User: brianthejabroni2
Asked on: Sunday, October 5, 2025 at 10:10 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, October 5, 2025 at 10:10 pm EDT
Question: I have a project where a customer has asked me to suggest a fixture for replacement. They prefer not to retrofit the existing light. Can anyone recommend a fixture suitable for either surface mounting or an old work style? The ceiling height is 40 feet, and the current light measures 7 inches wide by 21 inches long.Thank you
Okay, a 40-foot ceiling height with a relatively small existing fixture footprint (7" x 21") presents some specific challenges. You need a fixture that can deliver sufficient light from that height, has a reasonable footprint to cover the existing mounting point, and is either surface mountable or suitable for old-work installation. Here's a breakdown of fixture types and recommendations, considering these factors
Key Considerations:
High Lumen Output
At 40 feet, you'll need a fixture with significant lumen output to adequately illuminate the area below. Consider the existing fixture's lumen output as a baseline (if you know it) and aim for at least that much, and potentially more depending on the desired light level.
Beam Angle
A narrower beam angle will concentrate the light and be more effective at that height. A wider beam angle will spread the light more, but you may lose intensity. Experiment to find the best match for the room.
Ease of Installation
Surface mount is generally easier than old-work, but sometimes old-work is unavoidable.
Light Distribution
Consider whether you want a direct downlight, or some upward light as well.
Color Temperature
Choose a color temperature appropriate for the application. Cooler temperatures (4000K-5000K) are often preferred for industrial or commercial spaces.
Driver location
You must know where the driver for the new LED fixture will be located. If it is not within the light fixture itself, this adds another step in the installation process.
Recommended Fixture Types and Specific Examples (Focusing on LED)
High Bay LED Fixtures
Description
This is the most common and appropriate type for high ceilings. They are designed for industrial and commercial spaces with high mounting heights. They offer excellent lumen output and energy efficiency.
Surface Mount High Bays
These are designed to mount directly to the ceiling. Look for models that come with a mounting bracket that could potentially cover the existing hole.
Old-Work Considerations
Some high bay fixtures can be adapted for old-work if the ceiling structure is robust enough to support the weight. You would need to carefully assess the existing ceiling and potentially reinforce it.
Beam Angle
Available in various beam angles (narrow, medium, wide). For 40-foot ceilings, a narrower beam angle (e.g., 60 degrees or less) is generally recommended to concentrate the light.
Examples (Look for these features)
Round High Bays (UFO Style)
Compact, efficient, and easy to install. Look for models with adjustable mounting brackets.
Linear High Bays
Provide a more even distribution of light along a rectangular area.
High Lumen Output
Minimum 10,000 lumens, potentially much higher depending on the area to be illuminated.
Surface Mounting Kit Included
This will make the installation process much easier.
Specific Recommendations (Starting Points - check local suppliers)
Philips GreenPerform Highbay Elite
Reputable brand, good performance, and a variety of models.
Lithonia Lighting High Bay LED
Another well-known brand with various options.
RAB Lighting High Bays
Often a good value for the performance.2.
LED Canopy Lights (Can be repurposed, especially round ones)
Description
Originally designed for gas stations and parking garages, some LED canopy lights offer high lumen output in a compact, surface-mountable package. They are often round or square.
Suitability
Depending on the aesthetic and desired beam spread, a well-chosen canopy light could work.
Surface Mount
Almost always surface mount.
Examples
Look for models with high lumen output (at least 8,000-10,000 lumens) and a durable construction.3.
LED Area Lights (Smaller Sizes)
Description
While usually used for outdoor applications, some smaller LED area lights can be suitable for indoor use and are designed for surface mounting.
Suitability
Look for models with a sleek design and appropriate beam angles.
Surface Mount
Generally designed for surface mounting.
Steps to Take Before Making a Recommendation
Determine Existing Light Level
If possible, measure the existing light level (in foot-candles or lux) at the work surface below the existing fixture. This will give you a target to match or exceed.2.
Consider the Application
What is the space used for? A warehouse requires different lighting than an office or retail space.3.
Measure Existing Mounting Point
Accurately measure the dimensions of the existing fixture's mounting point or hole in the ceiling. This will help you choose a replacement fixture that can cover it.4.
Assess Ceiling Structure
Carefully inspect the ceiling structure to determine if it can support the weight of the new fixture, especially if considering old-work mounting.5.
Check Local Codes
Ensure that the new fixture complies with all applicable local electrical and building codes.6.
Consider Controls
Does the customer want dimming or other control options?
Important Considerations for Old-Work Mounting
Ceiling Material
Is the ceiling drywall, plaster, or something else? Drywall is the least supportive and requires special anchors.
Joist Location
Ideally, you want to mount the fixture to a ceiling joist. Use a stud finder to locate the joists.
Reinforcement
If you can't mount directly to a joist, you may need to install a support structure or backing board behind the ceiling to distribute the weight.
Weight Limit
Be very mindful of the weight limit of the ceiling and any anchors used.
Key Questions to Ask the Customer
What is the primary function of the space? What is the desired light level? What is their budget? Are there any aesthetic preferences?* Do they want any control options (dimming, occupancy sensors)?
By carefully considering these factors and following the steps outlined above, you can recommend a suitable replacement fixture for your customer that meets their needs and provides adequate illumination for their space. Remember to prioritize safety and compliance with local codes. Good luck! Flag for review