User: kjroller, Location: Dawson Mn
Asked on: Wednesday, October 8, 2025 at 3:31 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, October 8, 2025 at 3:33 pm EDT
Question: On a Analog output instrument in this case a fisher valve can you connect the Emerson 475 hart communicator direct to the valve (DVC6200) with no 250-ohm resistor? I know it doesn't hurt to use one but was wondering. Also I know why you use the 250 ohm resistor but am under the impression you can use up to 1100 ohms if need be which would operate between 4.4 and 22 vdc instead of 1-5vdc I understand you would rather use 250 ohm however I'm wondering if that is why you could hook up direct to a Analog output travel valve cause you would have a higher resistance internally through the instrument then 250 ohms at any given time. Let me know if I am on the right track or if anyone has any input. Thank you. I understand most analog input cards have 250 ohms built in strictly wondering on analog output.
Okay, let's break down the HART communication and the resistor question with the DVC6200 (and similar devices). You're on the right track with some of your thinking, but there are a few key points to clarify.
Direct Connection (No External Resistor) on Analog Output Valves for HART Communication Yes, you can connect a HART communicator (like the Emerson 475) directly to a DVC6200 (or similar HART valve positioner) on an analog output loop (mA signal from the control system) without an external 250-ohm resistor. Why? The DVC6200 itself (and similar modern HART field devices) provides the necessary impedance (resistance) internally for the HART signal to function. It's designed to modulate the current loop without the need for an external resistor. Why the Confusion? The confusion often arises because of the need for a resistor when using a HART communicator on a standard 4-20mA input channel, where you are not outputting voltage. In that situation, the resistor converts the current signal from the HART device into a voltage that the HART communicator can read, without disrupting the 4-20mA signal on the loop. However, when the valve positioner is on an analog output loop, the 4-20mA signal is coming from the DCS/PLC, not the valve, which already creates a voltage.
Important Considerations
Documentation
Always refer to the DVC6200 (or the specific device's) documentation. It will explicitly state if an external resistor is needed for HART communication. Typically, it will say it's not required. The reason is the valve provides the internal resistance.
Polarity
Ensure correct polarity when connecting the HART communicator. Wrong polarity can damage the device or prevent communication.
Wiring
Connect the HART communicator in parallel across the signal wires.
Analog Output Module Characteristics
Double-check the documentation for the analog output module (the card in your DCS/PLC that's sending the 4-20mA signal). It should be a standard current source (i.e., designed to maintain the current regardless of the load within its specified limits). Most modern analog output cards are designed to work with HART devices without needing external resistors, but confirming is crucial.
Regarding Resistance Values (250-ohm vs. Higher) 250-ohm Standard
The 250-ohm resistor is the de facto standard because it's generally considered the optimal value for creating the voltage drop (1-5 VDC) needed for a HART communicator to read the signal without significantly impacting the 4-20mA loop.
Higher Resistance (Up to 1100 Ohms)
Yes, technically, you could use a higher resistance, but it's generally not recommended and can cause problems.
Voltage Drop
A higher resistance will create a larger voltage drop across the resistor (Ohm's Law: V = IR). At 20mA (full scale), an 1100-ohm resistor would drop 22V (0.020A 1100 ohms = 22V).
Loop Voltage Requirements
The power supply in the 4-20mA loop needs to be able to provide enough voltage to overcome the voltage drops in the entire loop and still provide sufficient voltage for the field device to operate correctly. If the resistance is too high, the device won't function.
Accuracy & Signal Degradation
Using too high of a resistance can also introduce non-linearity and impact the accuracy of the 4-20mA signal, especially at lower current levels.
HART Signal Integrity
The HART signal is a small frequency-shift keyed (FSK) signal superimposed on the 4-20mA. A significantly high resistance can attenuate or distort this signal, making HART communication unreliable.
Why 250-ohm is Preferred
The 250-ohm resistor is a good compromise: Provides a sufficient voltage drop (1-5 VDC) for HART communication. Doesn't overly burden the loop power supply. Maintains the integrity of the 4-20mA signal. Doesn't significantly attenuate the HART signal.
In Summary
For modern HART valve positioners like the DVC6200 on an analog output loop, you generally do not need an external 250-ohm resistor for HART communication. The device provides the internal resistance.2. While technically possible, using a higher resistance than 250 ohms is not recommended due to potential problems with loop voltage, accuracy, and HART signal integrity.3. Always* consult the device documentation to confirm the specific requirements for HART communication.Let me know if you have any other questions! Flag for review