User: Saturn_Europa, Location: Fishing Industry
Asked on: Tuesday, October 7, 2025 at 10:59 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, October 7, 2025 at 10:59 pm EDT
Question: I am using a Fluke 1507 Insulation Tester for the first time. I am using it to test a motor that has a short to ground. The switch board shows a short whenever the motor is running. I am going to replace the motor.With the Fluke 1507 set to 1000 volts it is showing a reading of around 0.4 M ohms on each leg to ground. The voltage on the display of the meter will only go to around 514 volts.I am suspecting the 1507 wont put out the full 1000v because it is sensing a ground?Whats the rule of thumb on good/bad megger readings on motors?
You're on the right track. Here's a breakdown of what's likely happening and what you should do
Understanding the 1507's Behavior
Voltage Sag
Yes, you are correct. The Fluke 1507 (and most insulation testers) will reduce the test voltage when it detects a low insulation resistance (a path to ground). This is a safety feature and helps prevent further damage to the insulation by continuously pumping high voltage into a compromised area. The fact that your voltage is dropping to 514V when set to 1000V confirms that there is a low resistance path to ground.
Low Resistance Readings
A reading of 0.4 MΩ (400 kΩ) to ground is definitely low and indicates a problem with the motor's insulation.
Why You're Seeing a Short on the Switchboard
The short on the switchboard when the motor is running is happening because the compromised insulation allows current to leak to ground. This leakage current is enough to trip breakers or cause other protective devices to activate.
Megger Readings: Good vs. Bad (Rule of Thumb)
Here's a generally accepted rule of thumb for motor insulation resistance (Megger) readings, BUT ALWAYS CONSULT THE MOTOR MANUFACTURER'S SPECIFICATIONS FIRST. If their specs are tighter, adhere to those. Good (Acceptable)
A general, widely used formula is
1 Megohm + (1 Megohm / kV). So, for a 480V motor (0.48kV): 1 + (1/0.48) = ~3.1 Megohms minimum. Many electricians and technicians use a minimum threshold of at least 2-5 Megohms. The higher, the better. Questionable
Readings between 1-2 Megohms. This could still be acceptable if the motor is hot and/or dirty, but it warrants further investigation.
Bad (Unacceptable)
Readings below 1 Megohm are a red flag. Your 0.4 MΩ reading is definitely in the "bad" category.
Important Considerations
Temperature
Insulation resistance decreases with increasing temperature. A motor that reads OK when cold might fail a megger test when hot. Always note the motor's temperature during testing and, if possible, correct the reading to a reference temperature (like 20°C or 68°F) using correction factors (charts) if provided by the motor manufacturer.
Humidity
Moisture can also lower insulation resistance. Ensure the motor and test area are dry.
Surface Contamination
Dirt, oil, and other contaminants on the motor windings and terminations can provide a leakage path to ground, giving a false low reading. Clean the motor thoroughly before testing.
Test Voltage
Always use the correct test voltage for the motor's voltage rating. Using too high a voltage can stress the insulation unnecessarily. Generally: Motors < 600V: 500V DC test voltage Motors 600V - 1000V: 1000V DC test voltage Motors > 1000V: 2500V DC test voltage or higher
Steps to Take
Verify De-Energized and Lockout/Tagout
Absolutely essential! Make sure the motor is completely de-energized and locked out/tagged out before any testing.2.
Disconnect Motor Leads
Disconnect all motor leads (T1, T2, T3, etc.) from the switchboard. This isolates the motor and prevents readings from being affected by anything else in the circuit.3.
Clean the Motor
Clean the motor windings and terminals with a suitable solvent to remove any dirt or contaminants.4.
Perform Megger Tests
Test each motor lead to ground (T1 to Ground, T2 to Ground, T3 to Ground). Record each reading. Test phase to phase (T1 to T2, T1 to T3, T2 to T3). Record each reading.5.
Interpret Results
If any of the lead-to-ground readings are below the acceptable threshold (remembering the 1 MΩ + 1 MΩ/kV rule), the motor insulation is compromised. The 0.4 MΩ you initially saw confirms this. Low phase to phase resistance readings also indicate a problem.6.
Replace the Motor
Based on your initial readings and the fact that the motor is causing shorts when running, replacing the motor is the correct course of action.
Important Safety Notes
Capacitive Discharge
After performing a megger test, always discharge the motor windings. Insulation testers charge the motor windings with DC voltage, and a residual charge can remain. Many meggers have an automatic discharge function, but it's good practice to manually discharge the motor as well.
Safety Glasses and Gloves
Wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE) when working with electrical equipment.
In summary, your suspicion is correct. The Fluke 1507 is reducing voltage because it's detecting a low-resistance path to ground, which confirms the motor has a compromised winding. Replacing the motor is the right decision. Flag for review