User: NKC, Location: SLC, Utah
Asked on: Friday, October 3, 2025 at 2:06 am EDT
Answered on: Friday, October 3, 2025 at 2:07 am EDT
Question: We are back to this again with a new twist. We have 1 elevator Hostway/shaft and pit with 2 elevators side by side in it. Installed are 2 circuits 1 for lighting and one for the receptacles. This is installation is done per the engineers drawings. Today the state elevator inspector inspected and is requiring 2 circuits for lighting and 2 for receptacles, separated under each elevator that are in 1 common hoistway & pit. He is the AHJ so what can you do. The way I read the code is there are 2 circuits for the hoistway and the hoistway is the entire enclosed rated structure that houses the 2 elevators. The same issue is present at the top of the hoistway as in the pit.Any thoughts?
This is a tricky situation where interpretation of the code, engineering drawings, and the AHJ's authority clash. Let's break down the situation and potential approaches
Understanding the Core Issue
The AHJ (elevator inspector) believes that each elevator car within a shared hoistway needs its own dedicated lighting and receptacle circuit. Your interpretation, based on the drawings, is that the hoistway (as a single entity) only requires two circuits: one for lighting and one for receptacles.
Relevant NEC Sections NEC 620.23(A) & (B) (Power Sources for Elevators, Dumbwaiters, Escalators, Moving Walks, Platform Lifts, and Stairway Chairlifts)
This is the primary section. It specifies: (A) for elevator(s) 1 dedicated branch circuit (B) for the pit. 1 dedicated branch circuit
NEC 620.23(C)
This is where the inspector might be focusing, and it might be the root of the disagreement. This section applies to multiple elevators. This section requires elevator(s) 1 dedicated branch circuit and the pit 1 dedicated branch circuit, per elevator car.
NEC 620.24 (Branch Circuits for Lighting and Receptacles)
This section requires a separate branch circuit(s) for hoistway lighting and receptacles.
Arguments in Favor of Your Installation (Original Design)
Hoistway as a Single Space
You're interpreting the hoistway as a single enclosed space, and NEC 620.24 states a circuit for lighting and receptacles for the "hoistway." In your view, this requirement is met with the current installation.
2.
Engineer's Drawings
The installation followed the engineer's approved drawings. Deviating from approved plans without prior approval can lead to problems.3.
Cost and Feasibility
Adding additional circuits could involve significant rework, expense, and potentially require modifications to the electrical panel or service.
Arguments in Favor of the Elevator Inspector's Interpretation
Redundancy and Safety
The inspector is likely concerned about redundancy and safety. If a single lighting circuit fails, both elevator cars would be left in the dark. Similarly, a receptacle failure could impact maintenance work in both areas.2.
Service and Maintenance
Independent circuits make it easier to service or troubleshoot issues on one elevator car without affecting the other. This separation could reduce downtime.3.
NEC 620.23(C) - Elevator Grouping
The inspector might be arguing that because there are multiple elevators in the same hoistway, NEC 620.23(C) applies, and each elevator should have its own dedicated lighting and receptacle circuit.
Possible Courses of Action
Polite and Professional Discussion
This is always the first step.
Clarify the Inspector's Reasoning
Ask the inspector to specifically cite the NEC section(s) that require separate circuits for each elevator. Understand their rationale behind the interpretation.
Present Your Interpretation
Clearly and respectfully explain your understanding of the code and how it applies to the installation. Emphasize that you followed the engineer's design.
Refer to the Drawings
Show the inspector the approved engineering drawings. Explain why the engineers chose that design.
Ask for Clarification from Higher Authority
If you can't reach a consensus, politely ask the inspector if you can get clarification from a higher authority within the elevator inspection agency. Some agencies have chief inspectors or technical experts who can provide guidance.2.
Formal Code Interpretation Request
Some jurisdictions allow you to formally request a code interpretation from the electrical or building department. This provides an official ruling on the code's applicability in your situation.3.
Contact the Engineer
Consult with the engineer who designed the electrical system. Explain the inspector's concerns and ask them to provide a written justification for their design. The engineer may need to modify the drawings or provide additional documentation to support the installation.4.
Variance Request (Conditional Approval)
If all else fails, you might consider requesting a variance. This is a formal request to deviate from the code. You would need to demonstrate that the existing installation provides an equivalent level of safety and functionality. Variances are rarely granted, and it's usually a last resort.5.
Compliance (Reluctantly)
If you've exhausted all other options and the inspector remains firm, you may need to comply with their requirements, even if you disagree. This will likely involve adding two additional circuits (one for lighting and one for receptacles) and running new wiring.
Key Considerations
Safety First
Even if you disagree with the inspector, never compromise on safety. Ensure that any electrical work is done by qualified electricians and meets all applicable codes.
Documentation
Keep detailed records of all communication with the inspector, including dates, names, and the specific code sections discussed. This documentation can be helpful if you need to appeal the inspector's decision or make changes to the installation.*
Local Amendments
Be aware of any local amendments to the NEC. Some jurisdictions may have stricter requirements for elevator electrical systems.
Recommendation:
Start with a respectful and open discussion with the elevator inspector. Try to understand their reasoning and explain your perspective. Contact the engineer for support and consider seeking clarification from a higher authority within the inspection agency before resorting to a variance request. If compliance is unavoidable, ensure the work is done safely and to code. Flag for review