Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Interesting GFCI problem

User: Lmtoland, Location: Alabama

Asked on: Saturday, October 11, 2025 at 5:06 am EDT
Answered on: Saturday, October 11, 2025 at 6:09 am EDT

Question: Was called by my sister to help with a situation she encountered when she moved in to a new (to her) house. She assumed that this would be a simple issue for me and I did as well,, at least at first.House she moved in to is a 1950's era farm house. kitchen wiring appears to be original (cloth insulation, two wire, no EGC) but outlets have been updated to GFCI outlets. The house came with a propane range. She brought her refrigerator (about two years old) with her. The only outlet within reach of the refrigerator was the outlet in which the propane range was already plugged in to which is a standard NEMA 5-15 receptacle which is fed from the load side of a 5-20 GFCI receptacle on the other side of the kitchen. No EGC is supplied to the receptacle.Propane range functioned normally prior to installing the fridge and caused no issues even when utilizing the electric ignitor. However, once the fridge was plugged in to the same receptacle the GFCI would trip, sometimes immediately, and sometimes after several minutes. This would occur regardless of whether or not the range was being actively used.I verified that the range alone did not trip the GFCI. I then plugged in only the fridge and it alone did not trip the GFCI. Only when both were plugged in did the GFCI trip. Naturally one would assume that there was a small amount of leakage current from each device that when added together would surpass the threshold of the GFCI and cause a trip. However, upon thinking about it, I considered this unlikely since there was no EGC and the appliances sat upon a ceramic tile floor in a house built over a crawlspace.So after staring at the situation for a while and thinking it over I realized that the propane line running to the range was uninterrupted copper pipe that ran from the range into the ground in the crawlspace and emerged from the ground near the propane tank. So now I knew that the range and the fridge were being "grounded" through the propane line that connected to the chassis of the range which was in turn bonded to the EGC in the range cord which then created a path to ground through the outlet ground for the fridge.Based on a few hunches, I plugged the range into the receptacle normally and then used a grounding adapter to plug the fridge into the outlet as well so that the EGC in the fridge cord would no longer have continuity with the receptacle and therefore the "ground" provided through the propane line. Now the GFCI holds. I then took some measurements and this is where it really gets bizarre. The voltage between the fridge chassis and the "grounded" range chassis was 22V. I should also mention that the fridge was plugged into a 5-15 outlet (non-GFCI) at her previous house which she says she feels sure was grounded because the "grounded" LED on her surge protector she once used for the fridge used to stay lit.Out of curiosity, I place the back of my hand on the range and touched the fridge with my elbow expecting to sense a shock. I did not feel anything. However, I did hear a very faint buzzing sound when I bridged the two appliances with my arm. I used a different multimeter to check the values from before and confirmed the 22V to ground on the fridge frame. However, this meter gave me a frequency reading (the other meter did not have that feature) of 2.4kHz !? I initially doubted that reading, but it would explain the buzzing sound and the fact that I didn't feel a shock.So, thoughts? Ultimately, the kitchen is going to be rewired completely. But, what do you suspect is going on here? is the fridge defective? Will is trip a rewired GFCI circuit that has a EGC? Or is something going on here that is just outside my experience that maybe one of you has encountered?

This is a fascinating and complex situation! Here's a breakdown of potential causes and my thoughts

Understanding the Setup and Observations:
Old Wiring, New GFCI Outlets

This is a common but potentially problematic scenario. GFCI outlets are being used to address the lack of a ground wire in old wiring. While they protect against ground faults, they don't
create a safe grounding system.

Propane Range Grounding

The copper propane line acting as a ground is a major red flag. It's unintended, potentially dangerous, and likely contributing to the GFCI tripping.

GFCI Tripping Only When Both Appliances are Plugged In

This is the key clue. It indicates some form of current leakage or potential difference between the two appliances that the GFCI is detecting.


Fridge Alone Doesn't Trip GFCI

This makes a direct fault in the fridge's power cord or compressor less likely, but doesn't rule out internal leakage.

Voltage Between Appliance Chassis (22V @ 2.4 kHz)

This is very unusual and the frequency reading is especially strange. It suggests a non-conventional leakage path or induced voltage.


