User: Bigbri0104, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Wednesday, October 15, 2025 at 11:40 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, October 15, 2025 at 11:51 am EDT
Question: Hello Everyone,I'm working on a job that entails installing a 24 KW Generac automatic natural gas generator. The electrical service to the home is a 300-amp underground service with two 150-amp main breaker panels inside the basement, fed off a double lugged electrical meter. The service was installed prior to NEC 2020 code cycle. We are only installing one Automatic transfer switch, converting one main panel to a feeder panel, and updating the grounding and bonding system.I already contacted the electric inspector and received the green light to mount our 150-amp automatic transfer switch inside the basement without installing it outside as an "Emergency Disconnect. The inspector also wanted to ensure the electrode system was updated. During our conversation about grounding and bonding, he wanted to make sure that the installation included inversible crimps, if I were to utilize the existing 1/0 common grounding electrode.1st question - Does table 310.12 play into the initial installation, or must the SEU cable be sized to a min of 150 amp for each service panel that was installed? Table 310.12 was not used in the 2017 code cycle I think, which was around the time this house was built. However, for my own education would the electrician install 2/0 AL SEU cable or 3/0 AL SEU cable to each service panel.2nd question - 250.64 (C) states the grounding electrode shall be installed in one continuous length without a splice or joint. If necessary, splices or connections shall be made as permitted in (1) though (4).- Does this allow the electrician to install one large continuous wire by daisy chaining it through both service panels as shown in the picture below, Or must you follow the language in 250.64 (D) because of the charging language stating multiple disconnecting means in separate enclosures?- My other question pertains to 250.64 (D) (2). This sub section states the electrician is allowed to install one continuous electrode from one service panel/servicedisconnect based on the size of the largest ungrounded conductor in the enclosure, and terminate to let's say a water pipe, then install another continuous electrode from the second service panel/service disconnect enclosure to the same water pipe. The reason for the electrode example is because there is one present at the property. Am I reading this and interrupting it correctly?Thanks,Brian
Okay, Brian, this is a multi-faceted question. Let's break it down point by point.1. SEU Cable Sizing (Table 310.12) Does 310.12 apply retroactively? Generally speaking, the code cycle in effect at the time of the original installation governs that installation. You are not required to rip out existing wiring that was compliant with the code at the time it was installed simply because a newer code cycle has come out. This is sometimes referred to as being "Grandfathered" in. However, modifications and additions must comply with the current code cycle. This is where it gets tricky. Since you are making modifications to the electrical service (installing an ATS, updating grounding, and bonding), your work needs to comply with the current NEC. 310.12 does apply to the modifications. Sizing the SEU Cable
If you were installing this service today with a 150 amp breaker using Aluminum SEU, you would most likely use 2/0 Aluminum because it is rated for 175 amps at 75 degrees C.
Important Note
Always consult your local jurisdiction. Some jurisdictions have local amendments that may specify different conductor sizes or require larger sizes for specific applications.
2. Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC) & 250.64
This is where the details matter and can easily be misinterpreted. Let's break down 250.64(C) and (D) 250.64(C) Continuous Length
The ideal scenario is a single, continuous GEC running from the service equipment (main panel) to the grounding electrode (ground rod, water pipe, etc.) without splices.
250.64(C) Exception
This section describes the circumstances where splicing is permitted to the GEC, and the methods of doing so. Examples include irreversible crimps, listed connectors, etc.
250.64(D) Multiple Service Disconnecting Means
This is likely the section you need to focus on due to the multiple 150A main breakers. This section addresses situations where you have multiple service disconnects in separate enclosures.
Daisy Chaining (Your Picture)
Generally, no, daisy-chaining is not allowed as depicted. While it might seem like a continuous run, it technically creates a splice (a connection point within each panel) and doesn't comply with the intent of 250.64(D). Additionally, that illustration doesn't show where the grounding electrodes are connected, which is critical.
250.64(D)(2) Separate Electrodes
This subsection does allow you to run a separate GEC from each service disconnect to the grounding electrode (e.g., water pipe).
Your Interpretation of 250.64(D)(2)
You are interpreting this correctly. You can run a continuous GEC from panel A to the water pipe (sized based on the largest conductor feeding that panel), and then run a separate continuous GEC from panel B to the same water pipe (sized based on the largest conductor feeding panel B).
Practical Application for Your Situation (Assuming you can't drive additional ground rods, etc.)
Given your setup and inspector's input, the most likely (and compliant) method is:1.
Individual GECs
Run a separate GEC from each 150A main breaker panel to the common grounding electrode (water pipe, existing ground rod, etc.). Size each GEC according to Table 250.66 based on the size of the ungrounded conductors feeding that panel. Since they are 1/0 copper, the grounding electrode conductor is a min of #6 copper.
Important Considerations
Water Pipe Electrode
If using a metallic water pipe as a grounding electrode, you must also bond the water pipe within 5 feet of its entry into the building AND supplement it with an additional electrode like a ground rod or ground plate. This is to ensure redundancy in the grounding system.
Existing Ground Rod
If you have an existing ground rod, it must be supplemental to other grounding electrodes.
Bonding
Ensure all metal enclosures (panels, ATS, generator frame, etc.) are properly bonded to the grounding system.
Recommendations
Confirm with Inspector
Before proceeding, explicitly confirm with your inspector your understanding of 250.64(D)(2) and your proposed grounding method using individual GECs to the existing grounding electrode.*
Document Everything: Take detailed photos before, during, and after the installation, especially of the grounding connections and any splices. This can be invaluable for future reference or if any questions arise during inspection.By understanding the code requirements and confirming your approach with the inspector, you can ensure a safe and compliant installation. Good luck! Flag for review