They might have specific requirements regarding disconnects for outbuildings or additions.
Addressing the SER Cable
Make sure the SER cable is properly supported and protected where it enters the crawl space and at the point where it enters the disconnect.
In summary, while you might be able to argue your case, the inspector's interpretation is reasonable and aligns with the intent of the code. Installing the disconnect is the safest and most likely path to getting your project approved. Flag for review