Grounding Adapter "Fix"

Using a grounding adapter effectively disconnects the fridge's chassis from any potential ground connection, preventing the GFCI from tripping. This confirms that the ground path is the problem, not a short to neutral or hot.

Previous House's "Grounded" Surge Protector LED

This is anecdotal evidence that suggests the fridge was grounded properly at the previous location.

Potential Causes and Explanations


Fridge Motor Inductance / Capacitance

Many appliances have capacitors and inductors in their motors or power supplies. These can create a small amount of leakage current to the chassis. Normally, this leakage is shunted to ground via the EGC. However, without a proper ground, this leakage current can find other paths to ground (like the propane line). The 2.4 kHz could be a byproduct of the inverter / variable speed compressor.
2.


Range Ignition Module

The electric ignitor for the propane range could also be contributing to some high-frequency noise or voltage on the chassis, though this would typically be at 60hz.3.

The "Ground" Isn't Truly Ground

The copper propane line is likely acting as a somewhat conductive path to ground, but it is not a true code-compliant ground. The ground potential can float relative to the actual earth ground.4.

Neutral-Ground Bond Issue (Less Likely but Possible)

In older wiring, sometimes the neutral wire can develop a connection to a grounded object elsewhere in the house. This can cause current to flow on the "ground" path and create a voltage difference. This is less likely since you are seeing voltage on the fridge chassis even with no ground connection, but it is something to investigate.5.

Harmonics and Noise

The interaction between the fridge's power supply (especially if it's a modern inverter-type fridge) and the old wiring could be generating harmonics and electrical noise that is being coupled onto the chassis.6.

DC Leakage

It's possible that there is a DC leakage on the fridge chassis. Standard AC multimeters will not accurately measure DC voltage. However, DC on the chassis could cause corrosion on the copper propane line acting as a ground rod.

Troubleshooting Steps


Electrical Isolation



Disconnect Appliances

Unplug everything from the affected circuit except the GFCI outlet. Use a multimeter to check for voltage between the neutral and the grounding electrode. If you get a reading, you likely have a neutral-ground bond issue elsewhere in the house.

Inspect the Copper Propane Line

Visually inspect the copper propane line where it enters the ground. Check for corrosion. If possible, disconnect the propane line temporarily to measure the voltage between the range chassis and a known good ground (like a grounding rod).2.

Appliance Testing



Megohmmeter (Megger) Test

A megohmmeter applies a high DC voltage to test the insulation resistance of appliance wiring. This can detect subtle insulation breakdown that a regular multimeter won't find. Test both the fridge and the range, especially between the hot/neutral wires and the chassis.

Clamp Meter Current Measurement

Use a clamp meter to measure the current flowing through the propane line while both appliances are plugged in (before doing any rewiring). This can quantify the amount of leakage current.3.

Wiring Inspection



Check the GFCI Wiring

Ensure the GFCI outlet is wired correctly. The line and load terminals should be wired correctly, and the grounding wire (if present) should be properly connected.

Recommendations



Rewire the Kitchen

This is the ultimate solution. A properly grounded wiring system will provide a safe and reliable ground path for all appliances.


Replace the Range

It is possible that the range is contributing to the problem. Replacing the range will eliminate it as a variable.

Replace the Fridge

The 2.4 kHz signal is very strange. Consider taking it to an appliance repair shop to have it checked. It is possible that a component is failing.


Replace the GFCI

The GFCI may also be defective and more sensitive than it is rated for.

Proper Grounding

DO NOT rely on the propane line for grounding. This is a hazardous situation. The copper propane line is corroding and this can cause a propane leak, which is very dangerous.

Important Safety Considerations



Electricity and Propane are Dangerous

If you are not comfortable working with electricity or propane, hire a qualified electrician or HVAC technician.

Turn Off the Power

Always turn off the power at the breaker before working on electrical wiring.


Test Before Touching

Use a non-contact voltage tester to ensure that wires are not live before touching them.

In Summary:


The combination of old wiring, a copper propane line acting as a haphazard ground, and potentially some leakage from the fridge is creating a complex and dangerous situation. The 2.4 kHz signal is bizarre and warrants further investigation of the fridge. Rewiring the kitchen with a proper grounding system is the best long-term solution. Do not use the propane line for grounding!Good luck with this challenging problem! I hope this detailed explanation helps. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question