User: msilva94, Location: PA, USA
Asked on: Wednesday, October 8, 2025 at 4:48 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, October 8, 2025 at 4:48 pm EDT
Question: Hello all,I’m working on a site where the client wants the entire 800A Main Distribution Panelboard (MDP) backed up by a single generator.They also want to avoid using battery backups for emergency lighting. I'm figuring to place the lighting on a new 100A Panel 'EM', but not sure how to provide normal power to it.Per code, emergency lighting must be powered from a source separate from normal lighting.Here was my brief thought:800A MDP powers:Circuit 1 – 400A Panel 'A'Circuit 2 – 400A Panel 'B'Circuit 3 – 100A Panel 'EM'800A ATS feeds the MDP (normal loads backed up by generator)100A ATS feeds Panel 'EM' (emergency lighting backed up by generator)The issue is that if Panel 'EM' is fed from the MDP, this creates a loop.I’m struggling to figure out a simple solution without introducing more equipment.Thanks in advance.
You've correctly identified the core challenge: providing normal power to your "EM" panel in a way that complies with the requirement for separation from the normal lighting circuits. Here are a few options, ranked generally from simpler to more complex, and some considerations for each
Option 1: Taps Before the Main ATS - Preferred if Possible
Description
This is often the most straightforward and cost-effective approach, if feasible from a physical and service capacity standpoint. You tap the utility service before the 800A ATS, and feed that tap to the 100A EM panel.
Wiring Diagram
Utility Service --> Tap 1 --> 800A ATS --> 800A MDP --> Panels A & B Utility Service --> Tap 2 --> 100A EM Panel --> Emergency Lighting
Advantages
Simplicity: Requires only a tap off the utility service. Cost-Effective: Minimizes equipment needed. Clear Code Compliance: Absolutely isolates the EM panel source from the loads the generator backs up.
Disadvantages
Requires Physical Tap Location: You need space and accessibility at the service entrance to make the tap. Capacity Concerns: Ensure the utility service has enough capacity to handle the additional 100A load of the EM panel. You'll need to do a load calculation. Coordination with Utility: You'll need to coordinate the tap and metering (if applicable) with the utility company. Overcurrent Protection: Ensure adequate overcurrent protection ahead of your new emergency panel.
Important Considerations
This is the best option if physically possible and if you have enough service capacity. The tap should have its own dedicated overcurrent protection (fuse or circuit breaker).
Option 2: Separate Service (Less Preferred, More Costly) Description
Obtain a completely separate electrical service from the utility solely for the EM panel.
Advantages
Complete Isolation: The EM panel is entirely independent of the main service. Guaranteed Compliance: Easily meets the "separate source" requirement.
Disadvantages
Cost: Significant cost due to the additional service installation, metering, and ongoing service fees. Coordination: Requires extensive coordination with the utility company. Physical Space: Requires space for the new service entrance equipment.
Option 3: Dual-Source EM Panel (More Complex, Requires Special Panel) Description
Use a special "dual-source" emergency lighting transfer panel (or a standard transfer switch) specifically designed for emergency lighting. This panel has two separate incoming feeds. One feed comes from your generator-backed 800A MDP (for generator backup) and the other feed comes from a tap upstream of the 800A ATS (for normal power). The dual-source panel automatically switches to the generator feed when normal power is lost.
Advantages
Compact: All switching is contained within a single panel. Flexibility: Can be used in situations where a separate tap is difficult.
Disadvantages
Cost: Dual-source panels are specialized and more expensive than standard panels. Complexity: More complex wiring and control circuitry. Requires Careful Specification: You must carefully specify the panel to ensure it meets all emergency lighting requirements and transfer times.
Option 4: Small UPS for Normal Power (Less Common, Can be Problematic) Description
Provide a small Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) for the EM panel. The UPS is continuously fed from the 800A MDP. During a power outage, the UPS provides power to the EM panel until the generator comes online.
Advantages
Potentially Simple Installation: No major wiring changes (aside from feeding the UPS).
Disadvantages
Cost: UPS adds to the cost. Battery Maintenance: UPS batteries require regular maintenance and replacement. UPS Sizing: You need to size the UPS correctly to handle the load of the EM panel and provide sufficient runtime until the generator starts. Code Issues:
This method is generally discouraged by code enforcement. While it appears to provide a separate source, the UPS is ultimately still fed from the normal power system. Inspectors often interpret this as not meeting the "separate source" requirement. It's a gray area and very likely to be rejected. Also, some UPS units will not operate properly when fed from a generator due to harmonic distortion.
Analysis and Recommendations1. Prioritize Option 1 (Taps Before the ATS)
Thoroughly investigate the feasibility of tapping the utility service before the 800A ATS. Perform a load calculation to confirm sufficient service capacity. This is the cleanest and most compliant solution.2.
Consider Option 3 (Dual-Source EM Panel) if Option 1 isn't Possible
This is your next best option if you can't get a tap point upstream of the ATS. This requires careful planning and the selection of the correct equipment.3.
Avoid Option 4 (UPS)
While seemingly simple, the potential code compliance issues and the ongoing maintenance of the UPS make it a less desirable solution.4.
Option 2 (Separate Service) is the Least Desirable
The high cost and complexity make this a last resort.
Important Notes
Local Codes
Consult your local electrical inspector and AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) before making any decisions. They will have the final say on what is acceptable.
Emergency Lighting Requirements
Be absolutely certain you understand all the applicable codes and standards for emergency lighting in your jurisdiction (e.g., NFPA 101, local building codes). Pay close attention to required illumination levels, transfer times, and testing procedures.
Load Calculations
Perform accurate load calculations for both the main service and the EM panel to ensure you have adequate capacity.
Coordination
Coordinate with the utility company early in the design process, especially if you are considering a tap or a separate service.*
Documentation: Maintain thorough documentation of your design, including load calculations, wiring diagrams, and product specifications.By carefully evaluating these options and consulting with the relevant authorities, you can develop a safe and code-compliant emergency lighting solution for your client. Good luck! Flag for review