Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Could this have ever worked.

User: nizak

Asked on: Sunday, October 12, 2025 at 6:23 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, October 12, 2025 at 6:24 pm EDT

Question: Had a customer call me saying he removed a working 120V light fixture and installed a new fixture that then would not work.I get there and find a pair of 3 way switches that are properly wired that controlled the original light.Upon pulling the switches I find that the 14/2 that is what I’ll call the switch leg from the one 3 way has the neutral cut . There isn’t even a trace of the conductor beyond the sheath.The original working light was a 40 year old surface mount T-12 fixture.He shows me a picture of the fixture before he removed it. B-B W-W EG to the case of the fixture.Says he’s been in the house almost 40 years and the only thing he can ever recall doing is changing the T-12 tube.How could it have ever worked?Open splice in the wall picking up a neutral??He said he could physically trace the wire from the light all the way back to where it went down the wall 5’ above the switch box it terminated in.See no reason whatsoever for him to lie about it.

This is a real head-scratcher, and you're right to be skeptical. Here are a few possibilities, ranging from the likely to the highly unlikely (but still technically possible), that could explain how that old light fixture worked

The Most Likely (and Messy) Explanations:
Bootleg Ground/Neutral Connection

This is the most probable culprit, and also the most dangerous. Someone, at some point, may have intentionally or unintentionally connected the neutral conductor of the switch leg to the ground wire. This could have happened:


In the Light Fixture

While unlikely if the customer never touched it, it's possible the neutral was shorting/touching the ground at the fixture itself. Rust, corrosion, or even a damaged insulation could cause a fault.

In the Switch Box

A more likely scenario is that the neutral was intentionally or accidentally touching the metal box, which was grounded. This provides a path for current to return, completing the circuit, but it's a fire hazard.


Further Up the Circuit

The neutral might be connected to the ground somewhere upstream, maybe even back in the panel.

Borrowed Neutral

The neutral may have been "borrowed" from a nearby circuit within the wall. This is a common and dangerous DIY fix that can cause all sorts of problems, including overloads and voltage drops.


Degradation/Failure of Wire

It's possible the neutral wire was damaged or degraded, and the light was barely working. The new fixture may be more sensitive to voltage fluctuations or require a stronger neutral connection.

The Less Likely, But Possible, Scenarios



High-Resistance Ground Fault

In extremely rare cases, a high-resistance path to ground could have been sufficient to allow a small amount of current to flow and illuminate the old fixture. This is more likely in older homes with questionable grounding systems. The new fixture, being different, might not be able to draw enough current through this path.


Phantom Voltage

Sometimes, voltage meters can show a reading even when a circuit isn't truly complete. This "phantom voltage" is usually due to capacitive coupling and is not enough to power a light fixture.

Misremembered Wiring

While the customer swears he only changed the bulb, it's possible he's forgotten something about the wiring over 40 years. Memory is fallible.

What to Do Next


De-energize the Circuit

Turn off the breaker before doing any further investigation.2.

Thoroughly Inspect the Switch Boxes

Carefully examine the switch boxes for any signs of tampering, loose connections, or evidence of a bootleg ground. Check for any wires that appear to be touching the metal box.3.

Continuity Testing

Use a multimeter to perform continuity tests to check the integrity of the neutral conductor. Test from the light fixture location back to the switch box to confirm the break. Also, check for continuity between the neutral and ground wires (there should be none).4.

Check for Bootleg Ground

Use a multimeter to check voltage between the ground wire and a known good neutral. There should be little to no voltage. If you see a significant voltage reading, that's a strong indication of a bootleg ground.5.

Trace the Wiring

Since the customer can trace the wire, try to carefully trace it to see if there's any point where it could be picking up a neutral from another circuit.6.

Open Walls (If Necessary)

If you can't find the source of the problem with visual inspection, you may need to open up the wall to trace the wiring further. Be careful not to damage any other wires or pipes.7.

Consult with a Qualified Electrician

If you're unsure about any of these steps or if you can't find the problem, it's best to consult with a qualified electrician. They have the experience and tools to diagnose and repair electrical problems safely.

Important Safety Notes



Electricity is dangerous.
Always turn off the power before working on electrical circuits. Wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), such as safety glasses and insulated gloves. If you're not comfortable working with electricity, call a qualified electrician.* A bootleg ground is a serious safety hazard. It can cause electric shock, fire, and damage to equipment. If you find a bootleg ground, it should be corrected immediately.This situation highlights the importance of proper wiring and the dangers of DIY electrical work. Good luck with the troubleshooting! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question