User: jmellc, Location: Durham, NC
Asked on: Thursday, October 16, 2025 at 12:14 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, October 16, 2025 at 12:14 am EDT
Question: Some of us have posted about LED backups but I haven't seen this particular tube discussed. I found Aleddra on the web, they have a few LED's with battery backup built into the tube. Would be perfect for some of the LED conversions I do. Has anyone tried these or any other brand? I hate nothing worse than replacing emergency ballasts in fluorescent troffers. Often hard to find the same model, some connect differently, all crowd the belly pan and all are expensive.Thanks for any feedback.
You're right, dedicated LED tubes with integrated battery backup aren't discussed as frequently as standard LED tubes. It's a niche market but a valuable one, especially considering the hassles of traditional emergency ballast systems.Here's a breakdown of what to consider about Aleddra and other similar products, plus some general thoughts on this type of solution
Things to Consider About Aleddra (and similar integrated LED Backup Tubes):
Manufacturer Reputation and Reliability
Aleddra seems to have a decent online presence and claims to be a manufacturer of LED solutions.
Do your research
Look for independent reviews and testimonials. See if you can find any forum discussions or online reviews from electricians or building maintenance professionals who have used Aleddra products.
Check certifications
Make sure the product is UL-listed or has equivalent safety certifications. This is crucial for any electrical product, especially one with a battery component.
Specific Model Performance
Not all LED tubes are created equal. Pay attention to these specs:
Light Output (Lumens)
Ensure it provides sufficient light in emergency mode. Emergency lighting requirements are often specified by code.
Battery Life
The typical requirement is 90 minutes of emergency operation. Verify that the Aleddra tube meets this requirement.
Color Temperature (Kelvin)
Consider the desired color temperature for both normal and emergency operation. Consistency is usually preferred.
CRI (Color Rendering Index)
A higher CRI means colors will appear more natural. While not critical for emergency lighting, it's a factor in overall light quality.
Beam Angle
Wider beam angles usually result in more even light distribution.
Compatibility
Bypass Ballast (Direct Wire)
Most of these LED tubes require you to bypass the existing fluorescent ballast. This is generally a straightforward process, but it requires qualified electrical work. Make sure you or the installer understand the wiring diagrams.
Voltage
Ensure the tube is compatible with your voltage (typically 120V or 277V).
Installation
Ease of Installation
While bypassing the ballast simplifies some things, the installation still needs to be done correctly. Ensure the instructions are clear and easy to follow.
Professional Installation
Strongly recommended. This is electrical work and should be done by a qualified electrician.
Cost
Integrated LED backup tubes are generally more expensive than standard LED tubes and more expensive than replacing a standard fluorescent ballast. Factor in the potential savings from reduced maintenance and easier installation.
Warranty
A good warranty is essential. Pay attention to the length of the warranty and what it covers (both the LED components and the battery).
Battery Type and Replacement
Battery Chemistry
Lithium-ion batteries are common in these types of products. Understand the expected lifespan of the battery.
Replaceability
Can the battery be replaced when it reaches the end of its life? If so, how easy is it to do, and what is the cost of a replacement battery? If not, you'll need to replace the entire tube.
Code Compliance
Crucially important. Emergency lighting must comply with local building and fire codes. Ensure that the Aleddra tube (or any similar product) meets these codes. This is where working with a qualified electrician is essential.
Dimming compatibility
Check to see if the tube is dimmable, and if so what type of dimmer can be used (0-10V, etc.)
Pros of Integrated LED Backup Tubes
Simplified Installation (potentially)
Bypassing the ballast eliminates a common point of failure.
Reduced Maintenance
No more failing emergency ballasts to replace.
Cleaner Installation
Less clutter inside the troffer.
Energy Efficiency
LEDs are inherently more energy-efficient than fluorescent lamps.
Longer Lifespan
LEDs generally have a longer lifespan than fluorescent lamps.
Cons of Integrated LED Backup Tubes
Higher Initial Cost
The upfront cost is higher than standard LED tubes or emergency ballast replacement.
Battery Replacement
The integrated battery will eventually need replacement, which may require replacing the entire tube depending on the design.
Potential for Single Point of Failure
If the tube fails, you lose both normal and emergency lighting from that fixture.
Code Compliance
Ensuring compliance with local codes is crucial and requires careful consideration.
Alternatives to Consider
Dedicated LED Emergency Fixtures
Consider using dedicated LED emergency light fixtures in addition to or instead of the troffer lights. These are designed specifically for emergency lighting and often offer better performance and reliability.*
Central Battery System
For larger installations, a central battery system can power emergency lighting throughout the building. This is more expensive upfront but can offer long-term cost savings and improved reliability.
Recommendations
Consult with a Qualified Electrician
Before making any decisions, consult with a licensed and experienced electrician. They can assess your specific needs, evaluate the code requirements, and recommend the best solution for your application.2.
Request Samples
If possible, request a sample of the Aleddra tube (or other brands) to test in your application. This will allow you to evaluate the light output, color temperature, and overall performance.3.
Read Reviews and Testimonials
Look for independent reviews and testimonials from other users of the product.4.
Check Certifications and Compliance
Ensure that the product is UL-listed or has equivalent safety certifications and meets all applicable building and fire codes.5.
Carefully Evaluate the Warranty
Understand the terms of the warranty and what it covers.6.
Consider Long-Term Costs: Factor in the cost of battery replacement and potential maintenance when comparing different options.In conclusion, integrated LED backup tubes can be a good solution in some situations, but it's important to weigh the pros and cons carefully and ensure that the product meets your specific needs and code requirements. Thorough research and professional consultation are essential. Flag for review