User: stew, Location: federal way,washington
Asked on: Thursday, October 16, 2025 at 11:34 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, October 16, 2025 at 11:35 pm EDT
Question: Been off the forum for a long while due to health issues. Back in the saddle again.Just did a large retrofit of 30 year old troffers.120 units.The technology has ran past this old fart. Does anyone know of an inexpensive way to dim these buggers. The normal way of course woukd be a driver on the first fixture of 6 in a room and low voltage wiring. With a retro and Mc feeds to all the switches it's a bugger. Any ideas besides 175 $ worth of parts? No real way to feed the low voltage. No emt. .only eat is the feed to the first j box in the array.
Welcome back! Sorry to hear about the health issues, but glad you're back in the game. Retrofitting existing spaces for dimming can be a real pain, especially with older wiring. Here are some ideas, keeping in mind "inexpensive" is relative and depends on your client's expectations and what you consider acceptable performance
Understanding the Challenges:
No Neutral at the Switch
This is a common problem with older installations and eliminates many smart dimmer options that require a neutral.
MC Cable
Makes it difficult to add low-voltage wiring for traditional dimming control.
Cost Sensitivity
$175/fixture is too high, so we need to explore alternatives.
Potential Solutions (Ordered from Least Expensive to Most)
"Triac" or "Leading Edge" Dimmers
Concept
These are the simplest type of dimmer and work by chopping the AC waveform. Some LED drivers are designed to work with them.
Pros
Can be relatively inexpensive, direct replacement for existing switches (if compatible with the LED driver).
Cons
Compatibility with LED drivers is a huge issue. Can cause flickering, buzzing, and reduced lifespan of the LEDs if not compatible. May have limited dimming range. Leading Edge dimmers also don't dim as well as a Lutron style dimmer.
Considerations
DRIVER COMPATIBILITY IS KEY. Contact the LED retrofit kit manufacturer and explicitly ask if their drivers are compatible with "Triac" or "Leading Edge" dimmers. Get a specific model number of a dimmer they recommend. TEST, TEST, TEST
Before committing to 120 units, buy one dimmer and test it with a couple of the retrofitted fixtures. Observe for flickering, buzzing, and dimming range.
Dimmer Type
Ensure you get a dimmer specifically designed for LED lighting.
Load Rating
Make sure the dimmer is rated for the total wattage of the LEDs connected to it.
Local Code Compliance
Make sure your dimmers are compliant with local codes.2.
"ELV" (Electronic Low Voltage) Dimmers
Concept
Similar to Triac dimmers, but designed to work with electronic loads. Often have better performance with LEDs than Triac dimmers.
Pros
Potentially better compatibility with LED drivers than Triac.
Cons
Still require driver compatibility. Can be slightly more expensive than Triac dimmers.
Considerations
Same considerations as Triac dimmers (compatibility, testing, load rating, code compliance). Again, driver compatibility is paramount.3.
Wireless Dimmers (No Neutral Required)
Concept
These dimmers use wireless communication (e.g., Bluetooth, Zigbee, Z-Wave) to control the lights, often through a hub or gateway.
Pros
No need to run new wires. Can often be controlled via a smartphone app.
Cons
Can be more expensive than simple dimmers. Requires a wireless network. Reliability can be an issue with some brands. Often needs an additional component to talk to the drivers or LEDs.
Considerations
Research
Look for systems that are specifically designed for commercial applications and have a good track record for reliability.
Driver Compatibility
Some systems require compatible drivers.
Coverage
Ensure the wireless signal has sufficient range to cover the entire area.
Complexity
Setup can be more complex than traditional dimmers.
Security
Be mindful of security implications when connecting lighting to a wireless network.
Examples
Lutron Caseta (check for commercial applications and driver compatibility)
While Lutron Caseta often gets recommended, it might not be the most cost-effective for 120 units.4.
Wireless Dimming Retrofit Kits
Concept
These are complete kits that include new LED modules and a wireless control system.
Pros
Guaranteed compatibility between the LEDs and the dimming system.
Cons
More expensive than just replacing the dimmers, but potentially cheaper than running new wiring. You're essentially doing another "retrofit" of the retrofit.
Considerations
Installation Costs
Factor in the cost of installing the new LED modules.
Long-Term Cost
Consider the long-term cost of maintenance and replacement.
Lighting Quality
Ensure the new LED modules provide adequate light output and color rendering.
Important Steps Before Making a Decision
DRIVER INFORMATION
Get the exact make and model number of the LED drivers in the retrofitted fixtures. This is absolutely critical.2.
MANUFACTURER COMMUNICATION
Contact the LED retrofit kit manufacturer and ask for their recommended dimming solutions. Get specific model numbers of compatible dimmers. If they don't have a recommendation, that's a red flag.3.
TESTING
Buy a sample dimmer (or a few different types) and test them with a few of the retrofitted fixtures before committing to a large order.4.
CHECK LOCAL CODES
Ensure any dimming solution you choose is compliant with local electrical codes.
Why the $175/fixture might be too high: You're likely thinking of a solution that involves replacing the drivers and running new wiring, which is expensive and labor-intensive. If the existing drivers are dimmable with a simpler solution (like a compatible Triac/ELV dimmer), you can save a significant amount of money.Good luck! Let me know if you have more details about the LED drivers, and I can try to offer more specific advice. Flag for review