User: sparky, Location: Pennsylvania
Asked on: Thursday, October 9, 2025 at 11:49 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, October 9, 2025 at 11:50 am EDT
Question: Working in Pa which is still under 2017 code. We mounted a 400 amp disconnect for a fast food restaurant (according to the electrical drawings) at the power company transformer vault location on a rack and strut. From there we installed underground wires into the building into a main lug panel. This all according to the electrical drawing.Inspector failed the install because the exterior disconnect is to far away. It is across the parking lot about 100 ft away. I cant find anything in the code limiting the distance. All I find is 230.70 (A) (1) Readily accessible location. It is odd to have it that far away but we installed according the the engineered drawings.Any help on discussing this with the inspector other than 230.70?
You're in a tough spot, caught between engineered drawings and the inspector's interpretation of the NEC. Here's a breakdown of how to approach this
1. Focus on "Readily Accessible" and Safety Implications (Since you're under 2017 NEC):
Definition of Readily Accessible (Article 100 - Definitions)
The 2017 NEC defines "Readily Accessible" as "Capable of being reached quickly for operation, renewal, or inspections, without requiring those to whom ready access is requisite to climb over or remove obstacles or to resort to portable ladders, and so forth."
Safety Considerations are Paramount
Emphasize the intent behind the "readily accessible" requirement, which is SAFETY. Argue that 100 feet is arguably too far in an emergency situation. Think about these scenarios:
Fire
If there's a fire inside the building, firefighters need to quickly disconnect power to the building. 100 feet across a parking lot could add crucial minutes, especially in bad weather.
Electrical Fault/Arc Flash
If there's a major electrical fault inside, employees or emergency responders need to be able to kill the power quickly.
Maintenance/Troubleshooting
Maintenance personnel will need to switch power off and on for normal repairs. The time involved walking to and from the disconnect creates more down time for the business.
Practicality
100 feet is also a substantial distance for anyone to travel to shut the power off to perform maintenance.
2. Check for Local Amendments or Utility Requirements
Pennsylvania Amendments
While you're under the 2017 NEC, Pennsylvania might have local amendments that further restrict the location of service disconnects. Check with your local municipality and/or the Pennsylvania Department of Labor & Industry for any specific requirements.
Utility Requirements
The power company might have requirements that influence the disconnect location. Contact them to see if they have any guidelines that are relevant.
3. Leverage the Engineered Drawings (Carefully)
The Engineer's Rationale
Ideally, you should contact the electrical engineer who designed the drawings and ask them to provide their rationale for placing the disconnect that far away. There might have been very specific site constraints they were trying to address. Get this rationale in writing.
Don't Solely Rely on "We followed the Drawings"
The inspector is responsible for enforcing the NEC and ensuring safety. Saying "We followed the drawings" isn't a guaranteed defense. The engineer may have made an error, or the situation on-site may have changed since the drawings were created.
Potential Value Engineering Opportunity
Can the location be moved closer? This might come at additional cost for running new conduit, but this is a conversation to have with the engineer and owner.
4. Communication and Negotiation with the Inspector
Polite and Professional
Be respectful and professional when discussing this with the inspector. Show them you understand their concerns about safety.
Ask for Clarification
Ask the inspector to point to the specific code section(s) beyond 230.70(A)(1) that they believe the installation violates. This forces them to articulate their reasoning.
Present Your Arguments
Present your arguments regarding the engineer's design (if you have a good rationale) and any site-specific considerations.
Seek a Compromise
Try to find a compromise solution. Is there a more suitable location that's closer but still meets the needs of the power company and the building? Could additional safety measures (e.g., a clearly marked, dedicated pathway to the disconnect) mitigate some of the inspector's concerns?
5. Documentation
Keep Detailed Records
Document everything – your conversations with the inspector, the engineer, the utility, and any research you do on local amendments.*
Formal Appeal (If Necessary)
If you cannot resolve the issue with the inspector, you have the right to appeal their decision. Follow the formal appeal process outlined by your local jurisdiction. This usually involves submitting a written appeal to a board of appeals.
In summary, while following the engineered drawings is important, it doesn't supersede the NEC's safety requirements. Focus on the "readily accessible" requirement, emphasizing the safety implications of the distance to the disconnect, check for local amendments, and communicate effectively with the inspector to find a solution. Flag for review