User: Cheapshotsb, Location: Napa California
Asked on: Monday, October 13, 2025 at 8:11 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, October 13, 2025 at 8:12 pm EDT
Question: I have 2 tube equivalent 4' LED lightsNondimmable 65w. The customer purchased all the equipment without consulting me. First lights are too bright.They are already installed. The electricity bill is way too much, and he's wondering if we disconnected one of the strips in the fixture, would it reduce the power consumption?Ultimately, a smaller utility bill
Okay, let's break down this situation and figure out the best course of action.
Understanding the Problem Too Bright
The 65W LED equivalent to a 4' tube is likely overkill for the space, causing discomfort.
High Electricity Bill
65W per fixture adds up, especially if the lights are on for extended periods.
Existing Installation
This adds complexity since uninstalling and replacing is more labor-intensive.
Customer Responsibility
They made the initial decision, but you're now responsible for finding a solution.
Addressing the Core Issue: Reducing Brightness and Power Consumption
Here's a breakdown of options and their feasibility
1. DO NOT DISCONNECT THE STRIP LEDS!
Why This is a Bad Idea
Safety Hazard
Opening the fixture and modifying the wiring voids any safety certifications (UL, ETL, etc.). This could create a fire or shock hazard and expose you to significant liability.
Damage to the Fixture
LED drivers are designed to work with a specific load. Removing part of the load can damage the driver, shortening the lifespan of the remaining LEDs or causing it to fail completely.
Uneven Light
Removing one strip will create uneven light distribution, likely making the problem worse.
Warranty Void
Modifying the fixture will void any warranty.
2. Replacing the fixtures The Best Long-Term Solution
Replacing the fixtures with a lower wattage/lumen output.
Calculate Needs
Determine the appropriate light level for the space. Use a light meter or online calculators to estimate the required lumens. Consider the room's purpose, size, and surface reflectance.
Choose Suitable Replacements
Select LED fixtures with a wattage and lumen output that meet the actual needs, not just an "equivalent" to old fluorescent tubes.
Consider Color Temperature
Choose a color temperature (Kelvin) that's appropriate for the space. Warm white (2700K-3000K) is good for comfort, while cool white (4000K-5000K) is better for task lighting.
Downsides
Initial cost of new fixtures and labor for replacement.
3. Dimmers (Likely Not Feasible with Existing Fixtures) Dimming
Reduces both light output and power consumption.
Compatibility
Most LED fixtures require a compatible LED dimmer. Since the existing lights are non-dimmable, this won't work without replacing the fixtures or the internal driver (which brings you back to option #2).
Downsides
If dimming were possible, it would require replacing the switches with dimmers. Since the customer specifically purchased non-dimmable lights, this is likely not a good option.
4. Light Diffusers or Films (A Less Ideal, But Cheaper, Temporary Solution) How it Works
Applying a translucent film or diffuser to the outside of the fixture to reduce the amount of light emitted.
Pros
Relatively inexpensive, easy to install, doesn't involve electrical modifications.
Cons
Reduces light output but doesn't lower power consumption. Can alter the color temperature. May not be aesthetically pleasing. Light distribution may be affected.
Important Note
Ensure the diffuser or film is heat-resistant and rated for use with LED lighting to avoid any fire hazards.
5. Using Fewer Fixtures (If Possible) Evaluate Coverage
Can the space be adequately lit with only one fixture?
Disconnection
Simply disconnect one of the fixtures.
Downsides
May create dead spots.
Recommendation
Explain the Dangers of Modifying Fixtures
Start by clearly explaining the safety hazards and warranty implications of disconnecting LED strips within the fixtures. Emphasize that it's not a safe or recommended practice.2.
Assess the Lighting Needs
Discuss with the customer the actual purpose of the space and the desired level of illumination.3.
The Best Solution: Replacing the Fixtures
Recommend replacing the fixtures with appropriate-wattage LED fixtures. Provide options with different wattages and lumen outputs. Offer to calculate the estimated energy savings with the new fixtures.4.
If Budget is a Major Concern
Explore the diffuser/film option as a temporary solution, but clearly explain its limitations (doesn't save energy, may affect light color, may not look great).5.
Consider Occupancy Sensors
If the lights are left on unnecessarily, suggest installing occupancy sensors to automatically turn them off when the space is unoccupied. This will significantly reduce energy consumption.
Important Considerations
Liability
Document all conversations and recommendations in writing to protect yourself from liability.
Code Compliance
Ensure any changes comply with local electrical codes.*
Customer Communication: Be honest and transparent with the customer about the situation and the potential solutions.By presenting the options clearly and emphasizing the importance of safety, you can help the customer make an informed decision and find a solution that meets their needs. Good luck! Flag for review