Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: HVAC Equipment Causing Surges

User: mikev86, Location: Easton, MD

Asked on: Thursday, October 9, 2025 at 10:16 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, October 9, 2025 at 10:16 am EDT

Question: Hello all,We recently had a new 480V panel installed to serve some sensitive automotive equipment and a new 10-ton packaged HVAC unit.Prior to HVAC unit being installed, SPD counter was at 3. Since HVAC unit was installed we have been getting an average of 4 hits/day.There are no VFDs present and the HVAC unit is not cycling on and off frequently. We have checked for damaged wires and loose connections, even had Trane come out to investigate their unit and found nothing. That being said, when we turned off the disconnect, the surges stopped.We are looking at moving the HVAC unit to another panel to not have it on the same source as the sensitive equipment, but have concerns the surges will still happen and the other existing 480V panels do not have any surge protective devices.Looking for recommendations on what else to check and troubleshoot.Thank you!Mike

This is a classic surge problem investigation, and the fact that disconnecting the HVAC unit stops the surges is very telling. Here's a breakdown of things to check and potential solutions

1. Deep Dive into the HVAC Unit Itself:
Component Analysis

While Trane found nothing
obviously wrong, they might not be looking for surge-related causes. Focus on components that can generate transients:

Compressor Start-up

Even without a VFD, the compressor motor starting creates a significant inrush current and voltage transient. Look at the starting method (across-the-line, soft start, etc.). A soft starter, even if it's already present, could be faulty and creating more noise than it should.

Condenser Fan Motor

Check the condenser fan motor's starting method. Is it a standard motor with a contactor, or a multi-speed motor? The transitions between speeds can cause transients.


Contactor Chatter/Arcing

A weak or failing contactor in the HVAC unit can cause significant arcing and generate surges. Listen closely to the contactors while the unit is running. If you hear buzzing or excessive noise, it's suspect.

Control Board Power Supply

The HVAC unit's internal control board has a power supply. Check its condition and whether it's properly grounded. A failing capacitor in the power supply could cause noise.


Grounding Issues within the HVAC Unit

Verify the unit's grounding.

Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC)

Is the EGC properly sized and tightly connected to the unit's chassis and the panelboard's ground bus? High-frequency surges can be attenuated by a properly sized and installed EGC.


Bonding

Is the unit properly bonded to any metal piping or ductwork that might act as a ground?

HVAC Unit Wiring

Double-check all wiring connections
within the HVAC unit. Loose connections, even within the unit itself, can cause arcing.

2. Power Quality Issues



Voltage Imbalance

Measure the voltage on all three phases at the 480V panel, both with and without the HVAC unit running. Significant voltage imbalance can stress equipment and cause it to generate more noise. Also, measure the voltage at the HVAC disconnect to see if there's a voltage drop.

Harmonics

Use a power quality analyzer to measure harmonics present on the 480V system. HVAC units, even without VFDs, can generate harmonics. A high harmonic content can exacerbate surge problems. Consider a harmonic filter if the THD (Total Harmonic Distortion) is high.


Transient Voltage Recording

If you have access to a power quality analyzer with transient recording capabilities, capture the voltage waveform around the time the HVAC unit cycles on or off. This will give you a visual picture of the surges.

3. Grounding System Review



Grounding Electrode System

Is the grounding electrode system (ground rods, water pipe ground, etc.) adequate? If the ground impedance is too high, it won't effectively dissipate surge energy.


Ground Bus Connections

Verify that all connections to the ground bus in the 480V panel are clean and tight.

Separately Derived Systems

Are there any separately derived systems (transformers, generators) that might be contributing to grounding issues? Ensure all separately derived systems are properly grounded and bonded according to code.

4. SPD Placement and Configuration



SPD Proximity

The SPD should be located as close as possible to the equipment it's protecting. The longer the wiring between the SPD and the equipment, the less effective the SPD becomes. Consider installing a second SPD right at the sensitive automotive equipment.

SPD Type and Rating

Is the SPD adequately rated for the type of surges you're experiencing? It's possible that the surges are exceeding the SPD's clamping voltage. A higher-rated SPD might be necessary. Consider an SPD specifically designed for HVAC systems (they often have filters to reduce nuisance tripping).


SPD Grounding

The SPD must be properly grounded. A poor ground connection can render the SPD ineffective. Keep the SPD's grounding conductor as short and straight as possible.

SPD Monitoring

Is the SPD monitoring system working correctly? Are the indicators displaying correct information?

5. Isolation and Filtering



Isolation Transformer

An isolation transformer between the 480V panel and the sensitive equipment can effectively block common-mode noise.

Line Reactors/Chokes

Install line reactors or chokes on the HVAC unit's power feed. These can help to dampen transients generated by the unit.


RFI/EMI Filters

Consider installing RFI/EMI filters at both the HVAC unit and the sensitive equipment.

6. Moving the HVAC Unit



If you move the HVAC unit,
install an SPD at the panel to which you move it. Otherwise, you're just shifting the problem. It's crucial to protect every panelboard. Even after moving the HVAC, you still need to investigate and mitigate the source of the surges. Simply moving the problem doesn't solve it. Consider a dedicated panel for the HVAC unit, especially if it's a significant source of noise.

Troubleshooting Steps


Isolate

Disconnect the HVAC unit and monitor the SPD counter. If the counts stop, the HVAC unit is definitely the culprit.2.

Voltage and Harmonic Measurements

Take comprehensive voltage and harmonic measurements at the 480V panel with and without the HVAC unit running.3.

Inspect the HVAC Unit

Carefully inspect the HVAC unit for loose connections, damaged components, and grounding issues.4.

Transient Recording

If possible, use a power quality analyzer to record transient voltages when the HVAC unit cycles on and off.5.

Test with a Different SPD

If you have a spare SPD, try swapping it out with the existing one. It's possible the existing SPD is faulty.6.

Consult a Power Quality Expert

If you're unable to resolve the problem, consider consulting a power quality expert. They have specialized equipment and experience in diagnosing and mitigating power quality problems.

Important Considerations



Safety

Always work on electrical equipment with the power off and follow proper lockout/tagout procedures.

Qualified Personnel

Only qualified electricians should perform electrical work.


Local Codes:
Ensure all work complies with local electrical codes and regulations.By systematically investigating these areas, you should be able to identify the source of the surges and implement a solution to protect your sensitive equipment. Remember to document your findings and actions taken for future reference. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question