Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Motor starting surge on a generator?

User: zbang, Location: Roughly 5346 miles from Earls Court

Asked on: Saturday, October 11, 2025 at 12:34 am EDT
Answered on: Saturday, October 11, 2025 at 12:35 am EDT

Question: We're working over an event site problem-One of the caterers has a soft-serve ice cream machine (which we Have Opinions about). When they serve the "twist" of both flavors, it appears that the starting current of both auger motors together (my guess- 2HP each) causes the generator governor to try pulling up the voltage, which then spikes once the start surge slacks off. This is causing pretty much every LED in that area (100s of them) to flicker and is really bothering a lot of people. It may have caused some damage but there are no hard examples.Presently, that site is on a 75(?) KVA diesel with Deep Sea electronic governor. We're thinking that swapping the 75 for an otherwise-identical 150 KVA unit might lessen the apparent problem due to the larger size and rotating mass of the generator itself. Does this make sense or are we just rationalizing a solution? (We're going to make the swap anyway so folks can see that we're trying to deal with the issue.)Any other thoughts on the matter?

Okay, let's break down this event site power issue and analyze your proposed solution and potential alternatives.

Understanding the Problem



Inrush Current

You've correctly identified the likely culprit: the inrush current of the soft-serve machine's motors when they start. Induction motors draw significantly more current during startup (typically 5-7 times the running current) than during normal operation.


Generator Governor Response

The generator's governor is trying to compensate for the voltage dip caused by the inrush current. However, the governor's response isn't instantaneous. It overshoots the correction, causing a voltage spike.

LED Flicker

LEDs are sensitive to voltage fluctuations. The voltage sags and spikes are causing the LEDs to flicker noticeably.


Electronic Governor

The Deep Sea electronic governor should be faster and more responsive than a mechanical governor. The fact that it isn't perfectly handling this surge is a key point.

Potential Damage

Voltage fluctuations can indeed damage sensitive electronic equipment, especially if the spikes are severe.

Analysis of Your Proposed Solution (Switching to a 150 kVA Generator)



Rationale

The idea is that a larger generator has a larger rotating mass and a more powerful engine. This increased inertia helps to resist voltage dips and spikes when a large load is suddenly applied. The larger engine should also provide more "headroom" to handle the surge without bogging down.

Does it Make Sense?
Yes, it can help, but it's not a guaranteed fix. Pros

A larger generator provides more power reserve, which can better absorb the inrush current without significant voltage drop. The increased inertia will definitely help to smooth out the voltage fluctuations.

Cons

It's a brute-force approach. It's not addressing the root cause of the problem (the high inrush current and the governor's inadequate response). It's also a more expensive solution than some other options. There's still a chance the larger generator will also exhibit
some flicker, though hopefully reduced.

Here's a more detailed breakdown of why it
might not be a perfect solution



Governor Tuning

The electronic governor's response might still be the limiting factor. Even with a larger generator, a poorly tuned governor can still overcompensate and cause voltage spikes. The speed of the governor's response is critical. The governor needs to sense the change quickly and react appropriately.

Generator Impedance

The generator's internal impedance also plays a role. Higher impedance will lead to more voltage sag during load changes. The impedance is usually a characteristic of the generator design and is often specified in the generator's datasheet.

Other Thoughts and Solutions

Here are some other approaches to consider, ideally in combination with, or even instead of, the generator swap:1.

Inrush Current Limiters

This is often the
best solution.

Thermistor-based Limiters

These are relatively inexpensive. They start with high resistance and then heat up, decreasing resistance and allowing full current flow over a few seconds. This smooths out the inrush. You'd need one for each motor. You can build these yourself or buy them as pre-assembled units.

Solid-State Soft Starters

These are more sophisticated and more expensive. They gradually ramp up the voltage to the motor, limiting inrush current. They provide more control and are generally more effective than thermistors.2.

Adjust the Governor

Contact a Deep Sea generator technician and
ask them to tune the governor for better transient response. Explain the situation and the exact load characteristics. They might be able to optimize the governor's parameters to minimize voltage overshoot. This is critical.3.

Staggered Start

Can the soft-serve machine be configured so that the two auger motors don't start simultaneously? A small delay (even half a second) can significantly reduce the peak inrush current.4.

Capacitor Start/Run Motors

The existing motors are likely induction motors. Capacitor Start/Run motors have lower inrush currents because of the capacitor used to provide extra torque at startup. A motor replacement might be considered, but this would require a review of the existing application.5.

Dedicated Circuit

Run a dedicated, heavy-gauge cable directly from the generator to the soft-serve machine. This minimizes voltage drop in the wiring. Make sure the cable is sized to handle the inrush current.6.

Power Conditioner/UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply)

Place a UPS or power conditioner between the generator and the LEDs. A UPS provides a clean and stable power source, filtering out voltage fluctuations. A power conditioner provides surge protection and voltage regulation. This can be more expensive and complex, but it provides a very clean power source for the sensitive LEDs. You might be able to isolate the LED lighting circuits with a large UPS, solving the LED flickering while still using the existing generator for the bulk loads.7.

Phase Balancing

Ensure that the load is evenly distributed across the three phases of the generator. An unbalanced load can cause voltage fluctuations and reduced generator efficiency. Use a clamp meter to measure the current on each phase.8.

Generator Grounding

Verify that the generator is properly grounded. This is crucial for safety and can also help to reduce voltage fluctuations. Consult with a qualified electrician.9.

Check Generator Wiring

Ensure all connections inside the generator's control panel and at the output terminals are clean and tight. Loose connections can cause voltage drops and arcing, which will exacerbate the problem.

Prioritization

I would recommend this order of investigation/action:1.

Governor Tuning

This is potentially the cheapest and most effective fix.2.

Inrush Current Limiters

Implement on the soft-serve machine's motors.3.

Staggered Start

Investigate if this is an option on the soft-serve machine.4.

Dedicated Circuit

Run a dedicated circuit for the ice cream machine5.

Generator Swap

Proceed with the swap if the above options are insufficient or impractical. Monitor the results carefully.6.

Power Conditioner/UPS

Consider this if all else fails or if you need to guarantee flicker-free operation for the LEDs.

Before Swapping the Generator



Measure Inrush Current

Use a clamp meter with inrush current capability to measure the actual inrush current of the soft-serve machine motors. This will give you a more precise understanding of the load and help you size any inrush current limiters appropriately. It also can help confirm your theory.*

Monitor Voltage

Use a recording voltmeter or a power quality analyzer to monitor the voltage at the generator output and at the soft-serve machine's input. This will give you a visual representation of the voltage fluctuations and help you assess the effectiveness of any solutions.

Key Takeaway:


While swapping the generator to a larger unit may provide some improvement, it's not a guaranteed solution. A more targeted approach, such as using inrush current limiters and properly tuning the governor, is likely to be more effective and cost-efficient. Measure, analyze, and address the root cause of the problem for the best results. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question