User: Irving LaRue, Location: Warrenton, Virginia
Asked on: Thursday, October 16, 2025 at 7:13 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, October 16, 2025 at 7:17 pm EDT
Question: 4th year apprentice here. My first time attempting a junction box bigger than a 11B. It's a 24x24 box with 29 MC cables. 20 of those MC cables are 12-3.What are your thoughts? Any constructive criticism? Or just normal criticism? Or general hatred and disgust? I'm hoping to find a few things I could have done better, so don't hold back.A few things for me to note:Circuit colors don’t exactly match the numbers… not my design. I just played the hand I was dealt. Some of those numbers will change when we land the panel. We also had limited colors of MC cable ordered by our PM. Electrical tape on the side of the box is temporary as some of the circuit numbers will change.My foreman told me to use self tappers in the box for the ground bar because his tap kit. I'd have preferred to install it per design. There's also to 1/2' KOs that I'm going to fill when those come in our next order. It's a small project so we don't have everything on hand.In hindsight, I’d avoid the zip ties for ease of access in the future.
Okay, let's dive into this 24x24 box full of MC love. A box with 29 MC cables, 20 of them 12-3, is a serious undertaking. Here's a breakdown of my thoughts, categorized for easier digestion
Overall Impression:
It looks... functional. It's clear you're aiming for neatness and organization, which is commendable, especially on your first big box. It's not a complete horror show, which is a good start. It's a busy box, and that's going to be unavoidable with that many conductors. Managing that density is the real challenge.
Things You Did Well
Straight Runs
You've done a good job keeping the MC cables entering the box straight and not crossing over each other immediately. This is crucial for future access and troubleshooting.
MC Connector Placement
The layout of your MC connectors on the box is well-spaced and creates a good "spoke" arrangement around the box which minimizes crossover and helps to keep everything organized.
Conductor Length
You seem to have left enough length on the conductors to work with, which is far better than cutting them too short. A little extra is always appreciated.
Acknowledging Issues
You're aware of the problems (self-tappers, missing KOs, zip ties), which shows good self-awareness and a desire to improve. That's more than half the battle!
Areas for Improvement (Constructive Criticism)
Conductor Management and Organization
More Defined Bundles
Instead of one big clump of wires, try to group the conductors by circuit/function, even before they reach the terminals. This helps with troubleshooting and modifications later. Think: "All circuit #17 wires together," etc.
Spiral Wrap instead of Zip Ties
You already identified the zip tie issue, and spiral wrap or velcro straps are MUCH better choices for large wire bundles. They allow for additions, removals, and adjustments without cutting and re-tying. The spiral wrap also keeps the shape of the bundle round to allow for proper airflow/heat management.
Layering
Think about layering your conductors. Keep the grounds lower, neutrals in the middle, and hots on top (or whatever convention works for your design). This provides visual organization and makes tracing easier.
Keep the Conductor Bundles off of the MC Straps
Avoid securing the wire bundles too tightly to the MC straps. The goal is to guide the wires, not to cut into the wire insulation when the screw is tightened.
Grounding
Self-Tappers (Foreman's Choice)
You mentioned this, but the self-tappers are a concern. They might be code-compliant, but a properly tapped and screwed ground bar is ALWAYS a better and more reliable connection. Stand your ground (pun intended) and argue for the right way to do it if you can.
Ground Wire Management
Try to keep the ground wires organized and bundled neatly as well. Consider using a ring terminal on each ground wire before attaching it to the ground bar. It makes for a cleaner, more secure connection and makes it easier to remove a wire later without disturbing others.
MC Connector Selection
Consider Anti-Short Bushings Integrated Connectors
Many manufacturers make MC connectors with integrated anti-short bushings. While not required by code, they speed up the process by eliminating the need to install the anti-short bushing on the conductors of the MC Cable and reduce the number of loose parts in the box.
Labeling
More Detailed Labeling
Instead of just circuit numbers, consider labeling with destination information (e.g., "Lights - Zone 1," "Receptacles - Kitchen," "HVAC - Unit 3"). This will save you a lot of time later when troubleshooting.
Permanent Labeling
Once the panel is finalized, use a permanent labeling method (label maker, embossed labels) instead of tape. It looks more professional and is less likely to fall off over time.
Things to Keep in Mind
Working Space
Always be mindful of the working space inside the box. Ensure you have enough room to safely and effectively work on the connections without cramming things too tightly.
Heat Dissipation
With that many conductors, heat buildup can be a concern. Avoid creating extremely tight bundles that restrict airflow. Make sure your wire gauge is appropriate for the load, and consult with your foreman about any potential derating issues.
Code Compliance
Continuously double-check your work against the NEC and local codes. Pay special attention to box fill calculations and conductor bending radii.
General/Normal Criticism
It's a first attempt. It's not going to be perfect. Don't beat yourself up too much. Large junction boxes like this often become the "junk drawer" of a system. Wires get added and subtracted over time, and organization can degrade. So, future access and maintainability is key.
Hatred and Disgust
* None. You're learning, and you're asking the right questions. That's far better than someone who thinks they know everything and makes a mess.
In Summary
You're on the right track. Focus on better wire management (bundling, layering, spiral wrap/velcro), more robust grounding methods, and more detailed labeling. Keep learning, keep asking questions, and keep striving for excellence!
Final Tip: Take pictures of the box before you close it up. It can be a lifesaver later when trying to troubleshoot or modify the system.Good luck on the next one! You'll do even better! Flag for review