User: solarken, Location: Hudson, OH, USA
Asked on: Sunday, October 12, 2025 at 10:54 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, October 12, 2025 at 10:54 pm EDT
Question: I have an install at new construction home where the electrician that installed a Siemens meter main did not leave much room on the right side to bring conduit in thru a knockout from an Enphase Combiner. The left side of the meter main has the barrier for bringing underground service wires up to the meter compartment, and it does not have a knockout. The service wires in this case come into the top of the meter main from overhead, and so that barrier compartment is empty.I would like to punch a hole in the left side of this meter main, and mount the combiner to the left and bring conduit into the barrier compartment, and bring the conductors thru the barrier into the breaker area and land on a branch breaker. Attached is the PDF. Is there any issue with doing this? I have not looked at the meter main physically yet because the site is 90 minutes away. Has anyone installed one of these before and done something similar?
Okay, I've reviewed your situation and the Siemens Meter Main (likely the MC0816B1200 as that's the common 200A model in that series). Here's a breakdown of the considerations and potential issues, along with recommendations
Key Considerations & Potential Issues:
1. NEC Compliance
This is paramount. Your proposed modification touches on several critical articles:
NEC 110.3(B) - Equipment Installation and Use
Equipment must be installed and used in accordance with the instructions included in the listing and labeling requirements. Punching a hole likely voids the UL listing and is a significant code violation.
NEC 312.5(C) - Conductors Entering Boxes, Cabinets, and Enclosures
The method you use for entering the meter main with your conduit must protect the conductors from abrasion and strain. A properly installed connector into a listed knockout is acceptable; a hole you punch probably is not.
NEC 314 - Junction Boxes
While you're not necessarily creating a junction box, you're using a compartment as if it were one. You'd need to ensure adequate working space and access to conductors.
NEC 408.3(A) - Identification of Circuit(s)
Your branch breaker must be clearly identified as feeding the Enphase combiner.2.
UL Listing Violation
This is the biggest problem. Meter mains and load centers are UL-listed as complete assemblies. Modifying the enclosure in the way you describe almost certainly voids the UL listing. This has implications for insurance, inspections, and potential liability.3.
Enclosure Integrity
Punching a hole can compromise the NEMA rating of the enclosure (e.g., NEMA 3R for rainproof). Even a small hole can allow moisture and contaminants to enter, leading to corrosion and electrical faults.4.
Physical Space & Wire Bending Radius
Even if you could legally punch the hole, ensure you have enough room inside the barrier compartment to make proper connections and maintain the correct wire bending radius. Crowding conductors is a code violation and can lead to overheating.5.
Manufacturer's Instructions
Siemens explicitly designs these enclosures with specific knockout locations. They've considered the internal layout, conductor clearances, and structural integrity when placing those knockouts. Deviating from their design is highly discouraged.6.
Barrier Purpose
That barrier compartment is likely meant for the physical segregation of the utility service and customer load conductors to prevent accidental contact or damage.
Why Your Proposed Solution is Problematic
Almost Certainly Violates UL Listing
This is the main issue.
Potential for Compromised Enclosure Integrity
Could lead to water ingress.
Difficult to Achieve a Professional and Code-Compliant Installation
Making a clean, properly protected hole without damaging the enclosure is difficult.
Recommended Solutions (in order of preference)
Move the Combiner
The best solution is to relocate the Enphase Combiner closer to the right side of the meter main so you can use an existing knockout to enter with conduit. Sometimes, even a few inches of relocation makes a huge difference.2.
Use a Larger Nipple/Conduit Offset
If the issue is just the position of the knockout, you could use a larger nipple, short conduit run with a 90-degree bend, or a conduit offset fitting to align the combiner with an existing knockout. Consider using a conduit offset fitting to the existing knockout3.
Consult Siemens Directly
Call Siemens technical support and explain your situation. They might have a specific solution or an official way to modify the enclosure (though this is unlikely). Get any authorization in writing.4.
Replace the Meter Main
This is the most expensive option, but sometimes it's the only way to do the job right. If the electrician completely misjudged the space requirements, a different meter main with knockouts on the correct side might be necessary.
What I Would Do
Go to the Site & Evaluate
Before doing anything else, personally go to the site and take detailed measurements. Take photos. Understand exactly how much space you have and the positioning of the existing knockouts.2.
Try to Move the Combiner
See if relocation is possible. Even a small shift can make a big difference.3.
Examine the Existing Knockouts Closely
Are there any knockouts on the right side that are usable with an offset or a short conduit run?4.
Contact Siemens
If relocation isn't possible, call Siemens and explain your situation. Emphasize the limited space on the right side.5.
If All Else Fails, Consider Replacement
As a last resort, consider replacing the meter main with a model that better suits the installation requirements. This is the safest and most code-compliant approach.
Important Reminders
Always prioritize safety and code compliance. Never compromise the UL listing of electrical equipment unless you have written authorization from the manufacturer.* Consult with a qualified electrical inspector if you have any doubts or questions.
Making a change like this is not the type of thing that is done without consequences, I would highly recommend following my advice. Flag for review